Phil Johnson on the ‘Feminization’ of the Church

I wonder what you, dear reader, think of the following snippet of this message from Phil Johnson (in case you don’t know, Johnson is Executive Producer of John MacArthur’s radio ministry Grace To You, as well as MacArthur’s editor for his many books, and also an in demand speaker [he seems to be gaining more and more notoriety within parts of Evangelicalism—even though Johnson is a heavy critic of American Evangelicalism in general [as am I], and also founder of popular biblioblog, Pyromaniacs); here’s the video:

There has been a lot of hub-bub, as of late around John Piper’s comments on the masculination of Christianity; and yet Phil’s message has seemed to slip under the radar of some. Obviously Johnson is a staunch complementarian, and this informs the rather rugged tenor of his communique’ (by the way, I am also a complementarian—but of a softer version). Anyway, I just wonder what you all think of Johnson’s message; and the response he received as he delivered it at Shepherd’s Conference 2010?

26 thoughts on “Phil Johnson on the ‘Feminization’ of the Church”

  1. this is pure garbage. I don’t know where to begin. It is just silly. If he has a point it has to do with the sentimentalization of spirituality (which would actually be a good point). But to equate that with femininity and to equate that femininity with weakness, all for the easy laughs of a typical locker-room crowd, is just a disgusting misuse of the pulpit with little to no biblical warrant. it is just gross.

  2. @Jon,

    I agree with you. I think the laughter of the audience is what really put it over the top for me! The sentimentalization of the spirituality is an ethos, as you know, within our Evangelicalism—or our pietism.

  3. I kept expecting Mark Driscoll to jump out at any given moment. But I got to about 45 and turned it off, then turned it back on. I like how he uses ‘womanly’ as an insult…oi. And God forbid we talk about emotional hurts, or relationships, or needs…because we all know those aren’t legitimate things to talk about. Oi…this irks me.

  4. WF,

    Yes, that irks me too. It’s as if Jesus never look out upon the nagging masses, and had compassion on them like a Shepherd with his sheep. But this is what you get when your God is shaped by a metaphysic of impersonal Law … you get cold impersonal spirituality.

  5. I’m astounded by this man’s stuipidity – there’s no other word for it. As has already been pointed out it is incredibly offensive to equate femininity with weakness.

    In general I’m very tired of all the talk in evangelicalism about masculinity. I feel most of it, like what Johnson is talking about here, is just cultural. It is unbelievable that so many Christians are blind to their assumption that our cultural values are the same as God’s moral values. I also feel that much of the emphasis upon manliness in some churches actually just results in prideful self-righteous men getting to hold on to their sin of pride and self-righteousness. I recently had a son and it got me thinking about what is masculinity; what does it really mean for men to act like men. I wrote a post about it on my blog if you’re interested. http://www.thethousandmarch.com/apps/blog/show/12194228-manliness-what-i-will-teach-my-son – I wouldn’t expect you to agree with all of it (for one I’m not a complementarian) but you might find it interesting.

    I think the Church should not be worrying about teaching men how to be manly. I think the church should be concentrating on teaching men and women to be Christlike. I don’t care if my pastor can fight, I care if my pastor can help equip me to be a disciple of Jesus.

  6. Hi Bobby!
    Chuck Swindoll comes to mind right away, I really like his message, but it seems really out of phase with much of the “masculine” church. At some point, I hope he preaches about other stuff form the pulpit, and I’m sure this is only one facet of his total message; this is just what his radio ministry is about. There are a couple of other guys too, in family ministry. But that is so much of what Jesus’ total message was: to woo, not to force, He would not break a bruised read, nor quench a smoking flax. He showed so much force in weakness. He could have, by deciding so, made everyone present bow to Him, or He could have reduced them to ashes. I think the danger is rather that men work out there masculinity in the flesh and try to force their family into right spiritual relationship with them.
    Imagine this scenario: “Honey, you keep telling me you’re sorry you lied about doing your homework. We are going to have meetings about this every week with the pastor and sunday school teacher, and…sign this contract. There are four copies for you to sign.”

  7. The logistics and tactics used to forward this perception are in keeping with those who forward this theology. I am equally, if not more so, concerned with the enormous void that provides the rich soil necessary to cultivate both the theology and this particular ideology. May God bless us all to realize our full identity in Christ.

  8. In theology as well as biology – too much male testosterone leads to a dominance-orientation,, to “lording it over” others and overbearing leadership (in church and family). Not really surprising (here and with Driscoll) – this is what you get when you let an un-biblical Sovereignty obscure Mercy, as can be the case with classical Calvinism.

  9. My wife said after she heard me listening to the clip, “he just wants to be an asshole and not feel bad about it.” Sorry about the cuss word Bobby, I know you don’t like them. The perspective of strong and weak being related to gender is a non starter for any discussion in the modern world. When one relates weakness with women they are showing that thet haven’t really thought too long about what they are saying and how it relates to the real world. Anyway, I thought the church was supposed to be a “bride” not the groom.

