The Lombard, An Origenist Analogy On the Church Catholic the Church Protestant

Peter Lombard (ca. 1095-1160), bishop of Paris. Lombard taught theology at the school of Notre Dame and his text Four Books of Sentences was the key theology text of the Middle Ages. (Photo by Š CORBIS/Corbis via Getty Images)

I was just pondering how all of us Protestants (Reformed, Lutheran, evangelicals et al.) are still members of the Latin/Western church (normally understood to be the Catholic church). As Providence would have it, as I’m reading Book 4 of Lombard’s Sentences (in my quest to become a mediaeval doctor of the Church), I came across the following citation from Lombard on and from Origen:

ORIGEN, ON LEVITICUS. And so those whom the Church’s sentence strikes and wounds according to what they deserve are outside also before God. Whoever did not deserve it, is wounded by the Church’s sentence, unless he holds it in contempt. Hence Origen: “One has gone out from truth, from faith, from charity: on this account, he goes out of the encampments of the Church, even if he is not cast out by the bishop’s voice. Likewise, on the contrary, another is sent outside by a judgement which is not right, but if he did not do anything to deserve to go out, he suffers no wound. And so, at times, one who is sent outside is within; and one who is outside, appears to be kept within.” (Lombard, Sentences, 4.18.7 (103).3)

In context this is referring to the binding and loosing power that the Catholic church believes priests have, in regard to forgiveness and confession of sins. But on analogy, it could also be observed, in principle, that there remains this type of “outside/within” dynamic even within the broader catholic Western church (and beyond). Of course, how this outside/within dynamic is affirmed, perspectivally, will determine who the outside and within are. From a historical perspective it would be the Catholic church within which the Protestant church, while outside, is still within in certain important ways. Indeed, in the way Luther had originally intended: to be a reformer from within rather than outside the church. Hence, Exsurge Domine notwithstanding, I would argue, de jure, the Protestants are still within even while outside.

My Exchange with an ‘Orthobro’: Addressing the spirit of Sectarianism

I just recently had an exchange on X with a type of guy who is often referred to as an “Orthobro,” short for “Orthodox brother,” but with a “dude” edge. I am not going to use his name, which to his credit he actually uses his (real name) on X. But he is a recent convert from Anglicanism (as an ordinand for the ministry) to the Eastern Orthodox church (where he will be soon, apparently, also an ordinand). As you will notice, only by inference, I would suggest that he is still in the so-called “cage-stage.” Often this terminology is applied to guys who become “Calvinists.” It is that novelty stage where everything is new; where you’ve finally taken the plunge into a whole new world where everything is shiny and sparkly; and you think everyone else, besides you, and your newfound faith, is wrong. I would say my interlocutor easily fits within those parameters.

So, what I am going to do is simply string all of my responses to my interlocutor together, and allow you to infer what it is that I am probably responding to; with reference to his comments to me. I will share a comment from him that will serve as a nice synopsizing frame, which in spirit, typifies the gist of most of the exchange from his end. I will also note here at the outset that what sparked the whole exchange is that I reposted his original post, made on his timeline, where he was noting his conversion to the “only true and Apostolic Church on the earth.” When I reposted his post, my comment was something like: “it’s too bad when people move say from Anglicanism to Orthodoxy (in this case) that they simply can’t say that that’s what they did; without the further sectarian qualification that often attends it.”

The Orthodox interlocutor: It’s hardly surprising that as a Reformed theologian you have such a view. I pray you eventually come to see the truth and become Orthodox rather than holding to heretical Reformed doctrine that is wholly inconsistent with the Apostolic faith and the patristic consensus. . .. It’s simple, there was one undivided Church, the RCC split off at the Great Schism, then your denomination split off from them. The original Church remained unchanged and still exists today. Ask yourself which human man founded your “church”.

