Sometimes as theologians, exegetes, theobloggers and bibliobloggers; I think it is quite easy to get sucked into the game of it all, and forget that who we are claiming to talk about all the time is actually a Who, and is paying attention to what we say (see Malachi 3.16). Even for those of us who want to construct theological grammars that are attuned to the personalist, triune, and loving nature of our God. It is all too easy to slip into modes of communication and thinking about God that allow us to talk about Him, instead of to Him (as we “theologize”). It is as if somehow we have distantiated ourselves from the very one we claim to worship. I realize that this is part of the task of being a professional (or even amateur) theologian, but then I wonder; “should it be?” If we are so engaged in providing structure for the Church to talk about God through, and then fail to actually talk to the God we are supposedly talking about all the time; can we really claim to be even talking about Him? I know that some people place concerns like mine into the category of piety (and even pietism). But really, that seems to me to be an rather artficial category that theologians have invented in order to continue in a type of what has been called a theology of glory; where the theologian can continue to supposedly talkย about God in the public square, and presumptively talk to this same God on his/her own in their private square. But again, this seems problematic to me. Surely the theologian wants to be able to provide precise, cogent, somewhat coherent talk about God; and that this requires (I suppose) a modicum of dispassionate analysis and articulation. Yet, what if this vocation becomes all consuming; what if vocation becomes removed from evocation with the Lord whom they claim to speak for? This is always a concern for me, and I wonder if it is one for you too? That is, does it concern you that you might only be a wind-chime blowing in the wind?
Category Archives: Theology
I am most like Karl Barth, then John Calvin
I just took a quiz that tells you which theologian you are most like, the following are the results. You can take it here.
You Scored as Karl BarthThe daddy of 20th Century theology. You perceive liberal theology to be a disaster and so you insist that the revelation of Christ, not human experience, should be the starting point for all theology.
| Karl Barth |
|
100% |
| John Calvin |
|
100% |
| Jonathan Edwards |
|
73% |
| Martin Luther |
|
67% |
| Anselm |
|
60% |
| Friedrich Schleiermacher |
|
33% |
| Augustine |
|
33% |
| Jรผrgen Moltmann |
|
33% |
| Paul Tillich |
|
33% |
| Charles Finney |
|
20% |
"Can't We All Get Along? Nope!" Those crazy classic calvinists and arminians at it again . . .
I was alerted to a post by my Minders ๐ over at Parchment & Pen Blog. Sam Storms wrote a post articulating the exhausting and tired old fodder that makes up the usual discussion surrounding who God is and thus what
salvation looks like from a Classic Calvinist perspective. Predictably the status quo debate has now ensued in the comment meta, wherein I felt it my duty — given my Keepers ๐ — to do due diligence and alert these somewhat well intentioned brethren to how wrong they are. Per my humble self, I have registered three comments now; and according to the normal communication loop, thus far (at the writing of this post), there has been no response to the sheer brilliance that I have evinced (for free, no less ๐ ) on their rather pedantic and typical exchange. Here is what my last comment said over there (although I don’t know if it will remain my last comment):
Also, it is naive to assume that the only categories to work from in this debate are those represented by the polar opposites of Classic Calvinism/Arminianism. The reason you guys canโt get anywhere is because you all operate from the same philosophical ground provided by Thomas Aquinas or Thomism. Let me clear it up for all of you: you are all what is called classical theists, and thus itโs not a matter of offering different conceptual schemas about the nature of God or man; instead itโs just an issue of shifting your referent points and emphasizing different syllAblEs with the same words. You both Calv/Arm (classics) believe God works through โdecreesโ construed through the metaphysics and causality provided by Aristotle; you both suppose that God is a โsubstanceโ (who has accidents, so His attributes and persons); you both believe that grace and sin are created qualities ( privatio); you both believe that by Spirit imbued grace you are enabled to cooperate (operative grace or habitus) with God in your salvation (or that youโll Persevere); you both believe that predestination and election have to do with particular people instead of a Particular person (the God-man); you both believe that eternal life and damnation have to do with quantity vs. Trinitarian relationship; you both believe that the cross represents a transactional moment wherein God buys an โelectโ group of people (whether that be based upon his arbitrary choice or His foreknowledge) โ so your reductionistic view of a forensics only atonement; and you both are simply dead wrong! Can it be anymore clear than that
?