  10. @Nathan,

    All I can say to your comment is, Amen! I’ll come read your post.

    @Duane,

    Yes, your reference to smoking flax is highly apropos; you would make Richard Sibbes very happy ๐Ÿ™‚ .

    @Kc,

    Amen. an “In Christ” theology changes everything; which is reflected in tone, etc. Thank you!

    @Wayne,

    Amen. Testosterone was front and center in the tailoring of this message; right down to all the little jabs and jokes that Johnson preached to his choir. And yes, this is a symptomatic example of classic calvinism at work; the conception of the God of classic Calvinism—at least in the MacArthurite strain of that.

    @Kenny,

    “Anyway, I thought the church was supposed to be a โ€œbrideโ€ not the groom.” This is great! Absolutely, this is it!!

  11. I think this guy is a bully – enthralled to a culturally derived notion of masculinity which attaches itself to brutish power and authority, transposed onto his view of what Scripture says about the church – and just loves the fact that he has a receptive audience who clap at his mean-spirited comments.

    But then I’ve always been a sissy.

  12. @Mark,

    Phil Johnson is very American, and he inhabits a sub-culture that is very John MacArthurite and specifically Fundamentalist—and when I say that I mean ‘Law-driven’. You sissy ๐Ÿ˜‰ .

  13. Hey Bobby, could you clarify what you mean when you say “this is a symptomatic example of classic calvinism at work; the conception of the God of classic Calvinism”? I know you note “the MacArthurite strain” but I’d hesitate to call John MacArthur a Calvinist, and certainly not a classic one.

  14. Hi Shep,

    See my post, Rainbow of Calvinism http://growrag.wordpress.com/2012/01/28/the-rainbow-of-calvinism-2/ . MacArthur would be #2 on my list. But when I say classic Calvinist I am not referring to a particular expression, or even what some consider the mother of expressions found in the post-Reformed orthodox and or Covenantal/Federal Calvinism (which is the standard you’re probably using for MacArthur’s style). I am referring to the metaphysics that, in general, stand behind many expressions of theology in the West; whether that be found in Roman Catholicism (and the disparate orders and emphases), post-Reformed orthodoxy and Federal Calvinism, Baptist Calvinism (Spurgeon), Dispensational non-Covenantal Calvinism (MacArthur), Hedonist Calvinism (Piper) and/or Arminianism. The metaphysic I am referring to is substance metaphysics and its other designation is classical theism (see this post http://growrag.wordpress.com/2012/01/21/the-young-restless-reformed-matt-chandler-mark-driscoll-kevin-deyoung-justin-taylor-getting-to-know-their-calvinist-history-and-present/); which is Thomas Aquinas’ synthesis of Aristotelian categories with Christian Theology—and all of the aforementioned come directly from this kind of synthesis (e.g. with substance metaphysics). This starts with a concept of Godness, grounded in natural theology or an analogy of being; and extrapolating back from this ground, the God of the Bible is conceived from this vantage point—you necessarily (in a theological accounting), end up with a God who is the Unmoved mover, Monadic substance, and quite impersonal. Which is why we can end up with rather cold and impersonal remarks from someone like Phil Johnson; it’s because of his informing Theology Proper (or Improper as the case may be!). Here is TF Torrance sketching this kind of situation; his analysis is directed at Federal Westminster Calvinism, but is applicable to classical theism (and its many expressions, as just noted) in general:

    In Chapter One on John Knox and the Scottish Reformation, I have offered a general account of the deep doctrinal change that took place, but in the succeeding chapters I have tried to focus on the main issues that arose as a result of the adherence of the Church of Scotland to the Westminster Confession of Faith. Following upon the teaching of the great Reformers there developed what is known as โ€˜federal theologyโ€™, in which the place John Calvin gave to the biblical conception of the covenant was radically altered through being schematised to a framework of law and grace governed by a severely contractual notion of covenant, with a stress upon a primitive โ€˜covenant of worksโ€™, resulting in a change in the Reformed understanding of โ€˜covenant of graceโ€™. This was what Protestant scholastics called โ€˜a two-wingedโ€™, and not โ€˜a one-wingedโ€™ covenant, which my brother James has called a bilateral and a unilateral conception of the Covenant. The former carries with it legal stipulations which have to be fulfilled in order for it to take effect, while the latter derives from the infinite love of God, and is freely proclaimed to all mankind in the grace of the Lord Jesus Christ. It was the imposition of a rigidly logicalised federal system of thought upon Reformed theology that gave rise to many of the problems which have afflicted Scottish theology, and thereby made central doctrines of predestination, the limited or unlimited range of the atoning death of Christ, the problem of assurance, and the nature of what was called โ€˜the Gospel-offerโ€™ to sinners. This meant that relatively little attention after the middle of the seventeenth century was given to the doctrine of the Holy Trinity and to a trinitarian understanding of redemption and worship. Basic to this change was the conception of the nature and character of God. It is in relation to that issue that one must understand the divisions which have kept troubling the Kirk [church] after its hard-line commitment to the so-called โ€˜orthodox Calvinismโ€™ of the Westminster Standards, and the damaging effect that had upon the understanding of the World of God and the message of the Gospel. . . . (Thomas F. Torrance, โ€œScottish Theology,โ€ x-xi)

