The Bible and Science and Evangelism: A Boat Too Far and the Literality of the Biblical Stories?

I continue to do the work of an Evangelist; it is a challenge and gift of being a Christian that I thoroughly enjoy, and from which I draw personal telos or purpose in my ongoing adventure as a Christian person soli Deo gloria! One of my most recent contacts has an interesting brew (if I can say it like that) of beliefs about reality and his own personal purpose in this amazing complexity known as life. An aspect that seems to bother, this my interlocutor, is what appears to him to be an over-literal reading of, for one thing in the Bible, the Genesis account of human origins and the related stories therein—namely, and particularly troubling for my friend, the story of Noah and the Ark. He cannot even begin to fathom how any rational (vs. rationalist) person could suppose to believe that any modernly informed person could take this literal—he seems to think that this is not physically possible (see how Ken Ham seeks to answer this apparent conundrum here, this seems to be a very reasonable explanation—proviso, I am not generally a fan of Ken Ham). I would like to expand this conversation out a bit, for my friend, myself, and anyone else who is reading; and I will do this by drawing our attention to a recently released book by Brazos Press entitled: Evolution of Adam, The: What the Bible Does and Doesn’t Say about Human Origins by Peter Enns.  Here is how Enns describes some of his gist in this book:

And here is how Sandra Collins of Library Journal synopsizes the general themes of the book:

“[Enns’s] basic argument is this: modern creation arguments that focus on either the literal historical truth of the Bible or evolutionary perspectives are wrong. The Bible, including its creation accounts, represents a comprehensive theological worldview. It’s neither a literal accounting nor is it science. And it was never intended to be either of these two things. . . . Academically minded Christians looking to bridge this intellectual divide will appreciate the tone and bibliographic references here.”

I have once written on this topic here; and my thesis, taken from former seminary professor Al Bayliss, sound very similar to the way that Collins describes Enns’ primary theses in his book. Yet, my sense is that my conclusions will probably end up differently than Enns; my conclusion would be informed by the idea that a ‘theological worldview’ and ‘literal reality’ correlate with each other. That there is a ratio that  inheres between the rational (and literal) uncreated reality of God, and that which has been given expression in the contingent, and ordered reality of creation itself; so created order and rationality is given its rationality by definition of its contingence upon God’s rationality that he built into creation through Divine fiat. My point, I can’t follow this dualism, that is often posited, between theological reality and created reality; if for no other reason, but because we have these two realities in the conjoined hypostatic union of the Non-contingent/contingent reality of the Divine/human in the person of Jesus Christ—or that I see all of reality conditioned by the primacy of this kind of ‘unioned’ life. I am digressing a wee bit.

So this issue of origins, and the literal nature of the Genesis account, in particular, and for my friend; the literal nature of Biblical accounting in general continues to be an ongoing issue. Enns’ latest book and the work of the foundation of which he is an integral part, Biologos, illustrates the ongoingness of this continued struggle (or not) between modern science and modern biblical and theological studies—in fact Brian LePort, a blogger here in Portland, Oregon has just recently posted on a very related question here.

I write all of the foregoing to come up against the question that prompted me to write this in the first place; do you think that evolution, one way or the other, should be an issue that hinders or in fact fosters the ‘intellectual’ space for someone to have the room to entertain a belief in Jesus Christ as the historic orthodox person of Christian proclamation? In other words, if evolution (neo-Darwinian) stands in the way, intellectually (whatever that means, theologically), of someone being able to give a hearing to Jesus, do you think we should be softer on this issue and allow for the fact that it is possible to both affirm modern scientific theories and claims, and the claims of Jesus Christ? I know of plenty of believing Christians (like Peter Enns, or even my beloved T.F. Torrance) who believe in macro-evolution, and also are thoroughgoing Christians—I shared this, briefly with my friend, I think he was encouraged by this.

Anyway, what do you think?

