A Christian Statement of Scripture V. An un-Christian Statement

Here is a very dynamic statement on Scripture and its placement within the life of God’s people; finding its continuity in ongoing witness for those people in the ‘point and purpose’ of their existence, Jesus Christ.

[T]he source of all our knowledge of God is his active revelation of himself. We do not know God against his will, or behind his back, as it were, but in accordance with the way in which he has elected to disclose himself and communicate his truth in the historical-theological context of the worshipping people of God, the Church of the Old and New Covenants. This is the immediate empirical fact with which the Holy Scriptures of the Old and New Testaments are bound up. They were composed under the inspiration of the Holy Spirit, and in the providence of God have been handed on to us as the written form of the Word of God. They are the Scriptures of the people of Israel, for Israel was the selected medium of God’s revelation in which his Word operated prophetically in the life and understanding of a particular historical community in order to provide within mankind a place where divine revelation might be translated appropriately into human speech and where it might be assimilated and understood in a communicable form by all humanity. And they are the Scriptures of the Christian Church, for the Church was the appointed sphere in which the historical self-revelation of God through Israel, gathered up and transcended and fulfilled in Jesus Christ the Word made flesh, is given an evangelical form in the apostolic witness and tradition, kerygma and didache, through which the crucified and risen Lord Jesus Christ himself continues to meet men and women as the living Word of God and to impart himself to them as the Way, the Truth, and the Life, apart from whom, as our Lord claimed, no one has access to the Father. [Thomas F. Torrance, Divine Meaning: Studies in Patristic Hermeneutics, (Edinburgh: T&T Clark, 1995), 5]

I would suggest that this is a properly articulated and understood ontology and/or doctrine of Scripture and its placement within the grasp (so to speak) of God’s people; Christians. This is in contrast to the classical understanding of Scripture, here given voice by Evangelical Systematic Theologian, Millard Erickson:

[T]he epistemological question is simply, How do we know? Since our basis for knowing and holding to the truth of any theological proposition is that the Bible teaches it, it is of utmost importance that the Bible be found truthful in all of its assertions. If we should conclude that certain propositions (historical or scientific) taught by the Bible are not true, the implications for theological propositions are far-reaching. To the extent that evangelicals abandon the position that everything taught or affirmed by Scripture is true, other bases for doctrine will be sought. This might well be either through the resurgence of philosophy of religion or, what is more likely given the current “relational” orientation, through basing theology upon behavioral sciences, such as psychology of religion. But whatever the form that such an alternative grounding takes, there will probably be a shrinking of the list of tenets, for it is difficult to establish the Trinity or the virgin birth of Christ upon either a philosophical argument or the dynamics of interpersonal relationships. [Millard J. Erickson, Introducing Christian Doctrine, 62]

The nuance between the two statements is quite subtle to the naked eye, but there is one. The primary distinction between these two articulations is that the former does not make the veracity of Scripture contingent upon creation, or proving it to be so. Instead Torrance’s statement places Scripture within the divine speech which actually is life giving and formative to his people’s existence, as his people, indeed. The latter thesis statement, from Erickson, places humanity (in general) prior to God’s Word in Scripture; such that its veracity can only said to be so through the apologetic works of God’s people making it so. In other words, for Erickson, and the Evangelical sphere in general, Scripture is annexed to the realm of philosophical (epistemological) materiality in a way that leaves it out in the open until Christians can prove its reliability. But this is exactly backwards!

The question is who comes first? 1) God, 2) creation, 3) Scripture (Torrance); or, 1) Creation, 2) Scripture, 3) God (Erickson)? The latter set of questions see Scripture placed in the secular realm of philosophy; the former set of questions see Scripture located in the sacred sphere of salvation. Which means that Erickson’s approach cannot, theologically, be said to endorse a particularly Christian doctrine of Scripture—only Torrance’s can, because his does not make Scripture’s prophetic witness dependent upon humanity but upon God’s free voice of ‘Lordness’—since Erickson’s approach moves from a view of creation that ultimately sees creation as a mode of existence that determines its own fate and reality (this is a very modern move, but not a very Christian one).