My responses: Jesus loves you too. Altho, I’d say I’m not quite “Reformed” in the way you are presuming. I’m Athanasian Reformed; I’m “Eastern” Reformed; it could even be said, of Thomas F. Torrance, in important ways. You presume much too much methinks. In the end, you’re a sectarian in spirit, which is not of Christ, and thus is antiChrist. . .. Sure thing. And yet the esse of the church is not possessed by a particular “body” on this earth, but grounded in the body of Jesus Christ at the right hand of the Father. There is no prolongation of the incarnation in a peculiar people found in the “East” or anywhere. The church participates in the Church, so to speak, in the triune life, mediated by the Church’s reality in Jesus Christ. We thus bear witness to that reality, to the Church’s reality, through union with His life by the Spirit. . .. Yes, the Orthodox church is really Greek. There is either Greek or Latin churchiology in the history. Yes, indeed: His body, not ours. To simply assert an absolute representation of that on earth is in fact sectarian par excellence. Study of church history itself doesn’t bear out your assertions about the uniformity of things, per se. . .. Again, eh. I understand you must assert such things. It’s as if you operate with some type of physicalism in regard to the church’s lineage. The only yea or no in the church is not conciliar, but within the divine and triune life itself. Your appeals to authority aren’t convincing. . .. This will have to be my last comment. Quoting Bruce McCormack on the councils and creeds and their value. “I say all of this to indicate that even the ecumenical creeds are only provisional statements. They are only relatively binding as definitions of what constitutes “orthodoxy.” Ultimately, orthodox teaching is that which conforms perfectly to the Word of God as attested in Holy Scripture. But given that such perfection is not attainable in this world, it is understandable that Karl Barth should have regarded “Dogma” as an eschatological concept. The “dogmas” (i.e., the teachings formally adopted and promulgated by individual churches) are witnesses to the Dogma and stand in a relation of greater or lesser approximation to it. But they do not attain to it perfectly—hence, the inherent reformability of all “dogmas.” Orthodoxy is not therefore a static, fixed reality; it is a body of teachings which have arisen out of, and belong to, a history which is as yet incomplete and constantly in need of reevaluation.” -Bruce L. McCormack, Orthodox and Modern: Studies in the Theology of Karl Barth (Grand Rapids, MI: Baker Academic, 2008), 16. . .. Sola scriptura isn’t solo scriptura (most likely how you’re thinking of it—many do, even those who say they hold to sola). Anyway, I’m more radical than that given my theory of revelation. We won’t make headway here, that is clear. I can understand why someone would be drawn to the aesthetics of Orthodoxy, no doubt. If I were to go that way, it wouldn’t be Latin, but Greek for sure. Other than that, socially and politically you and I seem to be simpatico, as I’ve scanned your TL a little. . .. Eh. Enjoy.

I think I might have made a few more responses to him, but the above should suffice. I let him know in one of my responses that I would look forward to hooking back up in ten years, Lord willing, and seeing how he had calmed down on the sectarianism by then; hopefully.

Are the Western churches even the Church Anymore?

Confusing the various subcultures of Christianity, with the Gospel itself is fleeting. Each Christian tradition has its own idiosyncratic ways of liturgizing, and various parochialisms, and its just straight up weird stuff that they do. For my respective “tribe,” broadly speaking, as an American evangelical, what has become weird is driven by its slavish commitment to consumerism at all costs. Whether it be professional worship bands leading worship (like the folks who didn’t quite make the American Idol cut), the pastor wearing skinny jeans, sporting a mustache, with a man bun, or just the self-help sermons and programs that run amok in such environs, there is a cultural Pelagianism present behind such productions. That is to say, the belief that people, in the main, are simply neutral beings, and that given the proper external stimuli they can be persuaded, one way or the other, to affirm Christ or not; they can be “led” into a situation, through various conditionings (and programs), where, as the theory goes, they will come to feel included in the community. You know the whole “felt needs” and “real needs” combine. One big problem with this is that such seeker sensitive churches get so hyper fixated on meeting peoples’ felt needs—with the rationalization that it’s all being done in the name and claim of the Gospel—that that becomes the end. They are unable, under such inertia, to ever get to the real need; which has been the supposed justification for using the felt needs to begin with.

As an American evangelical who has grown up in this, from its more fundy iteration to where it is now, what I have come to realize, along with many, that such Pelagianistically funded churches really aren’t representative of the church writ large at all. That is not to say that there aren’t “saved” people in the pews all throughout such churches. But it is to say that these people have become used to, and thus expectant of having their ears and eyes tickled with feel good messages; for the most part. After awhile though, the discerning Christian has to start asking at what point such a group ceases to be operating as a real life, Spirit led church, and instead finds its function more in line with some sort of social club (e.g., think of Christian Smith’s adage: moralistic therapeutic deism). None of this is to suggest that the church, this side of the Eschaton, will ever be perfect. But it is to say that at a certain point the Ghost has been given up indeed, and the so-called pastors are nothing more than “hirelings” for cultural dereliction.

For those of us seeking a healthy local church to attend, in such environments, this scenario makes it exceedingly difficult. For me, the pastors involved in this type of tripe are heading for a serious and heavy judgment. In the end, the Gospel cannot be reduced to these church subcultures; and yet often, people do engage in such reductions—and so they become so-called Exvangelicals, Nones, or straight up atheists (of a certain pop type). The Gospel is Christ as attested to and encountered in Holy Scripture. The Gospel is God’s triune Life for the world, and a genuine church is to faithfully bear witness to this deep reality; through deep and stretching teachings, activities, so on and so forth. Outwith this I have a hard time seeing how the apostasies of the Western churches (and elsewhere) can be curbed.

Getting Beyond the Baby’s Dream: What Hath the Lectern to do with the Pulpit-Pew?

