Discoursing Our Way to an Angelology; Philosophy V the Bible; Thomas V Barth

Barth attempts to offer a Biblical Angelology. In the process he surveys some of the most primary developments on an angelology, in the history, as those were offered by Dionysius and Thomas Aquinas. Just on that level his treatment is interesting and rewarding. But in the midst of that, since he is slavishly beholden to the Protestant โ€˜Scripture Principle,โ€™ he also identifies what I also take to be primary to a truly Christian presentation on the angels. As is typical, especially with reference to my own interests, Barth rightly recognizes the role that a prolegomena/hermeneutic will end up having on how a respective thinker will arrive at their veritable conclusion on what in fact angels (and demons) are. This a priori commitment to whatever hermeneutic someone deploys in their attempt to understand the supraphysical verities in Godโ€™s world, will in the end determine whether or not said thinker actually has a point of contact with Godโ€™s world or not.

In the following passage the reader will observe how Barth believes a philosophical/speculative attempt at developing a doctrine of the angels, as is present in Aquinasโ€™ guiding habit, ends up providing something highly interesting and imaginative to contemplate; but beyond that, for Barth, this speculation only generates a notion of โ€˜angelnessโ€™ that only can get as high as the virtuosoโ€™s genius. That is, Barth believes, for example, in Thomasโ€™ attempt to prove the existence of angels, that insofar that he stays correspondent within his self-referencing universe, that Thomas does indeed offer something on โ€œthe angelsโ€ that entails a coherence. But thatโ€™s what makes it something of interest to Barth, rather than something of substance (pun intended).

It cannot be contested that in a specific sphere and on a specific assumption proof is here given of the existence of a specific object interesting to the one who conducts the proof. It might be asked whether this sphere is real, and if so accessible, and if so able to be marked off in this way and approached with this assumption. It might be asked whether the proof furnished on this assumption and in this sphere is really conclusive and convincing either in detail or as a whole. But if we assume that everything is in order in this respect, and that Thomas has legitimately proved what he really could prove, there can be no doubt that with this assumption (or with the criticism or partial or total rejection of his demonstration) we are merely making philosophical and not theological decisions. Whether there are intellectual substances without bodies, and whether their existence can be proved in this or some other way, may be a question which is interesting and important in the sphere of philosophy. It may be one which can be discussed and even decided in this sphere. It may even be one which is decisive. But it is purely philosophical. On the basis of the Word of God attested in Holy Scripture we are not asked whether there are or are not substances of this kind, nor are we required to prove their existence in some way. If there are, and if their existence can be proved, this does not lead us to angels in the biblical sense of the term. And if there are not, and their existence cannot be proved, this is no argument against angels in the Christian sense. What are called angels in the Bible are not even envisaged in Thomasโ€™ proof of the existence of these substantiae separatae [distinct substances], let alone is anything said for or against their existence, or anything meaningful states about them at all, with the eight proofs. And what Thomas later constructed upon the demonstrated existence of these substantiae separatae is very different from a doctrine of angels in the Christian sense of the term. In his demonstration Thomas has given us philosophy and not theology, and he has done so far more exclusively than Dionysius. He does so occasionally refer to Holy Scripture, and therefore it may be asked whether he does not incidentally and in some sense contrary to his own intention make some contribution to theological knowledge. But fundamentally and as a whole he simply offers us a classical example of how not to proceed in this matter.[1]

In nuce, if the Christian is going to attempt to offer a genuinely Christian doctrine of angels, they will, as Barth so rightly presses, be committed to the biblical categories rather than the philosophical ones. And of course, it is this methodology that funds the whole of Barthโ€™s style of a confessional trinitarian-dialectical christologically conditioned way of doing theology from the reality of the Bible. The Christian philosophers among us would sneer at this; the classical theologians, the โ€˜Great Traditionersโ€™ in our midst, would mock; how ironic.

Stay Biblical my friends.

[1] Karl Barth,ย Church Dogmatics III/3 ยง50โ€“51 [393] The Doctrine of Creation: Study Editionย (London: T&T Clark, 2010), 104.

Evil, The ‘Ancient Menace’: Christ is Victor!