The Special Nature of Scripture, is only Special, First, Because of Jesus: The Order

Let me quote a friend of mine, Darren Sumner (a PhD student at Aberdeen, almost done) on Karl Barth’s understanding of Scripture—I will be getting into what Darren is sketching further, as I provide some quotes and reflection from T.F. Torrance on Scripture and its humanity later today — all of this is in continued response to a friend whom I work with, who still seems quite skeptical about the Special witness of Scripture amongst the range that a pluralistic world and society and cultures provide relative to other books that claim to be Holy … so his concern continues to be, ‘okay, but what makes the Christian Bible most holy, or exclusively holy?’; and of course my answer has to do with what Sumner highlights below—relative to Barth’s view and usage of Scripture—that is, the centrality that Jesus Christ is to the whole of Scripture. As Carl Henry underscored for us the other day, Jesus himself and his personal view of Scripture ought to be determinative for how others (Christians and non-Christians alike) seek to understand and engage the authority and formative role of Scripture. So the problem for the higher critic or plain old non-believing person is not ultimately with the Special nature of Scripture, but instead; it is with the Special reality of the personal-work of Jesus Christ—who is the reality of Scripture’s witness. So this ultimately becomes an issue of first order V. second order consideration; Jesus and who he is is of first order importance, if you reject who he is, then it will only make sense that you will reject the second order and derivative specialty of Scripture—sense Scripture, for the Christian, is not an self-enclosed book of aphorisms and ‘historicisms’, but instead it is a book that like John Calvin’s spectacles is opened up towards it reality, Jesus Christ. So my friend from work (who is reading this 😉 ), we need to talk about something even that much more basic and fundamental; that is your rejection of Jesus as the Self-revealing, Self-interpreting personal loving gracious God who became fully man (and remained fully God) in the man from Nazareth, Jesus Christ. Our discussions are always, at least from me, going to be conditioned by this central reality. Without further ado then, let us hear from Darren on Barth’s view of Scripture; and then later today or tomorrow I will follow with some dovetailing (and even a bit more pointed for my friend) comments from Scottish born (and student of Karl Barth) theologian Thomas Forsyth Torrance. Sumner writes:

[B]arth is often criticized for having a low view of the nature of Scripture — that it is “mere” witness to God’s revelation, and not revelatory itself. (See this post for a bit more on this topic.) What we see here is that Barth’s view of the function of Scripture (read: its authority for believers) is, in fact, quite high. From its sermons and teachings to its theology, from its worship to its sacramental practice and its mission in the world, the church stands under the authority of Holy Scripture. It cannot do an end-run around the Bible and appeal to Jesus Christ or the Holy Spirit in any form other than the one in which they present themselves to us.

But the church’s speech, including its historic creeds, is derivative of this.  In short, the church only speaks truth in the formulation of dogma insofar as it is faithfully explicating the Word of God in Scripture. The standard by which the rightness of doctrine — or “orthodoxy” — is to be measured is ultimately not the creeds but the Scripture to which they point. This was the view of the Reformers. The creeds and confessions of the tradition do play a regulative role, of course, but this role is largely sociological. [Darren O. Sumner, see full post here]

So this is rather self authenticating, which is the point, about the nature of Scripture. This doesn’t get into what has been called ‘Text, Canon, & Transmission’ issues of Holy Scripture, but it does get us to the premise from which those issues (of Scriptural formation) ought to be understood; again, that is relative to the central role that Jesus Christ himself has as the ground upon which these other issues of canonization take their tenor and form. Without Jesus taking up the Old Testament promises as their New Testament fulfillment, and without his self-conscious understanding of all of this; the Scriptures we have today would never have taken shape or form, there would have been no Church and no Apostolic witness to give something form in the first place. In other words, the Church and Scriptures must of necessity presuppose upon the fact that Jesus is & was both their author and finisher. So my friend from work 🙂 … we are going to have to talk more about Jesus before we can talk about canon. If you’re concern is that we wouldn’t have Jesus without the canon of Scripture, as I just noted, that would be to fail to recognize the proper order that must be present in order for the conditions of the canonization of the Scriptures to be present in the first place. So there is a self-authenticating sense to the formation of the Scriptures, but only insofar as that self-authenticity is given its reality through its special witness bearing capacity towards its subject matter; that is the person of Jesus Christ. More to come …

The Problem of Sin and the Last Word, The Death of Death

I don’t know about you, but I grow weary of sin; I (we) face an ongoing battle every breath that we take. Whether it be perverse thoughts, dark deep secrets that plague the conscience, actions that result in destruction for you and all those related to you, systemic evil that permeates the very fabric of society (this is probably most insidious since we are conditioned by it in ways that give it a normalcy and thus societal and then personal acceptance); the Apostle can relate,

23But I see another law in my members, warring against the law of my mind, and bringing me into captivity to the law of sin which is in my members. 24O wretched man that I am! who shall deliver me from the body of this death? Romans 7:23, 24