Obviously, I am being somewhat facetious with some of the tone of my post here; but in all reality it is only “some” of my tone, most of it — in principle — I am quite serious about! Classic Calvinists and Arminians simply do not get it! Most of these fine folks (who I am sure love the Lord) in this thread — have never really considered the fact that the “history” of the Reformed tradition itself has much more nuance to it than the rather sociologically popular forms of Calvinism and Arminianism that they have been taken by, actually exists — in the history! Clearly, you can disagree with me (and be wrong ๐ ), but you cannot disagree that the “history” of the Reformed tradition (and that includes Barth, Torrance, et al) has conceptual possibilities; that as of yet, most Christians who claim the name Calvinist or Arminian have never ventured into. That really is my point. Sure, you can disagree with me; but don’t forget my point!
evangelical, theology
I like this thought from Kevin Vanhoozer on what evangelical means:
. . . The core “evangelical” conviction is that God has spoken and acted in Jesus Christ and that God speaks and acts in the canonical Scriptures that testify to him. In the beginning, God — not philosophy, not religion, not nature, not ethics, not genius, not even the church. An evangelical theology begins at the beginning with God’s speech and action. (Kevin J. Vanhoozer, The Drama Of Doctrine, 26)
To do “evangelical” theology is not to major on the minors; it is not to argue the kalam cosmological argument, it is not to speculate on a concept of Godness, it is not to figure out how man can bridge the gap from man to God, it is not to wear Birkenstocks-drive a Subura Legacy-eat granola-hug trees, it is not to save the Republic, it is not to split atoms, and it is not eating crackers and drinking grape juice. “An evangelical theology begins at the beginning . . .” with God’s eternal Word, who speaks and does the works of the Father in His economic mode (not modalism) of self-articulating Himself to us by the comm-union of the Holy Spirit.
Sola Scriptura, Re-Imaged
I thought this was a nice quote from Kevin Vanhoozer on his the Gospel Script or Sola Scriptura as practice (vs. the usual idea of it as principle). What is of import, from my perspective, is the point that Vanhoozer drives at here; the point is one that Karl Barth and others have pressed extensively, and that is that the Scripture’s primary point is not to present a religious encyclopedia full of facts about God and His Son. Instead, the Bible’s goal is
to point us to Jesus Christ and the relationship that that entails! Further, that the Scriptures have various Types, Forms, & Genres and we shouldn’t flatten these out in order to fabricate or construct our doctrinal statements which only lead to and from static notions of who God is and thus what the Bible is about. Let’s here from Vanhoozer:
Canonical Script
At the heart of the canonical-linguistic approach is the proposal that we come to know God by attending to the uses to which language of God is put in Scripture itself. Scripture’s own use of Scripture is of particular interest, for the cradle of Christian theology is perhaps best located in the interpretative practice of Jesus and the apostles. It was this interpretative practice that enabled them to read the Scriptures of Israel as identifying Jesus as the “Christ.” Canonical-linguistic theology therefore takes its primary bearings from the Scriptures themselves, making what we shall call canonical practices the norm for the church’s speech and thought of God. Sola scriptura returns, then, not by positing the Bible as a text book filled with propositional information but by viewing the Bible as a script that calls for faithful yet creative performance. Scripture is the norm for the Christian way, truth, and life, but only when Scripture is conceived as more than a handbook of propositional truths. (Kevin J. Vanhoozer, The Drama Of Doctrine: A Canonical Linguistic Approach To Christian Theology, 22)
I really like this proposal! The Bible should clearly be seen more as a place where we encounter the living God, and much less (if at all) as a place where we go to proof-text our pet dogmas. Vanhoozer, to be clear, is not arguing that “doctrine” is not important; but instead that doctrine should be given its proper and transformative frame. That is, that doctrine is really how “we” engage in signifying what in fact the Scriptures demand and impose upon us (spiritually and morally) as we meet the living Lord through the Spirit spirated witness that the Holy Writ actually is. So the implication is that Scripture and its interpretation has more to do with persuading and challenging God’s people, as God’s people, to be God’s people through response. The other supposition at work here, is that studying Scripture is really more of an emphasis of how Scripture studies us!