My recent readings in Barthโ€™s Church Dogmatics have me engaging with his development on a doctrine of nothingness (i.e., sin and evil). The particular section I am reading has been exceedingly edifying. The passage I am going to share from him is a summarizing type of statement of what he has been treating heretofore. As I was reading this section it gave me great hope to ponder the present and forthcoming realities, as those relate to Christโ€™s victory over nothingness-sin-evil, and all that entails eschatologically. It is hopeful to ruminate on the concrete victory of Christ vis-ร -vis the despair and delirium the current (seen) world order suffers under. Without this blessed hope, and the soon to come, glorious appearing of our great God and Savior, Jesus Christ, this world surely has no ultimate meaning or purpose. Without the Logos ensarkos all the world can do is to make an attempt at self-generating some type of existential meaning in the face of the absurdum of the abyss of darkness that enshrouds this world system. But Christ! Barth writes,

What is nothingness? In the knowledge and confession of the Christian faith, i.e., looking retrospectively to the resurrection of Jesus Christ and prospectively to His coming again, there is only one possible answer. Nothingness is the past, the ancient menace, danger and destruction, the ancient non-being which obscured and defaced the divine creation of God but which is consigned to the past in Jesus Christ, in whose death it has received its deserts, being destroyed with the consummation of the positive will of God which is as such the end of His non-willing. Because Jesus is Victor, nothingness is routed and extirpated. It is that which in this One who was both very God and very man has been absolutely set behind, not only by God, but in unity with Him by man and therefore the creature. It is that from whose influence, dominion and power the relationship between Creator and creature was absolutely set free in Jesus Christ, so that it is no longer involved in their relationship as a third factor. This is what happened to nothingness once and for all in Jesus Christ. This is its status and appearance now that God has made His own and carried through the conflict with it in His Son. It is no longer to be feared. It can no longer โ€œnihilate.โ€ But obviously we may make these undoubtedly audacious statements only on the ground of one single presupposition. The aspect of creaturely activity both as a whole and in detail, our consciousness both of the world and of self, certainly do not bear them out. But what do we really know of it as taught by this consciousness? How can this teach us the truth that it is really past and done with? The only valid presupposition is a backward look to the resurrection of Jesus Christ and a forward look to His coming in glory, i.e., the look of Christian faith as rooted in and constantly nourished by the Word of God. The knowledge and confession of Christian faith, however, inevitably entails the affirmation that by the divine intervention nothingness has lost the perpetuity which it could and must and indeed did have apart from this intervention. It can no longer be validly regarded as possessing any claim or right power in relation to the creature, as though it were still before and above us, as though the world created by God were still subject to and dominated by it, as though Christians must hold it in awe, as though it were particularly Christian to hold it in the utmost awe and to summon the world to share in this awe. It is no longer legitimate to think of it as if real deliverance and release from it were still an event of the future. It is obvious that in point of fact we do constantly think of it in this way, with anxious, legalistic, tragic, hesitant, doleful, and basically pessimistic thoughts, and this inevitably where we are neither able nor prepared to think from the standpoint of Christian faith. But it is surely evident than when we think in this way it is not from a Christian standpoint, but in spite of it, in breach of the command imposed with our Christian faith. If our thought is conditioned by the obedience of Christian faith, we have only one freedom, namely, to regard nothingness as finally destroyed and to make a new beginning in remembrance of the One who has destroyed it. Only if our thought is thus conditioned by the obedience of Christian faith is it possible to proclaim the Gospel to the world as it really is, as the message of freedom for the One who has already come and acted as the Liberator, and therefore of the freedom which precludes the anxiety, legalism and pessimism so prevalent in the world. We need hardly describe how throughout the centuries the Christian Church has failed to shape its thought in the obedience of Christian faith, to proclaim it to the world in this obedience, to live in this freedom and to summon the world to it. For this reason and contrary to its true nature, so-called Christianity has become a sorry affair both within and without. It is shameful enough to have to admit that many of the interpretations of nothingness which we are forced to reject as non-Christian derive their power and cogency from the fact that for all their weakness and erroneousness they attest a Christian insight to the extent that they do at least offer a cheerful view and describe and treat nothingness as having no perpetuity. It ought to be the main characteristic of the Christian view that it can demonstrate this more surely because on surer ground, more boldly because in the exercise and proclamation of the freedom granted to do so, and more logically because not in a venture but in simple obedience. We must not imagine that we serve the seriousness of Christian knowledge, life and proclamation by retreating at this point and refusing to realise and admit that the apparently audacious is the norm, the only true possibility. The true seriousness of the matter, and we may emphasise this point in retrospect of the whole discussion, does not finally depend upon pessimistic but upon optimistic thought and speech. From a Christian standpoint โ€œto be seriousโ€ can only mean to take seriously the fact that Jesus is Victor, the last word must always be secretly the first, namely, that nothingness has no perpetuity.[1]