We battle on. But how do we know what we battle; how do we gauge the target, how do we even know that there is a target to hit? How do we realize that evil isn’t some just mysterious lurking principle ‘out there’ that ultimately is outside of me, and not something that actually implicates my very being to its deepest depths—even when I engage in the evil ‘out there’ occasionally or situationally? How do I know, even if I can index concrete and ongoing instantiations of evil ‘out there, that the evil is indeed me? And that this all encompassing wickedness and deprivation consumes my inner self, which organically shapes my outer self—since really ourselves (body/soul) are integrated wholes. In other words, I am sin to the depths, and the reason there is sin, evil, wickedness ‘out there’; it is mostly because it has a context ‘in here’, in me. But how can I say such things, how can I ground such assertions beyond some sort of psychological intuition? We know that we are blind when the impression of light intensifies our darkness; when Jesus acts the way he does, and did, we know we are indeed blind. We come to the realization that for all our good, for all our posturing toward ourselves; that the next to the last word is that we live in a state of No, or blindness to the fact that what we see the Apostle Paul giving voice to can only come when faced with the depth of our problem as we participate in the life of Christ. The One who took our No, our blindness, and indeed our sin unto himself ‘by becoming sin for us that we might become the righteousness of God in him’ (II Cor. 5:21). As Calvin so perceptively knew, we only truly have knowledge of ourselves (and our abysmal state), when we first have knowledge of God through Christ, God the Redeemer.

It is this that John Webster masterfully elucidates as he engages Karl Barth’s vision of a christologically conditioned knowledge of sin in its most depth dimension. Let me quote Webster, who is commenting on Barth’s Church Dogmatics & Ethics, and the moral anthropology embedded therein:

[B]arth’s Christological determination of sin is not so much an attempt to dislocate ‘theological’ from ’empirical’ reality, as an argument born of a sense that human persons are characteristically self-deceived. Human life is a sphere in which fantasy operates, in which human persons are not able to see themselves as they truly are. The ‘man of sin’

thinks he sits on a high throne, but in reality he sits only on a child’s stool, cracking his little whip, pointing with frightful seriousness his little finger, while all the time nothing happens that really matters. He can only play the judge. He is only a dilettante, a blunderer, in his attempt to distinguish between good and evil, right and wrong, acting as though he really had the capacity to do it. He can only pretend to himself and others that he has the capacity and that there is any real significance in his judging. (CD IV/1, p. 446.)

This theme of concealment surfaces frequently in paragraph 60 (and elsewhere). Believing ourselves to see clearly, even allowing ourselves to suppose our sight to be sharper than that of our fellows, we are blind to the reality of our own selves. Barth acutely perceives that moral earnestness frequently rests upon clouded vision and lack of self-awareness and self-distrust. And so, once again, we return to the Christological basis for the treatment of human sin: ‘Compared with Him we stand there in all our corruption … The untruth in which we are men is disclosed … We are forced to see and know ourselves in the loathsomeness in which we find ourselves exposed and known.’

Human sinfulness, then, entails an ability to disentangle ourselves from our acts in such a way that they are no longer really ours. As Barth puts it in a passage in Church Dogmatics IV/2, we allow ourselves to believe that:

The sinful act is regrettable but external, incidental and isolated failure and defect; a misfortune, comparable to one of the passing sicknesses in which a healthy organism remains healthy and to which it shows itself to be more than equal. On this view, the individual — I myself — cannot really be affected by the evil action. I do not have any direct part in its loathsome and offensive character. In the last resort it has taken place in my absence. I myself am elsewhere and aloof from it. And from this neutral place which is my real home, I can survey and evaluate the evil that has happened to me in its involvement with other less evil and perhaps even good motives and elements; in its not absolutely harmful but to some extent positive effects; in its relationship to my other much less doubtful and perhaps even praiseworthy achievements; and especially in my relationship to what I see other men do or not do (a comparison in which I may not come out too badly); in short, in a relativity in which I am not really affected at bottom. I may acknowledge and regret that I have sinned, but I do not need to confess that I am a sinner.  (CD IV/2, p. 394)

These clarifications of the forms of human self-deception (which are by no means intended to underrate the ambiguity of the moral situation) are an important background to Barth’s treatment of original sin. His objection to some formulations of that doctrine is, at heart, that they are deficient in their account of positive evil. And his refusal of an independent locus peccati, his rejection of anything other than a Christologically determined account of sin, is directed by precisely the same concern. Far from averting attention from evil as fact, Christology is intended to furnish a means of clarifying our vision and dissolving our illusions about our own moral integrity. [John Webster, Barth’s Moral Theology: Human Action in Barth’s Thought, 69-70.]