What hath the lectern to do with the pulpit? I, personally, operate in this strange theological wilderness that spans both poles, whether that is found in the rigor of academic theology (so-called), or the practicality (so-called) of the daily Christian life. It seems that there might be room for both, but I’m not all that sure. What’s prompting this writing is a theological conference I just saw took place in Scotland at the Scottish Dogmatics Conference at Aberdeen Divinity School. After awhile what comes to the fore for me is the question: so what? Who cares? What is increasingly becoming clear to me is that typically the only people who end up caring are those in attendance at such conferences; i.e., the “academic theologians.” The irony of such efforts is that they are typically said to be in service of and for the Church writ large. But are they really? Is the theology being cajoled and discussed at such conferences really reaching the churches? Judging by the state of the churches, whether progressive mainline, or “conservative” evangelical, I’d say the answer to that question is a hard no.

What if the theology being discussed, and not just at this particular conference, but along the whole ambit of academic theology turns out to be sound, indeed, the truth (as far as we can proximate that in our theology, in our witness to the risen Christ)? That would mean, as any good Christian theology is, that it is mind independent/extramental; i.e., not contingent on its affirmation to be true or not-true (or objectively true). In that sense, such theological discoursing is justified; I would argue, because it simply just is the case, just as the triune God is the case. Whether or not people in the churches, in the pulpits or pews ascend to such “heights,” the material reality just is the case. And so in that sense there is a genuine witness to Christ present within the academicians’ discourse about God. And yet, as the Gospel narratives attest: “the common people heard Him [Jesus] gladly.” Somehow Christ was able to accommodate the linguistic modes of conversation in a way that met the people at their own levels of “common” discourse. If this was, and is the case, shouldn’t that be part of the so-called academic theologian’s burden; i.e., shouldn’t they feel the necessity to not only communicate at the heights, and for each other, as it were, but to communicate for the Church writ large; that is in a way that the Church can have access to the deep profundities of the faith?

And yet, there is another hand as well. The burden in this arena is a like a double-edged sword, it cuts both ways. Certain realities can only be brought “so low.” That is to say, there are meaty truths, as Hebrews attests, that Christians in general should come to the point of being able to consume; beyond their “milky” diets. That is to say, the “common Christian” has been burdened, just the same, to stretch and grow; to apply themselves with a zeal that comes from the heart of Christ Himself. That is to say, just as the Lord promised to provide His church with pastors and teachers (and prophets and evangelists), this also implies that there will be crops of students/disciples, eager to transform, to stretch, to grow deeper deeper in the grace and knowledge of Jesus Christ. Being lazy is not a virtue in the Kingdom.

How does this ditch between the lectern and pulpit/pew get bridged? 1) There must be recognition of it, 2) there must be intention to work beyond this impasse on both “sides,” 3) there, most of all, must be a constraining by the love of Christ within the hearts of God’s people for a growth in a knowledge of Him. On the Protestant side we have what is called “the priesthood of all believers.” This ought to suggest to Protestant Christians (at the least) that they have been called to toil, to rightly divide the Worth of Truth. The notion that the Christian can simply float along the path of salvation without putting in blood, sweat and tears is a baby’s dream. Such effort isn’t to ensure eternal life, but it is to grow in the grace and knowledge of Jesus Christ; to be transformed from glory to glory. This requires a cultivation in a study and reading ethic that the ‘flesh’ kicks against. Indeed, we are involved in a spiritual battle of the type that the Enemy makes appeal, over and again, to the tiredness of our bodies of death. It takes resurrection power, by the indwelling Holy Spirit and mediation of Christ by the Father, to endure, to perdure and persevere under the stresses of the Christian life; primary of which is to be a studying and reading people.

 

Church Culture isn’t the Gospel, isn’t God: On Deconstructing Deconstruction

Church culture isn’t the Gospel. Even so, it is what we most tangibly experience as Christians in the world. That kind of experience, as with any experience, can be either good, bad, or indifferent. Unfortunately, many these days (and in days past) are deconstructing. They are claiming to have this ‘come of age’ moment wherein they’ve finally come to realize that their respective evangelicalism[s], the cultures therein, have misrepresented God to them. The early mistake most of these folks make is to conflate their experience in various church cultures with God Himself. This represents some form of functional pantheism for them, wherein God’s existence is coextensive with the church’s “body” existence. Insofar, that such folk are unable to disentangle their experience of church culture with the reality of the living God Himself, they will mistakenly chuck the whole thing; at least, the whole thing in the way they have come to understand it.