Theological Exegesis and 'Inner-Logic' Interpreting
Inner Logic is an important concept to realize when approaching Scripture and its interpretation. These two words actually signify another way of saying theological exegesis; yet I find that many in my own tradition of “Evangelicalism” shy away from such thinking when it comes to Biblical interpretation. There is this unspoken (but often spoken) belief that when we interpret scripture that it is simply a staightforward exercise (of course the multitudinous interpretations of scripture put this belief to death quickly). The irony of this perspective is that so many of our Essential Christian Beliefs are grounded in anything but straightforward exegesis. Let me provide an example:
One of the bedrock, touchstone foundations of Historic Christian Belief is the doctrine of God known as the Trinity. Of course nowhere in the Bible will we find the nomenclature of Trinity; in fact one of the so called church Fathers, Tertullian,
coined the term Trinitas very early on in the Churches’ genesis; here’s what J. N. D. Kelly says:
. . . He, too, is a ‘Person’, so that the Godhead is a ‘trinity’ (trinitas: Tertullian is the first to employ the word). The three are indeed numerically distinct, being ‘capable of being counted’. . . . Thus Tertullian can state: ‘We believe in on only one God, yet subject to this dispensation, which is our word for economy, that the one only God has also a Son, His Word, Who has issued out of Himself . . . which Son then sent, according to His promise, the Holy Spirit, the Paraclete out of the Father’; and later in the same context he can balance the divine unity with ‘the mystery of the economy, which distributes the unity in Trinity, setting forth Father, Son and Spirit as three’. (J.N.D. Kelly, “Early Christian Doctrines,” 113)
I mention this to further substantiate that the language of Trinity, itself, is indeed foreign to the text of scripture; in fact as Kelly notes it came from a church Father. What I would like to further add, in flow with the context of this post, is that while the language of “Trinity” may be foreign to the text of Scripture; indeed, the grammar or concept is not. This brings us back to the language of inner logic or theological exegesis. In other words, how did Tertullian and the other church Father’s come to conclude that God is not only one (de deo uno); but in fact He is three (de deo trino) in one and one in three? Simple they read scripture, and discerned that when they read the Apostle Paul, for example, that there was an unstated theological concept about God that Paul was assuming in order to make benedictions like this:
“The grace of the Lord Jesus Christ, and the love of God, and the communion of the Holy Spirit be with you all. Amen.” ~II Corinithians 13:13
As you engage the rest of Paul’s writings (like all of II Corinthians for example) there is this constant assumption that the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit are at work in salvation. This is what discerning the inner logic leads to; i.e. key and fundamental doctrines upon which the Christian faith hangs — starting in the early church and into the present.
So there is more to scripture interpretation and exegesis than engaging in exegetical and syntactical analysis of the Koine Greek of the New Testament; there in fact is an inner logic that holds the text of scripture together. It is the theologian’s job to discern and lay bare this “logic” and work out the implications of that “inner logic” for the church and all of her exegetes. The Trinity is just one example of working out the inner logic of scripture; all of Scripture actually hangs together on Christo-logic, but this is discussion for another post.
I hope folks realize the depth embedded within the scriptures themselves; if you do you will be set up to enjoy the richness and freshness that scripture has to offer.
'Father'
Here is a quote on God as ‘Father’ versus ‘Creator’, this is important, so I am quoting this in length:
. . . The center of the New Testament is the relationship between Jesus Christ and the One he addresses as Father. The communion between Jesus and his heavenly Fatherly is an utterly unique relationship, of which we can know nothing apart from Jesus’ own testimony.