Years ago, I read a book by Donald Bloesch called, Jesus is Victor!: Karl Barthโ€™s Doctrine of Salvation. Bloesch was treating the very themes we have been reading about in Barth directly. Barthโ€™s primary point (he has more than one) is that nothingness or sin or evil cannot be rightly known, but through the One who first stands against it for us. That God alone in Christ has the capacity to see what evil is, in light of His positive life of righteousness and holiness. For Barth, the world has no access to the concrete non-reality of nothingness. As such, they have no way of battling it. As an implication, this would be one reason, among many, that there is Victory alone in Christ alone. The world is ensnared by a trap that might seem like the Stoic fate of fatalism; but as Barth opines, in light of Christ, things are much worse than that. Which is why it takes all of God to be for all of us in the face of Jesus Christ. As Barth rightly emphasizes, there is no release from the anxiety, the dread, the tragic, the doom&gloom apart from the Light of Light of God piercing the darkness that we might come to more accurately understand what darkness, what nothingness actually entails. Not that we can grasp the inner-anatomy of nothingness, per se, but in Christ, we can finally, at the very least, recognize the depth dimensional reality that ensconces us within the binding of a dread-nothingness that God alone has the ability to know the depths of; indeed, as the Theanthropos, โ€œ. . . He does not will to be faithful to Himself except as He is faithful to His creature, adopting its cause and therefore constantly making the alien problem of nothingness His own.โ€[2]

Marantha!

[1] Karl Barth,ย Church Dogmatics III/3 ยง50โ€“51 [364] The Doctrine of Creation: Study Editionย (London: T&T Clark, 2010), 74โ€“5.

[2] Ibid., 68.

Miscellanies On Barth Reception and the Homoousious as Hermeneutic

I wrote these for other social media outlets of mine. I thought I’d share them here asย miscellanies.ย 

People reject Barth out of hand simply because they’ve been told that Barth is ultimately a liberal (still). But these same people have never actually read Barth enough to know whether that be true or not. Coming from someone, an evangelical conservative Christian (me), who has both read Barth and Barth literature extensively, and published on Barth, these people are simply living in a willful land of ignorance. Granted, Barth’s ๐‘œ๐‘’๐‘ข๐‘ฃ๐‘Ÿ๐‘’ is extensive. But there are ways into Barth that can introduce you to him without having to read all of him, or even a substantive amount of him. But most will never give him a fair hearing.

One reason Barth is pertinent to theology today is because he elides so much of the pop debates surrounding Reformed and non-Reformed theology; among many other important offerings. He truly offers an ๐‘’๐‘ฃ๐‘Ž๐‘›๐‘”๐‘’๐‘™๐‘–๐‘ ๐‘โ„Ž ๐ž๐ฏ๐š๐ง๐ ๐ž๐ฅ๐ข๐œ๐š๐ฅ way forward that is actually true and correspondent with the best of what even a North American evangelical theology has striven for.