It’s hard to blame people for wanting to abandon North American evangelicalism (among other evangelicalisms across the world). In my own experience, and I’ve been “in it” since birth, the evangelical churches have gone to the seed of the anthropology they generally have appropriated from the very beginning. That is to note, evangelicalism, ironically, finds it genesis as a reactionary movement; at least as most of evangelicalism has taken shape into the present. It started with the so-called Fundamentalists. At the turn of the 19th and 20th centuries post-enlightenment rationalism, so on and so forth, began to penetrate the seminaries in North America; Princeton being the prime example. Once the higher biblical criticism, and its supporting rationalistic positivism began to seep into these seminaries, there were men who were intent on standing against it (think of someone like Machen). But the way they stood against the new theology, or ‘liberal theology,’ was largely to assume the burden put to them by the higher critics of Scripture. As a result, through this type of methodological appropriation, what came with it, was the type of supporting anthropology that funded the critics’ criticism; i.e., rationalism, romanticism, methodological skepticism etc. All this to say, in brief, through this reactionism the fundamentalist theologians allowed the critics to define the theological, and thus ecclesiological types of questions they were going to attempt to answer from the get-go. This type of theological mood was passed down to the fundamentalist and evangelical churches into the current moment. It is a ‘turn to the subject’ wherein the mode of the Christian is to first think of themselves, and then to God. It’s to think that we are singular islands in a voluntary treaty with other islands, and this cooperation we end up calling Church. But you see, if my sketch is correct, what is set up, when applied to a God-world relation, is a methodological starting point in an abstract individual self. It is through this starting point that such Christians approach God. The result ends up looking like the culture at large; i.e., we see a mass consumerism and self-enthrallment at the center of the biblical teaching (i.e., self-help, positive thinking, pragmatism etc.), as well as “worship” (music).

But the above type of enthrallment only superficially meets the basest of our human and fallen desires. It doesn’t offer a deep point of contact between the living and triune God, and what the truly human soul has been created for; indeed, to find its depth reality in the very ousia (being) of Godself. In other words, individualistic consumerist iterations of church culture only have a short burn available to them. For some that might entail decades, for others, a shorter period of time. Once people realize that they are only getting a watered-down version of what the world itself has on offer at full tap, the person seeking real depth turns to the fountainhead of the superficiality that the churches are only able to offer modified versions of. Of course, this “new” sense of liberty, that is from the shackles of “God” as “church culture, is experienced as a new burn is started, and the person is able to “live” off of this type of “early love” feeling for another season of life. Even so, they are left feeling vacuous and empty. They might be able to stoke their new exvangelical sensibilities, as noted, for seasons of time, but they still understand that underneath it all they haven’t found the depth dimension their souls have been longing for all along. Except, for many, they believe they’ve already “been there done that” with God; i.e., hearkening back to their experience with evangelical church culture as God. They are then thrown into a pit of despondency and despair fortified with the belief that they already tried the “God thing,” only to realize that “He” was really only a projection of the collective of people self-identified as the church.

My aforementioned sketch is bleak, but I don’t think is off point. The Church’s reality esse is not found in itself. The Church’s reality res is found in its inner-being in the inner-being of God’s triune life as it has come to participate in that life through the mediation of Christ’s life pro nobis for us through His union with our humanity, and through our union with His humanity as that is grounded in the bosom of the Father. The Church will always have a variety of iterations and cultural expressions, insofar that God’s life in Christ constantly afresh in-breaks into all types of human cultures all across the catholic globe. So, as that is the case, cultural expression, just as Jesus expressed His own human culture as the Jew from Nazareth, is not the problem. The problem is when human culture is thought in abstraction from its ultimate ground and reality in God’s life ‘for us.’ The problem for the churches is when the church’s culture becomes the starting and ending point in itself; as a harbinger to only reinforce the human incurved and sinful bent to begin with.

All of the above noted: it is understandable why many are walking away from God; insofar that they have conflated God with their purported experience of Him as given in their experiences actualized in the church cultures. I think it may well be the Holy Spirit attempting to wake people up to the spiritual failure of these many churches and their attending church cultures. But it is a fatal mistake to take your church culture, and your damaging experiences with it, and throw the whole thing away. God remains God, no matter the failures of the churches. The churches, as we all know, all too well, are of course populated by sinful people; chucking the whole thing doesn’t change that, nor does it change the fact that those who are abandoning God are themselves still, very much so, sinners. What we need to recognize is that the Church does not find its reality ‘within itself,’ but ‘outwith-outside itself’ in the risen Christ and the triune God. Once the Christian realizes this, i.e., that their relationship with God is not contingent upon their experiences within this or that church culture, they will have a better way to move forward. Maybe it will be to move onto another tradition, or just a specific church they find that is more genuinely grounded on the Word of God; or maybe it will be to stay in said church cultures and attempt to be a witness to the reality of the Church in the midst of all the superficialities they and others have been experiencing within the churches.

After saying all of the above, what also is true is that many people are simply using their dissatisfaction with the churches as an excuse to simply walk deeper into their own self-possessed desires and lusts, while hiding behind the real superficiality that is indeed present in the many church cultures today. That is to say, many aren’t finding the ‘level’ of superficiality they are experiencing in the churches as a sufficient means of self-centeredness to live the wanton lives they are really seeking; that is, as ordered by a disordered self-drivenness that their base selves long for.

There is a gambit here.