God is thus Father not by comparison to human fathers, but only in the Trinitarian relation, as Father of the Son. Whenever Father is used of God it means “the One whom Jesus called Father.” The paradigm text is John 1:18: “No one has ever seen God. It is God the only Son, who is close to the Father’s heart, who has made him known.” In Greek, the word for “made him known” is exegesato. Jesus “exegetes” or “interprets” the Father. The term does not denote a generic title for God outside of the Father-Son relationship. Father thus functions in Trinitarian language not as a descriptive metaphor but as a proper name, whose home is the relationship that exists from all eternity between the first and second Persons of the Trinity. That is a relationship to which we as creatures have not immediate knowledge or access.
But by an astonishing gift of grace, Jesus invites us to be united with himself in the power of the Holy Spirit so that in union with him we may come to share in his utterly unique relation of Sonship to the Father. By ourselves we have absolutely no right or ground to address God as “Father.” It is only as we are united with Christ, partaking of his communion with the Father, that we can truthfully address God in this way ourselves. In Paul’s words,
For all who are led by the Spirit of God are children of God. . . . When we cry, “Abba! Father!” it is that very Spirit bearing witness with our spirit that we are children of God, and if children, then heirs, heirs of God and joint heirs with Christ. (Rom. 8:14-17)
We know God only in and through Christ’s relationship of Sonship, into which he invites us as participants (“Pray then like this: Our Father, who art in heaven . . .”). This means that salvation is understood as our communion with the Father through the Son in the power of the Holy Spirit. As Fanny Crosby’s hymn put it, “O come to the Father through Jesus the Son, and give him the glory: great things he hath done!” Our knowledge of God and our hope for salvation are directly Trinitarian in their scope.
The traditional naming of the Trinitarian God as Father, Son, and Holy Spirit is sometimes replaced today by the functional titles of Creator, Redeemer, and Sustainer. This works as an occasional use, describing God’s acts, but not as a substitute for the Trinitarian Name. The Fatherhood of God is tied utterly to Jesus’ naming of his own relationship to God, into which relationship we, by the Spirit, participate.
It was St. Athanasius who noted that the only reason we have for calling God “Father” is that God is so named by Jesus in the Bible. This points to the historical shape that the Gospels too: Christian faith is a biblical faith and a Jesus-based faith. God’s Fatherhood was understood relationally in an through Jesus Christ as self-giving love, and not as a human image or concept projected onto God. There is, in fact, an appropriate “thinking away” of that which is inappropriate in this terminology. By this we mean explicitly thinking away all biological and sexual imputation whatsoever into the theological concept of God. God the Father revealed in Scripture is Spirit. God has no sexual identity; sexuality, after all, is part of creation. The imago Dei (image of God) is not reversible; God is not created in our likeness! The personalized language of Trinitarian theology intends to bear witness in Christ to the liberation of humankind from all patriarchal idols and divinized ideologies. Where this did not and does not happen, there is a perversion of intent that must be utterly rejected on the ground of the nature and reference of Trinitarian language itself. (Andrew Purves and Mark Achtemeier, “Union in Christ: A Declaration for the Church,” 34-36)
There is so much in this that could be noted. I am only going to touch on some of the implications of what is being said here; I am going to reflect (below) with (1) Theological Implications, and then (2) Pastoral Implications.