The Apostle Paul concurs with this kind of assessment about the deleterious effects of sin upon a life that knows that it only knows its true state of affairs because of the One who finally has given the last word  to our No-being by his Yes to the Father for us—viz. a Yes that is given concrete form through his death, burial, and most importantly resurrection-ascension. The Apostle Paul, with his eyes wide open, as we noted earlier, gives a final sigh of relief when he writes:

 25I thank God through Jesus Christ our Lord. So then with the mind I myself serve the law of God; but with the flesh the law of sin. Romans 7:25

The Apostle knew, that he knew sin, not ultimately because of the Law; but ultimately, because of Christ who penetrated deeper than the Law could on its own—viz. into the cavernous depths of the human soul which left to itself continues to look at evil and wickedness as if its ‘out there’, while all along failing to realize that they’ve never even seen sin and evil and wickedness in its most grotesque form; that’s because they’ve never presumed that maybe, just maybe the most insidious form of evil, in the end, dwells where they can’t peer, where they dare not, in themselves.

§1. Matt Chandler’s Calvinism Given Historical and Theological Background … Choose You This Day!

Okay, here we go. I am going to get into this issue, this way; i.e. by having you all watch this video interview with Matt Chandler done by John Piper. My point in sharing this video is not to use it as a piece that I critique materially; instead, I want what Chandler says to take up residence in your heart and mind so that you will be able to recall this as a reference point for some of the things I will be getting at later. What I mean is this; Matt Chandler says something very explicitly and up front that I’ve known to be true for along time, but I am afraid that many who listen to, not just Matt Chandler, but many others in his tribe, are failing to realize that the informing theology behind what Chandler & co. communicate to the masses is plain old 5 point Calvinism. Now, some folk are totally fine with this, but other folk didn’t realize this to be the case (until now); and so my motive is to expose where Chandler and The Gospel Coalition are coming from, and then offer an alternative way to approach scripture through a better Christian grammar and theological grid. Watch the video, please spend the time to do that, and then I will close this video with some brief reflections and set myself up for further posts.

Click Here: John Piper Interviews Matt Chandler on Calvinism.

One thing I don’t want this to turn into is another slam-fest on 5 point Calvinism; I want to take us somewhat deeper than that. I want to take us into the Holy of holies, or into God’s life; since this is where it all goes wrong for a 5 point Calvinist (which I will establish in posts to come). This is, as you heard Chandler mention in the interview, where a need for a God with two wills comes into the picture. Let me just assert right now, if you have a god with two wills you don’t have the God of the Bible revealed in Jesus Christ! And if you don’t have the God of the Bible Self-revealed in Jesus Christ; then you don’t have the full bodied version of the Gospel.

Just be prepared to have your thinking piqued, and maybe your beliefs challenged (which I hope is what happens if you appreciate or are a follower of Matt Chandler’s teaching). Just pray that I communicate in a fair, firm, and then loving way…. thank you!

My Reflections on Grace and Human Freedom

I have been having an ongoing discussion with two brothers; Nathan (a guy I went to Bible College with, and we both went to the same Seminary too), and then Kc, a dear brother who I have gotten to know over the years through blogging (like so many of you!). We have been discussing what free will, so called, entails (if there is even such a thing, or if this is the best lingo to describe it); and then this has also, now led us to a discussion of God’s grace and what in fact that might involve. I spent some time today, while at work, on my breaks in our little computer lab punching out a few responses to Kc and Nathan. I thought, since I am exceedingly tired, that I would reproduce those as a post here; to see if they might garner further feedback, or maybe they might serve helpful to someone out there in the great wide world of the blogosphere. The first response has to do with ‘human freedom’, and how that relates to our ‘choice’. The second is in direct response to Kc, and how he views God’s grace versus what he perceives of my view of grace (also, the last paragraph is in response to how I think Kc perceives Torrance’s concept of sin and salvation and sins continued (or not) effects in the believer’s life).

Response to Nathan on my view of what human freedom means and where it comes from.