 

 

20 thoughts on “A Christian Statement of Scripture V. An un-Christian Statement”

  1. Interesting comparison. You know I’m at least partially in the choir here, as a Barthian. Plus, I’m too Lindbeckian for Erickson’s propositional grammar of scriptural epistemology. Too much 17th-century “compendium doctrinae” for me. Abandoning “the position that everything taught or affirmed by scripture is true” and “truthful in all of its assertions” does not, as he supposes, lead to a reliance on religious anthropology and philosophy. False dichotomy. It instead leads to other ways of understanding the reference of scripture and its normativity for faith.

    And yet I am reminded that it is possible (and even necessary!) noetically to go 1) scripture, 2) God, 3) creation, entirely without such a propositional bent. In fact, working on CD III, I’m inclined to believe that that’s among the best paths. Creation is inevitably a late fruit of theological development, and not a primary noema. Claiming creation as a factual, evidentiary claim built on (only a few) scriptural narratives does screwy things.

    All that said, I’d like to back you up a few steps: ” a properly articulated and understood … doctrine of Scripture and its placement within the grasp (so to speak) of God’s people; Christians.”

    Surely you mean, “within the grasp of God’s Christian people”! Or are there no other peoples of this God?

  2. Maybe it’s just me, but the Erickson quote seems to have strains of positivism – i.e, no non-propositional truth (theologically, at least).

  3. @Matt,

    What do you think of John Webster’s critique of Lindbeck’s reading of Barth here?:

    In ‘Barth and Textuality’,28 Lindbeck presents Barth’s account of the Bible as a theory of textuality, closely allied to a particular understanding of the task of the church. Lindbeck finds in Barth a continuation of the Reformation insistence on Scripture as self-interpreting in the sense that as text it is a coherent and achieved world of meaning; as Barth’s thought develops, ‘the strange new world becomes ever more intratextual, firmly located within the biblical text’.29 Barth’s lesson for modern Christianity is thus that the church ‘has no future except in its own intratextual world’,30 and that Christian communities must ‘relearn the use of their own tongue’.31 The mistake here is to go no further back than communal practice, stopping short at ecclesiology and not pushing on to the doctrines of Trinity and revelation, which are crucial to Barth’s design, butwhich Lindbeckdismisses rather brusquely. As Ronald Thiemann notes in his ‘Response to George Lindbeck’,32 ‘Barth is interested in Scripture as self-interpreting text, because he sees Scripture as the vehicle of the self interpreting triune God … It is Barth’s view of revelation that warrants his intratextual view of theology. Without that doctrine of revelation, or its functional equivalent, textuality, intratextuality and self-interpreting texts have no theological force’;33 further, see here the critiques of Lindbeck by George Hunsinger, in How to Read Karl Barth. The Shape of His Theology,34 and ‘Truth as Self-involving. Barth and Lindbeck on the Cognitive and Performative Aspects of Truth in Theological Discourse’. 35A similar problem can be found (“Hermeneutics in Modern Theology”)

    “And yet I am reminded that it is possible (and even necessary!) noetically to go 1) scripture, 2) God, 3) creation, . . .”

    And yet I would argue that ontologically the order of God —> Creation —> Scripture is the order of things, and it is when we have this kind of theological accounting of things that we can properly see where Scripture has place in relation to God’s primacy in Christ over creation; I’m sure you don’t disagree with that, right Matt?

    “Surely you mean, β€œwithin the grasp of God’s Christian people”! Or are there no other peoples of this God?”

    Of course, I just wasn’t that careful with my syntax.

    I agree, of course, with you on your point about creation as a factual, evidentiary claim etc.

    @WF,

    Yes, indeed!

  4. @Bobby, Lindbeck’s Nature of Doctrine has many faults that are only redeemed in his later career of practice — when it becomes clear that this is strictly speaking a method for ecumenical and interreligious dialogues. And it’s quite good for that, which should be no surprise as that’s what it was written for. It builds out of Barth in directions brother Karl was never interested in going. His piece on Barth lines up far better with that methodological impulse than with Barth’s own — I will not claim him as a good Barthian, though he remains within the fold. He is a dialogical theologian, and far more interested in religion than the dialectical theologian we hold in common.