The Particularity and Concreteness of Christ: Against Cultural “Christianities”

A genuine Christianity is not pluriform, it does not have multitudinous realities at its core. It is not a cluster of beliefs that likeminded people rally around. A genuine Christianity—its inner reality—is in fact a person; it is God for us in the vicarious humanity of Jesus Christ. When people exit or walk away from this or that perceived form or expression of the “Christian existence,” they aren’t walking away from Christianity’s inner reality, per se, if in fact they believe that to be exhaustively represented in the form of that, as they have come to experience that, in this or that Christian tradition. In other words, if someone believes, when they walk away from Christianity, that they have done so by walking away from their immediate experience of that, they are sorely in error; and in error, in such a way that it potentially could have, or will have eternal consequences.

There are certainly damaging and erroneous forms or expressions of a self-proclaimed Christianity, but much of those are simply socio-cultural constructs masquerading as THE form of Christianity; at least in the way that it is presented to and received by its adherents. If someone has a personal relationship with the living God in Christ, walking away from Christianity becomes a much different thing than walking away from an experience of a so-called Christianity.

Make sure, if and when you walk away from something, you know what in fact you are walking away from. And just as important, make sure you understand what you are walking into as an alternative.

The Church as Triune Event and not Religious Phenomena

The Church. The Church’s reality is invisible, and only visible to those with eyes to see; with eyes offered by the faith of Christ. The Church doesn’t have a physical address, per se; it can’t be found at 777 Vatican Way or something. The Church’s only physical address is found in the ground of the vicarious humanity of Jesus Christ; but we currently see Him, not with eyes of flesh, but with eyes of faith (just as sure as we love Him, even though we don’t currently “see” Him). The Church is not a result of so-called religious phenomena, but instead its reality comes to it, afresh anew, by its in-breaking reality in Jesus Christ in the triune life. This, among other things, means that purely sociological analysis of the Church is non-starting. The Church has no horizontal reality without first gaining reality from its vertical touchstone in Jesus Christ. Jesus Christ is not a valent to be handled and touched in the way that the Elks Club can be; not in the way that majestic cathedrals can be; not in the way that beer-stained pubs can be. Jesus Christ, clearly, is the Lamb of God slain before the foundations of the world; viz., clearly for those with eyes of faith. Indeed, the Church is as concrete and blood-saturated as the veins of Immanuel; the Church has concrete extension into the world, and into the lives of bruised reeds, insofar that God freely and graciously elected our humanity to be His in Jesus Christ. Even so, this is not a matter of profane cogitation, but a sacrosanct reality that comes to us even if we don’t want to come to it.

John Webster, offers these words on the reality of the Church:

As the hearing church, the Christian community is wholly referred to the Word of God by which it is established. The church’s being is characterised by externality: it is ‘ectopic’, because its ‘place’ is in the being and act of the creative and communicative God of the gospel. There is, therefore, a certain strangeness about the church as a form of human life. To live as part of the church is to live at a certain distance from other modes of human fellowship and action. Because it is the creature of the Word, the church is not simply an outgrowth of natural human sociality or religious common interest and fellow-feeling. Its fellowship is properly to be understood as common origination from and participation in the presence of the divine self-gift. And because of this, the church is not primarily a visible social quantity but the invisible new creation. Even in its visible social and historical extension, the church is the presence in history of the new humanity which can never be just one more order of human society. The church is what it is because of the word of the gospel, and so it is primarily spiritual event, and only secondarily visible natural history and structured form of common life. Negatively, this means that the church is ‘invisible’, that is, not simply identical with its tangible shape as a human social order. Positively, this means that the church has true form and visibility in so far as it receives the grace of God through the life-giving presence of Word and Spirit. Its visibility is therefore spiritual visibility.[1]

To be clear, Webster is not promoting a docetic notion of the Church; as if the Church is swallowed up by its divine ground in the triune life. But what he is emphasizing is that the Church herself is not to be understood as an end unto itself. What should be understood, is that the Church doesn’t gain its reality from a turn into herself. Just as the humanity of Jesus Christ is grounded from outside itself, in the person of the eternal Logos of God, so too, the Church has her ecstatic ground in the vicarious humanity of Jesus Christ. This ought to keep the Church from thinking she has to do anything other than proclaim the Word of God who funds her. When the Church strays outside of her reality she attempts to create a reality based on her own immanent vision; or we might just speak more plainly: the Church, in this way, becomes an idol funded by its many idolaters.

There are many other implications we could tease out of Webster’s thoughts, but for space constraints the above should suffice.

[1] John Webster, Holy Scripture: A Dogmatic Sketch (Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, 2003), 47-8.