    While MacArthur & co. have eschewed Covenantal Calvinism; they have not eschewed this ‘rigidly logicalised God’ that we find at the eye of the Calvinist storm in general. Does this help clarify?

  15. Bobby,

    Wow, that was a much more detailed and in-depth explanation than what I expected. I understand the metaphysic to which you are referring – though referring to it as “classic Calvinism” rather than substance metaphysic or classical theism threw me for a loop. Thanks for clarifying.

    Blessings,
    Shep

  16. @whitefrozen, I think your definition of Calvinist must be much different from my own. MacArthur holds to the five points of Dort, and that’s about it. ๐Ÿ™‚

  17. Shep,

    I often use “classic Calvinism” at the blog here to identify various strands of Calvinism—whether that be your Westminster ๐Ÿ˜‰ , MacArthur’s 5 point hybrid version, etc. I know that you understand all of this with your teacher at hand—Webster (lucky!) ๐Ÿ™‚ .

  18. Bobby,

    You occasionally post videos that are 45 min in length and I didn’t want to watch another 45 min video of Phil talking. So, I read your post and all the comments before attempting to watch. Only after clicking on the YouTube image does the short length of the video appear. Since it was short, I watched it. This was one time where reading about up front really helped, even though the video was a bit more over the top than I anticipated from the comments. Incidentally, most figure skaters I’ve ever seen are so in shape they could probably kick some pretty good tail. ๐Ÿ™‚

  19. I am usually at least a week late to the party…. But I always manage to find something to eat.

    I admit bobby that your question was very open ended and so what appeared to come to mind to your readers was the style of the message – language and choice of metaphor. That is fine. It was convicting for me. Just today in an email to a woman friend of mine, I spoke of myself as one who was crying like a 4th grade girl. I am thankful for the rebuke… you know, from the HS. I receive it.

    But what I didn’t hear from anyone (I may have missed it) was comment on the substance of what he was trying to communicate about how the church hears the Word today.

    What do the pastors among you think about the pressure that can come upon you over difficult passages? Who do you fear more – The Lord of the Word or the people you proclaim it to? That is a question that I have to ask myself almost every week.

    The pulpit is a Real place. And come to think of it, it is not for women… of either sex :- ]

  20. Will,

    From my perspective—There is no substance to what Johnson is trying to communicate, other than mean spirited ungracious taunting of people who need a gentle compassionate Shepherd and not a hiriling who will beat them over the head. Yes, what has been called Therapeutic Moralistic Deism runs wide and far in American Evangelical Christianity, but that’s no excuse for the kind of fleecing of the sheep that Johnson is advocating for in this sickly message of his. I’ve read his blogs for years, and I understand his tone and context; and again, there is nothing in it but androgynous spite for broken people. Clearly there is shallowness and flimsiness coming from many American stages (Pulpits aren’t used anymore … unfortunately); but the answer to that isn’t a raised voice and appeal to the people (Johnson). It is reasoned and thoughtful articulation of deep and substantive teaching from God’s Word; the Word that magnifies Jesus who is full of grace and truth (truth w/o grace isn’t truth).

    I think the most frustrating thing about what he was communicating was his usage of an analogy of the woman as a symbol of all things weak. And then he employs this analogy to mock people who are broken and hurting; the very people who need sound theology and biblical teaching (and I mean the “leadership” in American Churches). Anyway, I hadn’t listened to this video since I posted it, and I just re-listened; it kindled the same spark in my gut that it did the first time, it is very aggravating to say the least.

    PS. You’ve read the Pyromaniacs in the past, you know what I am talking about.

  21. RE: Phil Johnson on the โ€˜Feminizationโ€™ of the Church

    As only a recent first time reader of this blog, I’ll comment, even if the article may be a little stale.
    Regarding “Feminization” or appropriating too much “Masculinity” in the Church, let me simply say – keep it balanced, enough to encourage more men coming to a service.
    Many traditional hymns seem to be more of an inspiration to older men in my opinion.
    I can also appreciate praise chorus’ that have quality lyrics along with pleasing melody, rhythm, & harmony.

  22. Hi Duane,

    I am really not so interested in this at the moment ๐Ÿ˜‰ ,but thanks for the link. I need to close down commenting on old posts like this, my attention span is not here at the moment :-).

Comments are closed.