  5. And as to ontic vs noetic rationales, surely you’ve got it right — but for every reason of our being creatures, we must follow the noetic rationale and accept the ontic rationale from it. We cannot proceed as though the ontic rationale of God -> creation -> (salvation -> revelation ->) scripture were one we could follow in our own faithful quest for knowledge.

  6. Just found the article in question, to see how Webster stacks up. The opening of Lindbeck’s article is telling: “This essay is more about the theological situation in which we find ourselves than it is about Karl Barth. I could not speak otherwise even if I wanted to, for my knowledge of him is sadly second-hand. Yet even second-hand knowledge may perhaps suffice for a discussion of the effects of changes in context on the understanding of texts.” And surely both Webster and Hunsinger are correct about the fact that Lindbeck is using Barth without faithfully representing Barth, but the man himself agrees! πŸ™‚

  7. “[T]he source of all our knowledge of God is his active revelation of himself. We do not know God against his will, or behind his back, as it were, but in accordance with the way in which he has elected to disclose himself and communicate his truth in the historical-theological context of the worshipping people of God, the Church of the Old and New Covenants.”

    Does this “active revelation” of God include His revelation of Himself to all mankind? Is it restricted only to His actions in the redemptive history of Israel and His ultimate revelation in The Word, Jesus Christ?

    If that is so, how is it that you fit Paul’s absorption of Geek Stoical ideas in Acts 17? I find that the reality of the divine presence in which all mankind lives, moves and has it’s being is the grounding for all other revelation to find resonance in the human mind and heart. Here again, I know this runs counter to the bias against “natural revelation” in Torrance and Barth. And I find that “natural revelation” to be a diminutive term – because, to me, this pervasive presence and revelation of the Logos is not “natural” – it is closer to “supernatural” – close, gracious and full of light and life.

    Additionally, it seems that (perhaps in some strange and ironic way) Paul has taken up the quotations he cites and brought them into the level of Scripture – while their provenance is not from a Divine community of faith.

  8. @Matt,

    Thanks. I haven’t really read Lindbeck too much; just have secondary knowledge of him through folk like Webster, Frei, and Vanhoozer—and their engagement of him, through their either critical and/or constructive interaction.

    I agree on the order of being/knowing; but of course as a good Torrancean I would want to ground the noetic in the ontic reality of the humanity of the Son (so that these then become mutually conditioning realities), and in this case then, we don’t have a Modern humanity on a quest of self-discovery (neo-Gnostic)—but a Christian instance of fides quarens intellectum.

    Thanks for the quote from Lindbeck, that is enlightening!

    @Wayne,

    Funny you should bring up Acts 17; I am currently reading Torrance’s Divine Meaning: Studies in Patristic Hermeneutics, and just finished his chapter 2 on Athenagoras at Athens. TFT constructively engages Athenagoras on his usage of the Logos as the ratio that provides a taxis to created, and thus contingent order we inhabit. TFT highlights how Athenagoras along with Athanasius engaged this notion from a Christian conception of things, and thus not as an illustration of an instance of the analogy of being or ‘natural theology’, even in a modified form. Stay tuned, I will quote some of this for you and everyone tomorrow by way of a post.

    I would say as a general principle though—pace hermeneutics—that narrative, such as Acts represents, should be read as descriptive more than prescriptive in orientation. If we do this I am not so sure that Paul’s engagement at Mars Hill commends itself as a universal prolegomena for doing Christian theology today. But I will address your comment more fully in my next post πŸ™‚ .

    But in short when you ask this: “Does this β€œactive revelation” of God include His revelation of Himself to all mankind? Is it restricted only to His actions in the redemptive history of Israel and His ultimate revelation in The Word, Jesus Christ?” I would say most certainly! And my appeal would be to Col. 1:15ff, and the supremacy of Christ over all creation; his usage of pleroma in the Colossians correspondence is helpful in developing the kind of supremacy that Christ and his recreated/resurrected life has over all of humanity in its exaltation. Anyway, watch for that post. πŸ™‚

  9. A few disconcerting snippets from the Torrance quote:

    “he has elected to disclose himself and communicate his truth in the historical-theological context of the worshipping people of God, the Church of the Old and New Covenants.”