God alone is the only free non-contingent self-determined being simpliciter; thus, if creation can be said to be ‘free’ (or have ‘free desires’) it can only be in a contingent way as it participates from the only kind of freedom available (from and thus for God). So creation’s freedom (while having an independent integrity of its own as creation) is a contingent freedom, and it is only ever truly freedom when it finds its terminus in God’s life of freedom for the other (which is is how I would describe God’s self given being, as subject-in-being or onto-relational). So whom the Son sets free is free indeed; free for God. There is only freedom of desires when our hearts of stone have been replaced (recreated) through Christ’s heart of flesh which we participate from as we are joined to his humanity by the Spirit. There is no other alternative way to speak about human freedom, theologically. (surely we can speculate and make inferences from our human intuition, but this is foundationalist methodology that imposes an abstracted aparatus upon God’s Self-revelation as it reasons from its own being to God’s or the analogia entis or analogy of being; which my personal chapter in our book is on, and which I reject, methodologically … I follow something like Barth’s analogy of faith and/or TFT’s).

Unless, we want to set up a competitive relation between the God-world Creator-creature relation; we will not posit an ontological category of desire or freedom that is not first grounded in God’s desire or freedom for us; as mediated through the homoousios life of the Son, our high priest, our mediator between God and man, the man Christ Jesus. This is how I view freedom, and anthropology, Nathan; as participationist.  To me, all other discussion of human freedom and desire is non-sensical as it arises from a position that is non-being or nothing.

Response to Kc on my view of God’s grace as personal (I am going to quote Kc’s distinction that he makes between mine and his view of grace as the jumping off point for my response back to him).

Kc writes: “Where Bobby would say that grace is a person, Jesus Christ, I would say the grace of God that brings salvation is the revelation of Jesus Christ.”

But ultimately, at least theo-logically there is a problem here that I think you would rather avoid, Kc. When you say that the ‘grace of God that brings salvation’ you make Jesus Christ the predicate of a quality or ‘attribute’ known as grace, of which grace is now the subject. To think through these terms is no different than how a classic Calvinist or Arminian thinks of the decrees as the intermediary created realities through which God interacts with creation. This is to place creation prior to God, in an order of being; and thus in the incarnation of Christ, he is meeting the conditions of ‘grace’ (whatever those are) and thus becomes only the instrument of “God’s grace,” instead of grace himself, in his act toward/for us. So this places a rupture in God’s life, and subordinates the Son to the Father (which in Church history is consider a heresy).

I want to think of grace as God’s personal act for us in himself (antecedently), and temporally made manifest in the incarnation of the Son. So I see God’s covenant life of grace preceding creation instead of following it. This emphasizes the primacy of Christ over all creation as its purpose (Col. 1.15ff). So we can then think of God’s purpose in creation as always already mediated through the Son who in Colossians 1 is called the icon or image of God. So to think from protology (first things) to eschatology (last things), if the eternal Son is the image of God, humanity was originally created in the Son’s image; and yet, this was not all that God had in store for creation (i.e. protology), since his life is eschatological. So given the ‘Fall’ humanity was ripped asunder from God’s image in his Son and from his being, into non-being. Yet humanity was kept/covered (Rom. 3:25) and suspended by God’s grace in his ongoing being for us in his Son. It was this being, the image of God, that incarnated for us, died, buried, and rose again through which we have been re-created; so now we have become mirrors of the mirror of God’s image (and exact representation Heb 1.3) in the (imago Christi) ‘image of Christ’. This is God’s grace, it is his person, in Christ for us reconciling us back to union with God through Christ; but back to something much greater, back through the mediator and point and purpose of all creation; through Jesus Christ, and it is in his eschatological life that our lives have purpose as we participate in him by the grace of his humiliating act of in-humaning.

Further, I do not hold to a form of perfectionism; that misunderstands TFT’s point. Instead, while the life of Christ is stable and perfect, and it is this kind of life that we participate in; we are still in the now aspect of the not yet coming consummate form of the kingdom. And it is this coming kingdom in Christ that breaks in on us anew and afresh every morning through which we have the power to reckon ourselves dead to sin and alive to and through Christ. This is the point of TFT’s ontological theory of the atonement; Christ penetrates into the depth of our sinful lives and hearts, and redeems us from the inside out. Starting in his crib, penultimately at the cross, burial, resurrection and ascension; and ultimately at the consummation of all things at his second advent when he makes all things new in fully realized form. This is when the protology of God’s life will be ‘fully’ known in eschatological form; the form that has always shaped even the ‘first things of God’s life’ in his gracious act of original creation (gracious because he, according to his outward othered focused life he choose to create a counterpoint that he might love us in the Son, the point of the creation).