Theological Implications
Certainly it should at least be highlighted that thinking like that articulated in the quote flows from a prior commitment to a certain mode of theological discourse, in fact methodology or prolegomena. Purves and Achtemeir are in the, what Barth has called, analogia fidei (or analogy of faith) versus the Traditional approach, best articulated by Thomas Aquinas called the analogia entis (or analogy of being). Instead of discussing what the distinctions are, in general here, I am going to focus on how these two disparate approaches play out theologically; and for our purposes, Confessionally. What happens if a particular theologian, or school of theologians, follows Aquinas’ approach versus the more Luther[an], Calvin[ian], Barth[ian], Torrance[an] approach? Here’s how the WCF starts out discussion on God and Trinity:
I. There is but one only,[1] living, and true God,[2] who is infinite in being and perfection,[3] a most pure spirit,[4] invisible,[5] without body, parts,[6] or passions;[7] immutable,[8] immense,[9] eternal,[10] incomprehensible,[11] almighty,[12] most wise,[13] most holy,[14] most free,[15] most absolute;[16] working all things according to the counsel of His own immutable and most righteous will,[17] for His own glory;[18] most loving,[19] gracious, merciful, long-suffering, abundant in goodness and truth, forgiving iniquity, transgression, and sin;[20] the rewarder of them that diligently seek Him;[21] and withal, most just, and terrible in His judgments,[22] hating all sin,[23] and who will by no means clear the guilty.[24] (WCF, 2/I)
And the Belgic Confession:
Article 1: The Only God
* We all believe in our hearts and confess with our mouths that there is a single and simple spiritual being, whom we call God — eternal, incomprehensible, invisible, unchangeable, infinite, almighty; completely wise, just, and good, and the overflowing source of all good.
Article 8: The Trinity
* In keeping with this truth and Word of God we believe in one God, who is one single essence, in whom there are three persons, really, truly, and eternally distinct according to their incommunicable properties– namely, Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. The Father is the cause, origin, and source of all things, visible as well as invisible. (Belgic Confession)
Contrast the above with the Heidelberg Catechism:
Of God The Father
9. Lord’s Day
Question 26. What believest thou when thou sayest, “I believe in God the Father, Almighty, Maker of heaven and earth”?
Answer: That the eternal Father of our Lord Jesus Christ (who of nothing made heaven and earth, with all that is in them; (a) who likewise upholds and governs the same by his eternal counsel and providence) (b) is for the sake of Christ his Son, my God and my Father; (c) on whom I rely so entirely, that I have no doubt, but he will provide me with all things necessary for soul and body (d) and further, that he will make whatever evils he sends upon me, in this valley of tears turn out to my advantage; (e) for he is able to do it, being Almighty God, (f) and willing, being a faithful Father. (g) (Heidelberg Catechism)
And the Scots Confession:
Chapter 1 – God
We confess and acknowledge one God alone, to whom alone we must cleave, whom alone we must serve, whom alone we must worship, and in whom alone we must put our trust; who is eternal, infinite, immeasurable, incomprehensible, omnipotent, invisible; one in substance and yet distinct in three persons: the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit; by whom we confess and believe all things in heaven and earth, visible and invisible to have been created, to be retained in their being, and to be ruled and guided by his inscrutable providence for such end as his eternal wisdom, goodness, and justice have appointed, and to the manifestation of his own glory. (Scot’s Confession, 1560)
At first blush there might not be much discernable difference between the WCF/BC and the HC/SC, but that’s what I want to reflect on for a moment. The “Westminster” tradition starts talking about God by highlighting His “attributes,” these are characteristics that are contrasted with who man is not. We finally make it to Him as “Father, Son, Holy Spirit,” but not before we have qualified Him through “our” categories using man (“analogy of being”) as our mode of thinking about “Godness.” This is true for both the WCF/BC. Contrarily, the HC/SC both immediately speak of God as Father; which is to say that these approach God through an (“analogy of faith” to speak anachronistically). Meaning that the emphasis is on the economic Revelation of God in Christ as the ‘eternal Son of God’ who exegetes God’s inner-life as loving Father, Son, by the Holy Spirit as the shape of his ‘being’ (ousia).
I hope the significance of this is not lost on you. It almost seems nit-picky, I am sure for some of you, that I would try and draw this distinction; but I want to assure you, that it is real — and that it would serve as one of the reasons that Purves and Achtemeir felt it necessary to make the point they do in the quote I provide from them above. The next question might be, what difference does this shift in “emphasis” and approach make in real life; in “pastoral situations?”