    “They are the Scriptures of the people of Israel, for Israel was the selected medium of God’s revelation”
    “the Church was the appointed sphere in which the historical self-revelation of God through Israel…is given an evangelical form…”

    What an odd and tenuous marriage between revelation and community!!! I know phrases like “self-revelation of God through Israel” are increasingly the latest rage, but do we even begin to fathom how Catholic, and thus how NON-PROTESTANT they are? This isn’t just a matter of ecclesiology, it’s a matter of REVELATION. And Torrance has given us a second mediator (s) of this Revelaton in the godless and idolatrous Israel on the one hand, and sinful and faithless church on the other. But the only mediator of Revelation is the flesh of Christ, which has been taken up into the Word for all time.

    God’s Word “operative in the prophets” was over and against Israel, again and again, a word of judgment (“From the time Jerusalem was built until now” in the recorded word of Jeremiah). I recognize we have to see the OT scriptures “in the context of the Israelite community” (although for that matter we might as well add the context of Babylon, Persia, Egypt, The Levant, Midian via Jethro, Edom via “The LORD marched out of Teman,” the Sea Peoples, Canaan etc….), but recognizing the Word of God in the context of something does not make that context it’s “self-revelation.”

    The same goes for the church. Take for instance the seven letters written in Revelation, or the letter of 1 Corinthian, or that to the church of Galatia…..these positive forms of ekklesia are not mediums of the Word but objects of its address. Nor were they faithful, and for that matter, they may have wished to tear to shreds Paul’s exhortations rather than gather them up and preserve them. The matter of preservation is incidental and does not give the 1st century church the honor that is due to Christ alone. We are all men, mere men, before and after just men.

    Instructive at this point is the reminder of the first appearance of the word ekklesia in the book of Acts (5:11).

  10. @Adam,

    Thank you, man!

    @Marc,

    I don’t even know where to begin with the erroneous nature of your comment; so I won’t. I would say though, that your comment reads more like a post—or something that you should have written as a post at your own blog.

    You need to spend more time with Reformed theology or something; and you need to take some time reading up on TFT’s view of God’s apocalyptic relation to humanity. Anyway, maybe if I had the time I would try to make some sense of your comment so I could then deconstruct it, but I don’t.

  11. I always need to spend more time with Reformed theology,

    For it is precisely they (From Luther, Melanchthon, Zwingli and Calvin right on down to Karl Barth) who so strictly pointed out the danger of elevating to the church any mediatorial status in connection with God’s Word, which the Barmen Declaration aptly and exclusively calls “Jesus Christ” (8.11).

    I would be interested in discussing this matter further with you, and as a good place to start, I recommend the Church dogmatics 1.2, p.526. Indeed, Barth’s whole discussion of the Word in relation to the church is helpful here. I don’t claim to emulate it fully and uncritically, but it is nonetheless helpful.

  12. As well,

    For the sake of clarity it might help me if you answered these questions.

    1. Does the church or Israel in any sense “mediate” the Word?

    2. If so, how does that square with the scriptural decree that there is only one Mediator between God and men?

    3. Does God reveal Himself THROUGH Israel?

    4. If so, which Israel? The Israel of Jer. 32:30 or some other Israel?

    5.If so, TO WHOM does God reveal himself through Israel?

    6. If something which is not Israel, why are the majority of texts in the OT addressed to Israel?

    7. If to Israel, we arrive at a contradiction. For God cannot reveal Himself through something to that same thing. There must be a division. We have to, in some respect, admit that there is an Israel which is not medium bu recipient, and recipient alone.

    3. Are the scriptures scripture because of the church and Israel, or are the latter as they are because of scripture?

  13. 1. No, Israel has the vocation of prefiguring of what only becomes reality in the incarnation of Christ as he takes up all of the shadowy forms and ceremonies in himself.