There is a hermeneutical logic inherent to the โ„Ž๐‘œ๐‘š๐‘œ๐‘œ๐‘ข๐‘ ๐‘–๐‘œ๐‘  articulated and thought out at the Council of Nicaea (and post). It offers a ‘depth dimensional’ understanding of Holy Scripture that functions well within what can be called the ๐‘ ๐‘’๐‘›๐‘ ๐‘ข๐‘  ๐‘™๐‘–๐‘ก๐‘’๐‘Ÿ๐‘Ž๐‘™๐‘–๐‘ . That is, it understands that the Bible has an ontology (a givenness by God), and thus an antecedent context wherein it comes to make meaningful sense in the ๐‘๐‘Ÿ๐‘œ๐‘ ๐‘œ๐‘๐‘œ๐‘› (face) of God in Christ. It realizes that Scripture is simply a ๐‘ ๐‘–๐‘”๐‘›๐‘ข๐‘š (sign) to its ๐‘Ÿ๐‘’๐‘  (reality) in Christ in the triune life. The fact that so many would-be exegetes of Scripture gloss right past this in favor of a higher critical approach, ought to be a warning of what being a theologian of glory looks like rather than a theologian of the cross (seeing the unseen things as seen).

Barth, Bobby, and a Trinitarian Pietism

โ€ฆ This means that in spite of all his undeniable efforts to move away from Pietism, Barth was clearly too closely attached to it to be able to attack the innermost bastion of Pietism held by his reviewers. In the following section we will elaborate on the decisive point where he was still closely attached to Pietism in spite of everything.โ€

-Eberhard Busch, Karl Barth & the Pietists, trans. by Daniel W. Bloesch (Downers Grove, Illinois: IVP Academic, 2004), 65.

This is probably another reason I have so resonated with Barth over the years. My background, of course!, as an evangelical in North America, is indeed, Pietistic. But Pietism, of a certain ilk, has some โ€œEnlightenedโ€ problems; particularly, as that involves a turn to the subject (a navel-gazing spirituality). And yet, Pietism, insofar that it thinks of God as Father of the Son in the bond of love by the Holy Spirit, it is this kind of trinitarian Pietism that indeed has the right relational (and catholic) focus. I think Barth operates with this type of trinitarian Pietism, as I also attempt to.

Barth on Philosophy and Theology and Nothing

The relationship between philosophy and theology remains a varied thing, at least for me. In the Barth[ian] tradition there are a variety of takes on this relationship just the same. Barth himself sees a relative value to having an understanding of the various philosophies blowing about, whither and thither. But in the main, for Barth et al., an untoward appropriation and deployment of any philosophy vis-ร -vis a Christian theology, ends up presenting a highly delipidated theology that bears no resemblance to the genuine article as Self-revealed in the prosopon (face) of Jesus Christ. Of note, as Barth is engaging with a doctrine of God and Nothingness, here we have an example of how he thinks of the Catholicโ€™s deployment of the Aristotelian philosophical categories in the grammarization of their respective theology. As you read the following passage from Barth you will also notice him referring to these โ€˜modern thinkers,โ€™ in regard to their respective impact upon the unfurling of an Enlightened and post-Enlightened theological offering (he is referring, in context, to his treatment of Heidegger and Sartre on a metaphysic and doctrine of nothingness per their respective existentialist [atheistic, in a way] theological offerings). So, a lot going on here: but as an evangelical calvinist I am wont to press Barthโ€™s comment on the impact of Aristotle on the doing of Latin theology in general; he sees it as fallacious, as do I (as I/we have detailed with our Evangelical Calvinism books, and my blog posts here over the decades).

. . . And the position which Roman Catholicism gives to Aristotle as the philosopher par excellence was and is a very remarkable but also a very questionable matter. In theology, at least, we must be more farsighted than to attempt a deliberate co-ordination with temporarily predominant philosophical trends in which we may be caught up, or to allow them to dictate or correct our conceptions. On the other hand, there is every reason why we should consider and as far as possible learn from the typical philosophical thinking of the day. As we have listened to Leibniz and Scliliermacher [sic], so now we listen to these modern thinkers at a point which is particularly important for them and in which they may be able to teach or warn us in our own understanding of the theme.[1]

The theme, as already noted, has to do with a doctrine of nothingness (rather than somethingness). But again, what I wanted to draw our attention to was simply the way that Barth thinks a relationship between theology and philosophy. He doesnโ€™t see no value in understanding the philosophers of the day, whatever period, and how their respective inklings might create a cultural milieu, which in turn might impact and even distort a reception of a genuinely conceived Christian theology. Indeed, it is primarily in this negative type of a way, even as it might contribute to the construction of a positively framed Christian theology, wherein Barth sees a legitimate placement and engagement with philosophy. Even so, in the end, what stands primary for Barth is the Word of God.