Pastoral Implications
I have a friend who is in the midst of “hellish” personal circumstances (a divorce with extraordinary circumstances surrounding it). We meet almost weekly to talk and pray. He has previously (for the past few years) sat under teaching that is self-consciously promoting theology that lines up with the Westminster approach to articulating God; his pastors teach through the theological grid that both John MacArthur and John Piper provide (in general). He is totally relying on the Lord, for this is really all he has, through this terrible season. And often, in our conversation he brings up the issue of “why” if God is sovereign would He allow or decree or appoint or cause the things that are happening to happen in his life in the way that they are. It is hard for my friend to conceptualize a God who is loving Father before He is sovereign Creator. So, like the “WCF” my friend primarily thinks about God through God’s attributes; instead of think of God through His relationship as Father, Son, Holy Spirit. This has real life consequence upon how my friend is trying to process his circumstances, and I must say not for the good. I am glad that I have been able to point him to a way to think about God as loving Father who is sovereign in relation to His Son versus thinking about God as sovereign Creator who deals with humanity through his unqualified attributes as if this is what defines the “essence” of “who” God is. My friend, I think, is starting to see what a difference this makes in trying to think about God in right ways!
Sola Scriptura, 'Land of the Giants'
We all, as good Protestants, want to hold to an idea of sola scriptura (or prima and/or solo); my point being, we want to say the that the Scriptures are our authority for doctrine, life, and practice. Within the history of the church we have had many commentators, theologians, and teachers who have provided the body of Christ with layers and layers of dogmatic formulation and exegetical articulation that have come to be known as the ‘Tradition’ of the Church — your respective view of this will depend, of course, upon your particular ecclesial affiliation (I have no intention engaging that issue with this post). In many ways this is a great gift, a needed gift, for the Church’s self-identification as a historic body of people defined by a historic and Apostolic teaching. Yet, this can pose problems as well; the kind of problem that the Protestant Reformers — like Luther — sought to
rectify by going back to the ‘sources’ (Ad fontes). The climate that fostered going back to the ‘sources’ — e.g. the ‘sources’ being the Bible (in its original languages & the Patristics or Church Fathers) — was a movement largely initiated by a guy named, Lorenzo Valla, and was called Humanism (I’ve written about that here). The movement, which the Church prior to this (during the Medieval era specifically) had been stewing in can be called scholasticism. This style of thinking and methodology operated through three points held in dialectic tension, they are: 1) Thesis, 2) Anti-thesis, 3) Synthesis . . . then the ‘synthesis’ became the new ‘thesis’, and the whole process of disputation started over and rolled on (to state this all very simply). The unattended consequence of this kind of methodology results in ‘Tradition’ building, or a ‘Commentary’ tradition; so that, in effect, as the years pass by we move further and further away from the original source which we are purportedly talking about in the first place — in this case the “source” that we are talking about (as Christians) is the Scriptures. The net result is that when we think we’re talking about Scripture, in fact, instead, we’re talking about a ‘Tradition’ that barely resembles what it tenuously says it is discussing. This was the situation Luther faced.
I want to suggest, that this kind of ‘tradition’ building — the scholastic kind — is alive and well today! All one has to do is peruse the theo-blogosphere and it becomes quickly evident that the reference points of many discussions revolve around what this theologian said, or that Biblical commentator said; whilst the concern to see how what is being said measures up against its original ‘source’ it typically absent. In fact, for many, the Bible has become part of the ‘Tradition’ and relegated to the level of a ‘Symbol’ much like the Augsburg Confession became for the Lutherans; in other words, the Tradition and Scripture sit side by side in practical force.
The ideal that we all seek, as Protestants, is to always allow the ‘Scriptures’ themselves to be both the norm and rule by which we adjudicate all ‘tradition’ and ‘theological formulation’; the Scriptures are to provide the ‘Check-and-Balances’ on tradition or our theologizing (purportedly of the inner-logic provided by the Scriptures and whom they bear witness to, Jesus Christ). This is a tenuous task, one that I think we all probably fail at in one way or the other. For example, we might elevate a ‘Pet Teacher’, like T. F. Torrance, attributing to him the functional status as Christ’s vicar on earth ๐ . We might casually assume that since we believe this or that particular teacher or school of thought has said things that are sound on some things; that things they say on all things are true or consonant with the Scriptures, ipso facto — thus we give them a pass, as it were.