    2. So it squares fine.

    3. God reveals himself through Christ, and yet he does not do so w/o becoming the Jewish man from Nazareth.

    4. The Israel of Gen. 12:1-3, Gal 3.

    5. All of humanity, in his humanity pro nobis

    6. It is Israel, the ‘Israel of God’.

    7. He supersedes as the ‘seed’ giving Israel and all of humanity telos.

    8. The scriptures are because of Jesus.

    I am not totally sure what you’re trying to drive at, Marc. Other than you really dislike TFT, and seem to love a particular version of Barth.

  14. I don’t “really dislike TFT” or even “dislike” him. The man is brilliant. Even were I to limit his work to overseeing the translation of the Dogmatics alone (in short, bringing an important aspect of Reformation history to the english speaking world) I would have to exclaim my admiration. He has done some incredible work.

    What I’m driving at is the subtle manner in which Protestant theology cannot seem to detach itself from catholicism (and thus pelagianism). We erect a “positive” role for humanity in the catchwords Israel and the Church, as if this historical community for all time cannot be other than a medium of God’s Word. How is that not analogia entis? I’ve heard it said from divers protestant mouths, directly: “God has revealed himself in Israel and later Christ.” By placing Israel next to Christ (and first in order!!!!) we are giving a historical community the status of possessers of God’s word. Honestly Bobby, how does that not appear catholic to you? How is that not the loudest trumpeting of, “We have the temple of the LORD!!! The temple of the LORD!!!” or “We are Abraham’s descendants!!!!”

  15. @Marc,

    My response is pretty much summed up by Whitefrozen’s.

    I don’t think you are adequately considering the way that TFT, along with some Church Fathers, understood the relation of the imago Dei to the imago Christi. Christ (cf. Col. 1.15) is called the imago Dei, humanity has always already been created in the imago Christi, then; which then becomes the ground for understanding humanities’ being, Christ. BUT, what happens in the Incarnation, as Torrance is always fond of noting, is a novum, something that there is no analogy for—that is Theanthropos, the Godman. Knowledge of ourselves, pace Calvin, is grounded in the humanity of Christ, and this is not just an epistemic but also an ontic reality—so both Barth’s and TFT’s emphasis on Revelation is Reconciliation. Your point on the analogia entis, is stretching us beyond the point of credulity—or it is an unnecessary move, since this is not the way that TFT, for example, frames this. So the positive role for humanity (like the outer role of the Covenant) is only given traction as it is grounded in the inner life of God in Christ for us by the Holy Spirit; so then the humanity of the Son is not the predicate of another humanity (like ours), but our humanity is predicated by his as we then are mirrors of the mirror, in the image of Christ in the image of God.

  16. @Wayne,

    I’m sorry, that post I said I would write today in response to your point on Acts 17 will have to wait for the next couple of days πŸ™‚ .

  17. “Your point on the analogia entis, is stretching us beyond the point of credulityβ€”or it is an unnecessary move, since this is not the way that TFT, for example, frames this.”

    Making Israel the predicate of the subject “Revelaton” (which I take to be the meaning of “God’s self-revelation THROUGH…”) is not analogia entis? Israel is an aggregate of human beings. Faithful or no, to make them a vehicle of the Word (which is God, pace John) is an epistemic and an ontological move. Epistemic, because the Word which is God signifies knowledge thereof, and ontological, because this Word is encased in the historic being of Israel. One must needs look to Israel if one wishes to see God. Whether or not Torrance would be comfortable saying such things, his words point in that direction. I seem to recall that Torrance was comfortable with a nuanced natural theology, so I question whether my criticisms are so far from the mark.

  18. Israel’s not the subject of “Revelation,” Jesus is! TFT followed an analogia fidei not entis (which is what my personal chapter in our forthcoming book is on). But, I would like you to deal with my points on imago, because that reframes this in a way that avoids your conclusions about an analogy of being. And TFT does not follow an “nuanced natural theology,” he believes that faith is where belief is justified; his theological science and epistemological inversion attest to this (just see Elmer Colyer’s book on TFT, he explains how TFT does not after all endorse a natural theology—I also have some guest posts from Myk Habets on this if you go to my category “Myk Habets”). Anyway, you didn’t deal with my points on ‘imago’ and so I am left to wonder why.

Comments are closed.