The Church’s ecstatic Existence and Evangel[istic] Mandate

The Church is for the world, because God in Christ is for the world:

For God so loved the world that He gave His only begotten Son, that whosoever believes in Him will not perish, but have everlasting life. -John 3:16

The Gospel gives us life eternal; the Gospel is God’s life for the world, for us, in Christ; thus, genuine life, of the eternal type, of God’s triune type, comes ecstatically to us. It comes to us from the vicarious humanity of Christ as ‘He becomes us that we might [by grace] become Him, and share in the superabundance of God’s triunity that has always already been. This ‘alien’ form of life becomes native to us only as we come into union with Christ (unio cum Christo); it, again, is a life given to us, afresh anew, as the grace of God in Christ by the Holy Spirit, continuously sustains and paracletes us with the risen and ascended body of the Son of Man. Since this life is extra nos (‘outside of us’) this presupposes or implies that life for all, for the world, is outside of them. That is to say, the new creation, that is the resurrected and ascended vicarious humanity of Christ, has universal inclusion. All of humanity is only humanity insofar that God is humanity for them, for us, in Jesus Christ. As such, the constitution of the Church necessarily includes all of humanity, insofar that the Christ’s humanity is archetypal humanity. This calls the Church, as the Church is constituted by the esse of God’s life for the world in Jesus Christ, to a kerygmatic existence. This is an existence that, by definition, is populated by ‘worldings,’ by people like us. This mission of God (missio Dei), as first given for the world ad extra in the economy of His life in the assumptio carnis, is one that requires for the Church’s flourishing (and telos) that she constantly goes out into the highways and byways of the world seeking the lost sheep for whom Christ has shed His eternal blood. The Church is a ‘go out into the nations and make disciples reality,’ or in the end, it is nothing but an incurved sociality of people who are living for themselves, in the name of Christ; thus, forming institutional bonds that keeps the world out there, and the Church ‘in here’—hence, quenching what, and who in fact the Church is ultimately for.

Matt Jenson writes this about the Gospel as Church:

. . . It is the very logic of the gospel which both judges and justifies Christian theology and then compels and frees it to engage widely and deeply with and in the world.

The material implication can be seen in ecclesiology. To be the church, the ekklesia, is to be that body of people who have been ‘called out’ — out of the world, yes, but also out of ourselves. It is to be those who live excurvatus ex se, finding our lives, ourselves in Christ and in one another. A relational account of ecclesiology, particularly one with an ecstatic dynamic, will yield a doctrine of the Church that emphasizes its missional, eschatological and, above all, doxological character. This is a Church open to the world, the future and God; but even more it is a Church open for the world, the future and God. Living in and as the Church is not living self-satisfied in the possession of eternal life but is instead living ecstatically in a continual outreach which hopes for an ever-widening ‘inner circle’ and lives towards the vision of Revelation 7 in which people from every tongue, tribe and nation bow in worship before the Lamb of God.[1]

The Apostle fleshes this very pattern out in the context of his Philippi hymn:

 5 Let this mind be in you which was also in Christ Jesus, 6 who, being in the form of God, did not consider it robbery to be equal with God, 7 but made Himself of no reputation, taking the form of a bondservant, and coming in the likeness of men. 8 And being found in appearance as a man, He humbled Himself and became obedient to the point of death, even the death of the cross. 9 Therefore God also has highly exalted Him and given Him the name which is above every name, 10 that at the name of Jesus every knee should bow, of those in heaven, and of those on earth, and of those under the earth, 11 and that every tongue should confess that Jesus Christ is Lord, to the glory of God the Father.12 Therefore, my beloved, as you have always obeyed, not as in my presence only, but now much more in my absence, work out your own salvation with fear and trembling; 13 for it is God who works in you both to will and to do for His good pleasure.14 Do all things without complaining and disputing, 15 that you may become blameless and harmless, children of God without fault in the midst of a crooked and perverse generation, among whom you shine as lights in the world, 16 holding fast the word of life, so that I may rejoice in the day of Christ that I have not run in vain or labored in vain.17 Yes, and if I am being poured out as a drink offering on the sacrifice and service of your faith, I am glad and rejoice with you all. 18 For the same reason you also be glad and rejoice with me.

Paul knew where His life came from, that is from the One who ‘humbled Himself and became obedient to the point of death, even the death of the cross.” As such, by the Spirit, he lived out of the life being poured into His, afresh anew, moment by moment, as the sustenance of His life has come for His life in Christ’s. This pattern is continued in Paul’s life as he ‘pours himself out as a drink offering,’ since this is the character of the ecstatic life He is receiving from Jesus. It is this freedom, the freedom of God, which God has graciously invited us into through becoming us in Christ, that Paul is compelled by the love of Christ for others; for the Church; for the Gentile world at large.

The Church in this instance isn’t a prolongation of the incarnation, instead it is a testimony, a witness to the fundamentum of its life as that is given to her by the risen and ascended body of Christ. The Church is not the head, but the ambassador to this world that Christ is risen, ascended, and coming again! The Church is the sanctorum communio only insofar that she receives God’s eternal life for the world in Jesus Christ. It is this ‘release of the prisoners’ that the Church is to proclaim loudly from the rooftops; that is, that Christ is Lord, and that because of who He is in the triune life, He is the One for the many. The Church has life only as that is ecstatically given to her, and the life that is given for her is, indeed, given for the sins of the world.