Let me close my little reflection this way: I don’t think theologizing, tradition building, or commentary building are inherently bad things; in fact all of this is inevitable, we’re going to build and stand on the shoulders of giants that have gone before us. The common assumption, for Protestants, is that the giants are standing on the Word of God (Scripture in this case) as their foundation. So what we need to constantly be doing is looking down at the ‘giant’s feet’ to make sure that we’re standing on the “right shoulders.” I honestly don’t think this is being done so often. The next question is how can this be done? The “giant’s feet” are way down there (i.e. there are lots of layers to get through — our own preundestandings and presuppositions betrothed to us by these metaphoric “giants”), is there a way to actually get to the Scriptures; or are we so conditioned that this task is seemingly impossible? Can we, and/or should we even attempt to say that we can get to the Sources?
My next post or a post some time soon will seek to engage my question, further, here.
Christian Doctrine, "A Wash?"
Do you ever get the impression that for most Christians doctrine doesn’t really matter? I get the sense sometimes, that for those for whom it
doesn’t; figure that they’re saved, they’re on their way to heaven, so things like doctrine and theology really don’t matter.
I realize that some are called to “teach/preach”, but this presupposes that those who are being taught are learning; and further, that as they learn they are going out and teaching themselves (this used to be called “disciple-making”). I also realize that life is truly busy, it just is! And that for the normal American (or Western) person this leaves precious little time for serious time of Bible study and reflection. But then again, I bet we all have time to carve out of the day where we could engage in study and thought that would contribute to our growing in the grace and knowledge of Jesus Christ.
Just a quick little reflection. I wonder what you think about Christian doctrine and growth in this area for all Christians; do you think it’s really a “wash” in the end, that we’re going to heaven anyway, so what else matters as long as I am “saved?”
Knowing God, Are you 'positive'?
Here Richard Muller describes, briefly, both Luther and Calvin’s thinking on the relationship of ‘faith’ and ‘reason’ (what hath ‘Jerusalem to do with Athens’, eh):
“Assuredly, no one can be a theologian except he become one without Aristotle.” So wrote Martin Luther his Disputation against Scholastic Theology of 1517. According to Luther, philosophical knowledge was, at best,
superficial: it discerned the one God but knew nothing of his identity as Trinity; it examined essences but failed to perceive either the present purpose or the end of man as ordained by God. Calvin also was profoundly aware of the limitation of human reason and of the danger of placing too much confidence in the product of reason or philosophy: “one can read competent and apt statements about God here and there in the philosophers. . . . But they saw things in such a way that their seeing did not direct them to the truth, much less enable them to attain it.” Luther, Calvin, and the other early Reformers had little interest in elaborating a positive relationship between faith and philosophy. This is, of course, not to say that there was total antipathy to philosophical learning or, indeed, to the entirety of the scholastic past on the part of either Luther or Calvin. . . . (Richard A. Muller, “After Calvin,” 122)
This is the kind of stance that both Karl Barth and T. F. Torrance took seriously in their theologizing, and what Karl Barth’s analogia fidei (‘analogy of faith) was on about, in the main. That is that we must engage in theological knowledge through looking at Christ. There are clearly differences, developments, and even points of departure between Luther/Calvin and Barth/Torrance; nevertheless, the basic contours are the same. We don’t want to engage in a ‘negative’ speculative theology that thinks of God through ‘essences’ ‘accidents’ etc. We want to approach the Holy of holies through the unveiling of God’s life through the torn veil of Jesus’ body, and remember that He alone — He who dwells in the bosom of the Father — explains God to us.
This is the approach that EC seeks to harbor, to one degree or another, and I would encourage all of you to likewise engage in theological thinking that starts in the center of God in Christ’s life, and works out from there towards a knowledge of God that is robustly Trinitarian; and thus, is also pervasively ‘Evangelical’ in orientation.