**All of the above comes from my reading, of course, of many theologians and Scripture; primarily: Athanasius, Barth, TF Torrance, John Webster, and mostly, Myk Habets. It must be obvious that I just jotted these little replies rather quickly and off the top, but I hope they give you some further insight into my thinking on such things. I think it is probably quite obvious to some—and no surprise—that my thinking on such things is very much so what can be called Torrancean, and clearly Habetsian … but I like to think that these things have an impress of my own upon them as well. Now let me have it …

Travis’ Updated Blog: From ‘Der Evangelische Theologe’ to ‘Die Evangelischen Theologen’

My friend, Travis McMaken, recent PhD graduate of the infamous Princeton Theological Seminary, and newly minted Barth scholar has re-created (which is what Barthians and Torranceans are into, re-creation) his blog from the one to the many (another Barthian and Torrancean emphasis … so this move makes sense, from being to becoming); he has changed his blog from his sole proprietorship, into a consolidated form that now includes a few others. You will have to check it out! Here’s what Travis wrote of the new direction at his blog:

Attentive readers may have noticed that there’s something different about DET. Indeed, there is something very different. For DET has transformed from “Der Evangelische Theologe” to “Die Evangelischen Theologen.”

You may ask, Why the change?

While I was in Princeton to defend my dissertation, circumstances and conversations lead me to reminisce about the “good ol’ days” of theo-blogging and the current decline in the practice. Put simply, all the old theo-blogs that were my fellow travelers have ground to a halt and – indeed – my own work here at DET has slowed considerably under the strain of assuming the rigorous responsibilities of full time academic teaching. . . . Rather than remaining only my personal blog, I have invited a number of theological students from various stages of their academic careers to join me here in a communal endeavor to foster theological community through blogging. You can read about these intrepid individuals on the new Contributors page in the top menu. You may also read more about this renewed vision for DET in the new About page, also accessible in the top menu.

I encourage you to head on over! Here’s the link Die Evangelischen Theologen, or you can always find this in my sidebar/blogroll.

Culture Wars: Creation, Evolution, and Intelligent Design … Continue

In the past I would have been known as a hard Intelligent Design advocate, now I could probably be identified as either a soft ID advocate, or even somewhat indifferent (but I will say that I do have problems with the assumptions of a neo-Darwinian conception of macro-evolution, grounded in metaphysical materialism, as it is). This issue of Creationism/Biblicism V. Evolution/Science continues to fuel the culture wars in America at fevered tempatures, in certain tribes that is. My indifference on the topic is probably related more to the fact that I am worn out, at this point, in arguing about it; and the fact that I just don’t pay that much attention to it anymore. David Fergusson, Scottish Theologian at New College, Edinburgh (TF Torrance’s school) writes this:

Recent cultural conflict has been generated, particularly in the USA, by attempts to present Genesis 1—2 as offering an alternative cosmology to that of the modern scientifc world view. Instead of galaxies, planets, and life forms emerging from a violent explosion from a point of infinite density around twelve billion years ago, ‘creation science’ has attempted to maintain a ‘young universe’ only thousands of years old (Frye 1993). While allowing for some changes that are attributed to the effects of the flood, the world is perceived as created in much the same condition as we observe it today. The intellectual impossibility of this movement is evident from its attempt to challenge not merely biological evolution but the confirmed theories of other well-established scientific disciplines, including cosmology, astronomy, physcis, geology, and palaeontology. From the theologian’s perspective, it is an unnecessary fight to pick for the reasons outlined above. As Steve Jones, the distinguished geneticist, has often said, the conflict between science and religion resembles a fight between a tiger and a shark. Each will prevail on its own proper territory, but it will be hopelessly defeated by encroaching on the domain of the other. [David Fergusson, The Oxford Handbook of Systematic Theology: Chapter 4, Creation, 74]

When push comes to shove, I think my ‘ID’ sensibilities are still present. There is too much of a quid pro quo[ness] to this whole game sometimes—i.e. if the theologian will scratch the scientist’s back, the scientist will scratch the theologian’s back, or vice versa, etc. ID has been collapsed into creationism, when in fact ID is clearly not creationism, as it seeks to offer an active working scientific model (like Dembski’s ‘specified complexity’ etc.). I think there is more to this than Fergusson lets on. Someone no less than famed atheist of the 20th century, Antony Flew, converted to theism (no small feat), in no small part to the arguments presented by Intelligent Design scientists—clearly this is circumstantial, and not an argument for ID; but it helps to illustrate the kind of force that ID has to offer, to the point of helping clear the intellectual and evidentiary hurddles that heretofore had prevented an antagonistic atheist like Flew to reject his life’s work, to state that he was now a convinced theist.