[1] Matt Jenson, The Gravity of Sin (New York: T&T Clark a Continuum Imprint, 2006), 190.

Against Clericalism through the Priesthood of Jesus Christ

Clericalism ought to be anathema. Whether that be Catholic, Orthodox, or Protestant, there is no High Priest save Jesus Christ. And yet, whether it be cult of personality, cult of Rome, cult of Alexandria, whatever iteration of the church we might be looking at, clericalism and its elevation of certain people as “authorities” in the church is present. A major premise of the Protestant Reformation was that clericalism goes immediately awry insofar that said clerics are merely human, and fallen human to boot. What God always already knew was that if the church was going to obtain, it would first have to obtain in His free choice to be one with and for us in Jesus Christ. With Him as the anchor of the church, of our souls, no matter what happens, no matter what inner or outer forces attempt to thwart His church, it shan’t prevail since He, Himself, the Theanthropos is the very ground and esse of His church; indeed as that has taken formation, and continuously does as event, in the glorified and vicarious humanity of Jesus Christ.

Tom Greggs offers a good word contra clericalism as he cites Blumhardt:

In the Reformation time a cry for this Zion arose in Luther’s soul. He sought a people freely surrendered to God’s grace, without self-righteous works, and in this he was right. But what must we say? The clerical element still muddied up the stream of the Reformation. Too many human beings wanted to rule. But Zion is not like this. God’s Zion is the fellowship of where Christ rules.[1]

The author to the Hebrews gets into this matter in the following way:

For every high priest taken from among men is appointed on behalf of men in things pertaining to God, in order to offer both gifts and sacrifices for sins; 2 he can deal gently with the ignorant and misguided, since he himself also is beset with weakness; 3 and because of it he is obligated to offer sacrifices for sins, as for the people, so also for himself. 4 And no one takes the honor to himself, but receives it when he is called by God, even as Aaron was.

5 So also Christ did not glorify Himself so as to become a high priest, but He who said to Him,

“You are My Son,
Today I have begotten You”;

6 just as He says also in another passage,

“You are a priest forever
According to the order of Melchizedek.”

7 In the days of His flesh, He offered up both prayers and supplications with loud crying and tears to the One able to save Him from death, and He was heard because of His piety. 8 Although He was a Son, He learned obedience from the things which He suffered. 9 And having been made perfect, He became to all those who obey Him the source of eternal salvation, 10 being designated by God as a high priest according to the order of Melchizedek.[2]

The old was merely a type, gaining any reality it had from its antitype. Christ’s priesthood, of the Melchizedekian order was archetypal priesthood, such that the Aaronic and Levitic priests were given priesthood only insofar as their priesthood gave way to its reality in Christ’s.

On analogy, this remains the reality. When ecclesial structures re-iterate what has already and finally been iterated in the office of Christ’s eternal priesthood, these are bad ecclesial structures (just as any tradition that nullifies the Word of God is bad tradition). The reduction, as Blumhardt rightly points out, with reference to Luther, is that either ‘Christ rules’ His church, or hirelings do, as they attempt to supplant and impose themselves, and their sense of self-authority and importance on the body of the risen Christ. Semper Reformanda

 

[1] Blumhardt, Action in Waiting, 82 cited by Tom Greggs, Dogmatic Ecclesiology: The Priestly Catholicity of the Church: Volume One (Grand Rapids, Michigan: Baker Academic, 2019), 161.

[2] Hebrews 5:1-10, NASB95.

Against the Inward Turned Church: Whether Catholic, Orthodox or Protestant

I am a “low church” evangelical. In other words, my ecclesial heritage has its chops in the congregational form of church government. I am also Free church, so not part of a state endorsed church (like we get with the Church of Scotland, Church of England et al.). But this doesn’t mean us “low-churchers” can’t struggle with the same type of inherent inward turn and focus that high churches have historically been characterized by. That is, whether the theory of the church I follow is grounded by looking to its clergy as its formative esse, or whether I look at the particular church programs (low church) that often typify the very existence of the local American evangelical church, what is similar to both is that they find their relative identity as the Church by looking, in abstract ways, into the ‘heart’ of their own self-asserted referent for what it actually means to be the Church. It isn’t the Church for the world, for the other, but the Church for itself, collapsed in on itself as an end in itself.

My thoughts above were inspired by Tom Greggs and the work he is currently doing in his ongoing trilogy on the Church. Here we pick up with him mid-thought on the problems the churches have, as the Church, when they think themselves in abstraction from her genuine, and ec-static, center in Jesus Christ.