[1] Karl Barth,ย Church Dogmatics III/3 ยง50โ€“51 [334] The Doctrine of Creation: Study Editionย (London: T&T Clark, 2010), 44.

Barth’s Leibniz on an Anthropology and Nothingness

As I continue on with my linear read through of Karl Barthโ€™s Church Dogmatics I have come across a small print section in CD III/3 ยง50, 30 wherein Barth is engaging with a doctrine of nothingness/sin. In this particular section he is commiserating with that Teutonic, Leibnizโ€™s understanding on such matters. Without providing the necessary context I am simply going to drop some of my reflection on this following:

Leibnizโ€™s anthropology, according to Barthโ€™s reading, was highly monistic in regard to what it means to be human vis a vis Godโ€™s perfections. Indeed, a rather dreary prospect for the Eschaton. In the sense, that humanity by its necessary constitution must always live with the negation of privation within themselves in order to remain creaturely. But this would mean that a genuine participation or beatific vision in the eschatological life would never obtain. Because for Barthโ€™s Leibniz, if such obtainment were to occur this would mean that humanity has crossed the Rubicon of divinity; viz., humanity would not just be like the Son, the eternal Logos, by grace, but by nature. So, true perfection, in Leibnizโ€™s frame, always must remain out of reach insofar that what it means to be human for him, to be creaturely, is to always already have an in-built imperfection of the good as the primary component of what it means to be human.

Go in peace, be ye warmed and filled.

The Christological Men: Karl Barth and TF Torrance

Barth and TF Torrance are the only modern theologians I have come across who if you don’t start with radically construed Chalcedonian premises, you won’t get. Their dialect is strictly christologically conditioned all the way down. This is one reason I think so many evangelical and conservative theologians of today write them off as incoherent. For example, theologians who harvest purely from the Post Reformed orthodox (pro), and some of the mediaeval theologians, will attempt to read Barth and TFT through the speculative, decretal categories they have imbibed vis-ร -vis their recovery of said pro and med. theologians. And yet, this is precisely why I took such a liking to both TFT and Barth. I am really just a Bible reader, and as a result christological theology had an immediate resonance with me. Barth and TFT’s theology was the most organic move I could make as someone who also sees the value of doing Christian Dogmatic and systematic theology; i.e., engaging with the inner-theologic of the text of Holy Scripture.

This is why I will always remain confused by evangelical and other conservative theologians who write Barth and TFT off. TFT, a named protopresbyter of the Greek Orthodox church (even as a Church of Scotland churchman), and Barth called purportedly, by Pope Pius XII, ‘the greatest theologian since Thomas Aquinas,’ have a breadth and depth among the church catholic that most theologians since the Protestant reformation have never had. Beyond that, as already mentioned by illusion, I see Barth and TFT actually continuing on within the conciliar Christianity started at Nicaea, Constantinople, and Chalcedon in particular, in ways that no one else has. In my view, there are no modern or contemporary theologians who are so principially Christ conditioned in their methodology and devotion, as are Barth and TF Torrance.

c’est la vie

Iconoclasm and Karl Barth: On the Third Deadly Sin, Smoking

To be or not to be iconoclastic, that is the question. Not really though. As a Free low-church evangelical I have no problem with using artistic renditions of Jesus, and many other biblical and Christian characters and events that have significance within the Christian story. Indeed, this more broadly brings up the issue of how Christians ought to use pictures and art within their own narratival schemas and presentations. For me, an issue has been on how or if I should use pictures of Karl Barth. If you have read me for any season of time it is clear to you by now that I am a huge benefactor of the theological themes, categories, and grammars developed by Karl Barth. But as we all know (or most of us do), Barth comes with his own barnacles; many would consider them to be totally disqualifying of him as a Christian theologian. The primary issue with Barth, of course, is his relationship with Charlotte von Kirschbaum; his live in โ€˜second wife.โ€™ I have virally engaged with this matter back in 2017, which you can find an index for here. More mildly than that particular sin, Barth was also a smoker; not a chain smoker that I know of, but he smoked nonetheless. From the Fundamentalist-evangelical background I have grown up within smoking is one of the three deadly sins.[1] And so to share a picture of Barth, which I have said picture, showing him with a โ€œcigarilloโ€ in hand could be another stumbling block for folksโ€™ reception of Barth all by itself.