Anyway, this is something that, ultimately, I don’t think Christians need to divide over (I mean fellowship); but it is something we can disagree over. I don’t think Fergusson and those like him have considered that there are actually quite a few reputable scientists who have rejected neo-Darwinianism in favor of ID. Alas, the public smear campaign has by and large worked to relegate ID to the quagmire of so called ‘Creation Science’.

This is one thing that I actually disagree with TF Torrance on; TFT would have been in the Fergusson camp. Or more to the point, Fergusson is actually in TFT’s camp on this.

What do you think?

What Do You Think About My Reply on Karl Barth and Human Freedom?

I have been over at Brian LePort’s blog Near Emmaus engaging with him on questions about Jesus, sin, free will and the like. Since I don’t have the proper time to devote to this, I provided some quotes from TF Torrance and Karl Barth that I have posted in the past here at the blog. Brian asked for further clarification on what Barth meant about ‘human freedom’ in this quote:

[T]he perfection of God’s giving of himself to man in the person of Jesus Christ consists in the fact that far from merely playing with man, far from merely moving or using him, far from dealing with him as an object, this self giving sets man up as a subject, awakens him to genuine individuality and autonomy, frees him, makes him a king, so that in his rule the kingly rule of God himself attains form and revelation. How can there be any possible rivalry here, let alone usurpation? How can there be any conflict between theonomy and autonomy? How can God be jealous or man self assertive? (CD I I/2, p. 179)

Genuine freedom as it is realized in Jesus is not a freedom from God but a freedom for God (and, with that, a freedom for other human beings). ‘ To the creature God determined, therefore, to give an individuality an autonomy, not that these gifts should be possessed outside Him, let alone against Him, but for him and within his kingdom; not in rivalry with his sovereignty but for its confirming and glorifying’ (CD I I/2, p. 178).

Here is how I just tried to answer Brian’s question on Barth:

I think “freedom for God” simply presumes that all things have been opened up toward God through Christ’s choice on behalf of humanity. In other words, to be free means to live from the freedom that God has imbued upon creation; a freedom that only finds register in him. From what I know of Barth, what he is getting at is that genuine human freedom is only actualised through the freedom of becoming where humanities’ raison d’être terminates; viz. in the freedom that God has in his own life. So to have an autonomous human freedom, means to be opened up to what God’s intention for human freedom has always already been; a freedom that participates in the freedom that God has in and for himself, and then for us in the telos (Col 1) of recreation, in Christ. So what it truly means to be human can only be realized in Christ’s humanity for us (for Barth and TFT); and what it means to be truly human, and becoming, is to be opened up to God as participants in his life. I think the binary of this, for Barth (and I know TFT) is not a legitimate category for consideration; and I mean the negative questions that classic free will questions presuppose. Like logical-causal (cause and effect) questions; like ‘if humanity is now opened up to God in Christ, and this signifies an autonomous human freedom; then why don’t all people actualise this freedom by responding to God in faith and belief?’ I don’t think these kinds of metaphysically causal questions are credible questions for either Barth or TFT, because they are the kinds of questions that are imposed upon God, and thus are not the kind demanded from God’s Self-revelation of himself in Christ. So, that’s why I would say that both Barth and TFT’s approach to questions like this are principally Christian; and why other ways of getting at these kinds of questions are classically Christian (the ‘classically’ playing to the force that classical theism [the synthesis of Thomism or Aristotelianism or even Scotism with Christian Theology] has upon the methodology and metaphysics of classically Christian questions). [This is a little more constructive than simply answering how Barth would answer this, but I think it is proximate with the ethos of what Barth might say]

To all you Barth scholars out there; what do you think, do you think that my reply to Brian is adequate, or do you think that I have taken too much constructive license? If anything I did a voice over with Torrance over Barth a bit.