When churches speak of their mission, it is all too often code for self-preservation and survival. The desire is not to go to the world with the good news that it is the world reconciled by God, but to expect those outwith the bounds of the church to come to the church so that—in this or that institutional form or congregation or denomination—it may continue. What has resulted has been an ecclesial “hyperactivity of panic.” The church has grasped after every possible means, manner, policy, idea, and mode of survival. It has resorted to change, to “make itself relevant,” and to employ management and business modes—all of which may instrumentally be good, but are problematically employed for the sake of the church’s own survival. The problem is that the desire to survive, and to focus on organization, is often indicative of the instrumentalization of the world for the sake of the church (which sees the world and its members as the means of its own continuation) and of a non-episcopally oriented focus on the polity of the church which sees the reality of the church’s being as resting on this or that structure, program, or organization. Usually, the emphasis is not continuity of service for the world but continuity of this or that church. The focus, once more, is inwards: the church exists towards and for the sake of itself and the salvation of its own members, and not towards and for the sake of the world and its redemption.[1]

Greggs continues with an antidote for the above problem:

This inwards-orientated self-understanding of the church must be reversed. The essential hierarchy should exist but in its inverse form: the church must understand itself as existing for the sake of the world; the ministers of the church as existing for the sake of the church for the sake of the world; and the overseers of the church as existing for the sake of the ministers who exist for the sake of the church who exist for the sake of the world. The Protestant family of churches would do well to learn from Hans KĂźng:

The phrase “priesthood of all believers” can all too easily remain a negative slogan—even and indeed precisely in Protestant theology—in order to reject the idea of priestly representation and mediation. This may well be a justified reaction to centuries of clericalism in theology and in practice. But it is essential that the positive significance of the priesthood of all believers is realized; the positive authorization and obligation must be recognized and practiced. . . . Hence we must ask what the concrete content of this priesthood of all believers really is.

What is required of us is to explain more fully that “concrete content” of the church’s priesthood. This is not only the priesthood which accounts for the internal ordering and dynamics of the church, but also the priesthood which expresses something of the “positive authorization” to engage in representation and mediation corporately for the world. The church has a priesthood, but this comes about only and strictly as the church corporately participates in the forms of life of its one and unique high priest, Jesus Christ, whose body the church becomes through the Holy Spirit, who forms the church into Christ’s body as the church participates intensively in the same Spirit-filled humanity Christ has.[2]

Greggs traces the inward turned notion of the Church back to Augustine’s notion of predestination, particularly as that is fleshed out in the City of God. Suffice it to say, there is a theo-logic that stands behind the inward turned notion of the Church, and its reality, in the end is what TF Torrance identifies as the dualism of Augustine’s Latin Heresy. That is to think of the people of God, and the people of not-God, in abstraction from God’s life for the World in Jesus Christ. The consequence of not thinking the life of God’s people from God’s life for the world in His second person in Jesus Christ, is to think God’s people in abstract ways leaving room for a vacuum to be filled by some after-thought provided for by the witty among us. In other words, when there are a people of God who thinks their identity into, rather than from the identity of God for the world in Christ, this type of abstract people of God will necessarily elevate their own notions, and construct their own superstructures as the bases for thinking a God-church relation. But it is precisely because of this abstract way of thinking, that is abstract from understanding the Church’s existence as grounded in and by the vicarious humanity of Jesus Christ, that said people of God are ‘thrust back upon themselves’ to think out what in fact it means to be the people of God; what it means to be the Church.

Hence, by adopting an abstract frame for thinking a God-church relation, such people of God will necessarily turn inward, instead of thinking their life extra nos (outside of us) in God’s life for us in Jesus Christ. To turn inward is the organic consequence of thinking churchly identity from a contractual frame vis-à-vis a relation to God, rather than from a relational-filial frame that God unilaterally provides for us in Himself, in Jesus Christ. In other words, when the people of God think their own identity from a decree of God wherein God has already decided that this or that individual will either be elect or reprobate, and this apart from a grounding in the life of God, it is up to the people of God to think out how it is that the Church in fact comes to have a solid, “assured,” ground in the life of God. The problem, though, that this type of people of God is confronted with is that they can never get back behind the decree of God’s absolute predestination, since the decree doesn’t come in the face of Christ, but instead is simply made in abstraction from God’s life for the world. It is only when people understand that the Church’s existence has come to be purely because before the foundation of the world, God freely chose, in the eternal Son, to assume our humanity, as His, and then give us His resurrected humanity as ours. As Greggs notes, this is how the Church becomes the Church; not by might, nor by power, but by the Spirit of the living and triune God. The Church in the relational-filial frame is not something we have abstractly constructed as our possession; no, properly understood, the relational-filial frame for the Church recognizes that the Church is simply an event that is given afresh anew to us in and from the vicarious humanity of Christ as we are “unioned” into Him by the Holy Spirit, as He hovers over our dark lives, just as He hovered over Mary’s womb, bringing life where there was none before. Thinking the Church this way, theologically, is the only way out of living the ‘churched’ life as if it is something we are sustaining, rather than her Head, her true sustainer, Jesus Christ. Kyrie eleison

[1] Tom Greggs, Dogmatic Ecclesiology: The Priestly Catholicity of the Church: Volume One (Grand Rapids, Michigan: Baker Academic, 2019), 128.

[2] Ibid., 128-29.