Should I share pictures of Karl Barth without opprobrium; or should I share pictures of Barth simply because I respect his theology, even if I reject his sin? I typically share pictures of Barth when I am engaging directly, or even indirectly with his theology. This seems to be an appropriate usage of said pictures. Currently, there are some pastors, who also have reach on X, who are under fire for โ€œslanderingโ€ other high-profile leaders among them; whether this is done anonymously (in Josh Buiceโ€™s case), or in person (in Bryan Chapelleโ€™s case). Indeed, these folks are losing their ministries for their ostensible slander of others. Should their disqualifying sins keep people from engaging with their past teachings, or should they still be respected; insofar that said teachings are respectable and truly bear witness to the living Christ? Should they be referenced, and even pictured in days to come; even in the name of showing them respect, insofar that their prior witnesses commend that?

What remains the case, whether we are iconoclasts or not, is that we have all sinned (and continue to) and fall short of the glory of God. Should I share pictures of Karl Barth in an honoring way, or should it only be when I am critical of the man and his sin[s]? Is Godโ€™s witness and work in the lives of His people greater than the person themselves; even while including the person being worked on? Indeed, greater is He who is in us than he who is in the world. While we are simul justus et peccator (despite Jason Staplesโ€™ critique of said doctrine), it can be said that those who are Christโ€™s are Christโ€™s indeed, insofar that Christ is for us rather than against is. That even when we fall into, or even live in particular sins (consciously or unconsciously), His mercy and grace in the face of Jesus Christ triumphs over all of it. It allows us to look at the fly in the ointment, and still see the beauty and value of the ointment; to understand that ultimately the overwhelming of Christโ€™s โ€œointmentedโ€ body floods into the sinnersโ€™ life pushing out and dissolving said flies that might seek to putrefy the work of God in the person of Jesus Christ.

I understand this is a bit stream of consciousness, but hopefully something coherent has come through. Sharing pictures of Barth for me is just a brute fact in a certain way. He just is who he is by the grace of God in Jesus Christ. The lesson we might derive from this is that this same grace applies to us and our โ€œfliesโ€ just the same. Soli Deo Gloria.

[1] Personally, I think smoking is a deadly habit with some nasty side-effects associated with it; both science and experience bear this out.

Against the Magical Faith of the Pelagians and Others

In my online wanderings recently the locus of Christian faith has come up. It is oriented around the age-old debate of the origination of faith; and in fact, what faith is. Is justificatory faith before God a quality inherent to the human (so, a Pelagian frame), or is it a reality that is alien to and outside of human agency that is given as gift to humanity (whether that be given to certain โ€˜electedโ€™ humans or to all of humanity)? I would argue, along with Karl Barth, that justificatory faith is an outside of us reality that comes to us as Godโ€™s gift to us in and through the vicarious human agency of the Logos ensarkos, Jesus Christ. In this way โ€œsaving faithโ€ is first an ingress of the Sonโ€™s faith for us; it is His trust in the Fatherโ€™s will for us, even as that is actualized in His freely chosen humanity for us (Logos incarnatus). It is by these means that faith can be said to be a capacity of humanity, even while that capacity is grounded in the divinely grounded person of Jesus Christ pro nobis (for us). The upshot of this is that the integrity of both God and humanity is upheld, insofar that faith before God is understood as a capacity freely given by God to humanity through the vicarious humanity of Jesus Christ; the archetypal humanity that reflects what a genuinely created humanity looks like as the triune God has always already intended.

Karl Barth writes,

We may dismiss briefly, on the one hand the idea that faith is a magical quality imparted to man and enabling him to surpass the nature given him at creation, and on the other idea that is an activity which man produces of himself simply by exercising a capacity which belongs to him by nature. The true source of faith is the Word of God. Faith, therefore, is a new activity which man cannot of himself decide to undertake, and which he has no power of himself to undertake. When it takes place, faith is a historical determination of human existence, a determination in the history of salvation. Butโ€”in opposition to the first viewโ€”it is an awakening of man to his own activity which as such is not merely within the sphere of his own creaturely nature, but corresponds at every point to the highest natural determination of his creatureliness; just as the incarnation of the Son of God, which is the great pattern of the origin of faith, means not only a completely unmerited liberation of human nature, but also and for that very reason a restitution of its highest creaturely determination.