What is Theology? And Why You Should Care …

What is theology? Literally Theo=God & Ology=Study; so it is the Study of God, in case you didn’t know. One of the things about theology, that I think some misunderstand—and why for some there is a dichotomy placed between it and biblical studies—is because some seem to think that theology, as its own sub-discipline, tends to, if not overtly engages in ‘creative’ thinking about God and what the Bible teaches. Creative, not simply meaning constructive, but creative in a way that theology (even ‘good’ theology) ends up going beyond the logic of scripture, and thus engages in fanciful thinking that does not help but hampers in the process of knowing God, and knowing the Scriptures. And so many—pastor and lay person alike—leave theology for the Theologian, and they simply think that they will take the more noble path of simply studying the Bible. Of course, and this is what I am trying to clarify through this post; good theology, which should be creative, constructive, and christocentric, simply is seeking to provide a grammar for speaking about what the ‘inner-logic’ of scripture demands for the thinking Christian. In other words, it indeed is a false dichotomy to play biblical studies/exegesis off against the doing of theology. And yet we see folks majoring in one of these two areas to the neglect of the other. I am not saying that someone can’t or shouldn’t be a Hebrew scholar or a Systematic Theology; all I am saying is that these are complementing realities. And thus, it would do the Old Testament Scholar, the New Testament Scholar, and the Systematic Theologian well to take the time to spend time in all three of these sub-disciplines; to one degree or the other. And it would do pastors and lay people good to equally do the same; i.e. to study all of these areas, to one degree or the other (which is rather subjective). But it doesn’t do anyone any good to assume that can be a straight biblical studies guy or gal, and not a systematic theology guy or gal; all this will mean is that this kind of biblical studies guy or gal will most probably engage in bad theological method and form. And the same is true vice versa.

So why am I writing this? Because I just wanted to clarify that theology is inextricably related to biblical studies. And in fact, when someone does biblical exegesis, ultimately they are doing theological exegesis (even if they simply follow something like the LGH or do lexical analysis or word studies). I say this because the scriptures demand this, since they presuppose theological realities in order to communicate the things they do; like about God (so the Trinity, etc.). Theology is simply providing a grammar and a creative way to talk and think about the God of the Bible from the Bible’s own witness to the God of the Bible revealed in Christ.

The Philosopher’s Theology, and Calvinism

I am writing a review for this book right now, for the Pacific Journal of Baptist Research; I should be done with the review by tomorrow. But I thought I would throw something up here from the book for your consideration. Michael Rea writes:

The methodological divide between systematic theologians and analytic philosophers of religion is ripe for exploration. It is of obvious theoretical importance to both disciplines, but it also has practical import. The climate in theology departments for analytic theologians is muck like the climate in English-speaking philosophy departments for continental philosophers: often chilly. Moreover, the methodological divide is surely the most significant obstacle to fruitful interdisciplinary dialogue. The problem isn’t just that academics with different methodological perspectives have trouble conversing with one another. Rather, it is that, by and large, the established figures in both disciplines don’t even view mutual conversation as worth pursuing. They ignore one another. They (implicitly or explicitly) encourage their students to ignore one another. They allow their methodological preferences to play a very large role int their judgments about hiring and about the quality of papers they referee for professional journals. And the divide only grows deeper. No doubt many (on both sides) will thin that all of this is perfectly legitimate. Maybe it is, but that is beside the point; its legitimacy shouldn’t just be taken for granted. It is an open and interesting question whether theology can sensibly be done in the analytic mode. [Michael C. Rea in Analytic Theology: New Essays in the Philosophy of Theology, edited by Oliver D. Crisp and Michael C. Rea, 2]

For some of you you could care less about what appears to be cutting the bologna way too thin. But I assure you this represents a substantial issue with real life fall-out (which I understand personally). The divide that Rea is speaking about represents a substantial methodological difference between how folk “do” theology. The difference is the difference between starting with Christ, in principle (principially) and methodologically (which is the method I follow); or starting with generic philosophical abstractions about nature and the god of nature, and from this set of principles working toward God and Christ. This divide works its way out, finally, to the issue that I am often harping on here at the blog; the distinction that I often draw between classical Calvinism and Evangelical Calvinism—viz. the disparate doctrines of God, for example (do we have a substance metaphysic [classic Calvinism] or a [onto] relational metaphysic [Evangelical Calvinism] shaping how we conceive of God and all the subsequent doctrines that follow? etc.).

I realize that I moving fast, from one thing to the other; but I want to illustrate how this “divide” that Rea is speaking about can play out THEOLOGICALLY.