We may also dismiss, on the one hand the idea that faith is a blind subjection to a law imposed upon the will and understanding from without, and on the other the idea that it is a conviction of the truth and importance of certain objective facts, a conviction which is established and attained by man himself, and then, and for this reason, chosen and adopted by man himself. As opposed to the second idea, faith is, of course, an arrest and commitment in which man is set free from his own caprices and acquires a Lord whom he must follow. It is a new strange light shining upon man from above. Butโ€”in contrast to the first ideaโ€”it not only shines upon human life, and therefore the human will and understanding, from without, but it also illuminates them from within. It does no close our eyes, but opens them. It does not destroy our intellect and compel us to sacrifice it, but it sets it free just as in a definite sense it captivates it, i.e., for itself. It does not break down our will, but sets it in free movement; just as the incarnation of the Son of God, the pattern of our nature of faith, is actual and visible not only in the perfect obedience but also in the perfect sovereignty of the activity of Jesus Christ.[1]

As previously noted, as Barth has helped to develop, Christian faith rightly understood, is a faith that comes to us, not of our own strength or human nature, but by Godโ€™s free gift and choice to become us in Jesus Christ, that we, by that grace, might become Him as co-heirs with His dearly beloved Son, Jesus Christ.

There is a way to maintain both the integrity of God and the integrity of humanity vis-ร -vis the reality of justificatory faith; indeed, this way is forged by the inbreaking of Godโ€™s life for the world in and through the womb of Mary. It is by these means that we can think of faith from within a non-competitive relationship between God and humanity; surely, as that has been begotten in the Son of God become man. The online, and superficial debates surrounding this issue, should take heart; there is a better, indeed a Christian way to parse the false-binary made by our own untamed discursive imaginations.

 

[1] Karl Barth,ย Church Dogmatics III/3 ยง49 [247] The Doctrine of Creation: Study Editionย (London: T&T Clark, 2010), 247โ€“8.

On the Jews: God’s Free Choice

As Barth rightly argues, the Jewish people have been a non-people while at the same time the people of God throughout the millennia. Particularly after the destruction of Jerusalem in 70 AD, by Titus Vespasian of the Roman empire, the Jewish people strangely have wandered about throughout the nations, seemingly in a continued exile and disrepute, such that they are scorned; but mysteriously so. People donโ€™t really understand why they are anti-Semitic versus being anti-Laotian, or against some other identifiable people group. There is something much deeper, much more spiritual to anti-Semitism than the profane mind could come to fathom. The Jewish people were unconditionally and freely chosen of God to mediate the Savior of the world to the nations. Their existence is not contingent upon their own inner-existence, but upon Godโ€™s continuing choice to uphold them as His elect people within their vocation to bring the Son of David, Jesus Christ to all the nations. That is to say, the Jewish people havenโ€™t remained the enigmatic people that they are for all these years because of something โ€œspecialโ€ about them per se. They have remained a people, in spite of themselves, purely because God freely chose to covenant with them in a way that was as peculiar to them, as it was for Him to choose Mary to birth the Theanthropos into the world so that the world, including the Jews, might be saved. Barth says it like this:

. . . And from the standpoint of the Christian message the reason for this is that Godโ€™s decree in His election of this people and covenanting with it is an eternal unshakeable decree. The people was an unfaithful people. From the very first it willed to be a people of like others, to have a king and a history like others. But this could not alter the faithfulness of God, and it has not altered it right up to the present time. It was not altered even by the provisional judgments and finally the definitive judgment which in the year 70 ended its existence in identity, or at any rate similarity, without her peoples. . ..[1]

โ€œfor the gifts and theย calling of Godย are irrevocable.โ€ โ€“Romans 11:29

[1] Karl Barth,ย Church Dogmatics III/3 ยง49 [217] The Doctrine of Creation: Study Editionย (London: T&T Clark, 2010), 219.