John MacArthur the Philosopher

Watch this interview with John MacArthur; he is discussing his view on limited atonement and predestination. Notice the irony of everything that he communicates; especially how he says to avoid philosophical speculation in regards to these issues, yet he fails to identify that his whole response is deeply entrenched in philosophical (like Stoicism, Aristotelianism, etc.) grammar. He assumes, uncritically, it seems, that what he is communicating is pure Bible truth.

13 thoughts on “John MacArthur the Philosopher”

  1. B. man, you should get this book and tell me what you think. I say this because stoic philosophy might be very Pauline ( I say might, Pedersen does make a pretty good case)

    Cosmology and Self in the Apostle Paul: The Material Spirit
    Troels Engberg-Pedersen

    Review
    “Engberg-Pedersen is one of the very best Pauline scholars in the world … this book is intellectually exciting, timely and controversial.” –John Barclay, University of Durham
    Product Description
    Cosmology and Self in the Apostle Paul challenges the traditional reading of Paul. Troels Engberg-Pedersen argues that the usual, mainly cognitive and metaphorical, ways of understanding central Pauline concepts, such as ‘being in Christ’, ‘having God’s pneuma (spirit), Christ’s pneuma, and Christ himself in one’, must be supplemented by a literal understanding that directly reflects Paul’s cosmology.

    Engberg-Pedersen shows that Paul’s cosmology, not least his understanding of the pneuma, was a materialist, bodily one: the pneuma was a physical element that would at the resurrection act directly on the ordinary human bodies of believers and transform them into ‘pneumatic bodies’. This literal understanding of the future events is then traced back to the Pauline present as Engberg-Pedersen considers how Paul conceived in bodily terms of a range of central themes like his own conversion, his mission, the believers’ reception of the pneuma in baptism, and the way the apostle took the pneuma to inform his own and their ways of life from the beginning to the projected end.

    In developing this picture of Paul’s world view, an explicitly philosophically oriented form of interpretation (‘philosophical exegesis’) is employed, in which the interpreter applies categories of interpretation that make sense philosophically, whether in an ancient or a modern context. For this enterprise Engberg-Pedersen draws in particular on ancient Stoic materialist and monistic physics and cosmology – as opposed to the Platonic, immaterialist and dualistic categories that underlie traditional readings of Paul – and on modern ideas on ‘religious experience’, ‘self’, ‘body’ and ‘practice’ derived from Foucault and Bourdieu. In this way Paul is shown to have spelled out philosophically his Jewish, ‘apocalyptic’ world view, which remains a central feature of his thought.

    The book states the cosmological case for the author’s earlier ‘ethical’ reading of Paul in his prize-winning book, Paul and the Stoics (2000).

  2. Hey Kenny,

    Didn’t Justin Martyr think that Plato read Moses too πŸ˜‰ ? Sounds like an interesting thesis. I’d rather contend that Paul wrote as a Christian, and that his informing background was Hebraic vs. Stoic.

    Thanks for the heads up on the book; maybe I’ll give it a read someday.

  3. Bobby,

    You make a good observation of MacArthur when you say, “He assumes, uncritically, it seems, that what he is communicating is pure Bible truth.” I have always had this take on MacArthur even when I agreed with most everything he taught. Pure Bible Truth is the assumption and foundation of the system of theology. To disagree with MacArthur is to disagree with PBT, and that places you on shaky ground.

    Disagreeing with a MacArthurite church on relatively minor points of ecclesiology, for example, can place you in the Matthew 18 crosshairs because you disagree with PBT.

  4. “Notice the irony of everything that he communicates.”

    I’m sure TeamPyro notices it. They’re good at noticing irony. πŸ˜‰

  5. In reference to John McArthur, you commented on Randy Boswell’s blog: “I think the papal system is alive and well in Protestantism.” Would you mind fleshing that out a bit? Is it particularly a function of ecclesial government, or what? I’ve observed a mode of church gov’t that I call “the pastor-driven church”, and I’m wondering if that’s along the same lines as what you mean, or if you’re referring to something else/something more.

  6. Hi, B. Rowe,

    I think its probably in line with what you’re getting at; mostly I am just noting the role that personality cults play within Evangelicalism. Is that kind’ve what you’re getting at with pastor-driven church?

  7. Yes, that sounds right: personality cults. What I have observed (both from a distance and up-close) is the elevation of a specific person to a status of implicit infallibility — though of course no Protestant church would come right out and explicitly articulate a doctrine of pastoral infallibility. Lots of such churches, however, suffer under — and support! — abusive leadership.

    What I noted about the video above is that Macarthur looks exhausted and seems angry at particular moments in the film. It strikes me that fatigue and anger are inevitable outcomes of living out a pastoral calling defined by the need to be powerful, in control, and oh-so-invincibly right about everything. I also noted (before the video proper began) that the title “Shepherd’s Conference” gave me pause, as did the mini-logo of a shepherd’s crook which is visible throughout the video in the lower right hand corner of the screen — subtle hints of power and control dynamics which persistently divide clergy and laity in many sectors of evangelical protestantism.

  8. B. Rowe,

    Yes, I agree, MacArthur does seem somewhat angry in the video; although I wouldn’t want to read too much into that. Maybe he just had an argument with his wife or a staff member before he came on; one never knows πŸ˜‰ .

  9. I don’t know Bobby, he didn’t seem angry, if you ever met him that is just how he is. I heard him back up every comment with Scripture then admit that he doesn’t understand how some tensions in Scripture are to be solved. I agree that his veiw of the attonement was strained. He allows for common Grace but disavows common (universal) grace (attonement).

    I was very intrigued by your post on “Scripture Open for Business” I like to see that you also struggle with just following the dogmatics of someone else to quote you, you say:

    “I think this has been the source of my feeling of loss; I cannot countenance the notion that Scripture is in anyway secondary to who I know God in Christ to be. And I can’t live having one Dogmatician, or another telling me what the proper Christological categories must be (based on their prior constructive work); I am way too Protestant for that (and Trad, still)!”

    I think if i read it correctly you are struggling with blindly following Torrance without Scriptural backing. (Of course I know that you know that Torrance has done his homework) But it seems to me a lot on this blog is just what you are accusing MacArthur of (and believe me I cannot believe I am defending the man) You want your philosophy or theology to be the most correct one. But it has to start with man looking at the word to even work out a philosophy of life or a theology (or theo-logic as you like to say)

    And I am sure that we are all influenced by some theologian or some philosopher that has come before us, but I still would rather have someone quote chapter and verse to point out how they worked out thier theology than just quote Barth or Torrance or Calvin for that matter.

    As I understand it you want to see everything through Christ (and I agree) but I am only informed about Christ through His revealed word (therefore I don’t believe it to be very secondary). What am I missing? (he asks cringing):)

  10. Steve,

    I wrote this post quite some time ago, so I don’t know exactly how I was feeling at the moment I did that.

    On my post on “Scripture Open for Business,” my intention with that has more nuance associated with that than the post lets on; and the nuance is a result of my own personal journey and sense that is not easily explicated in this venue. But I will say that I am not concerned with blindly following Torrance, Barth et al.; instead I am concerned that there is indeed a temptation (and in fact indulgence), for some to NEVER actually engage the text of Scripture. So this “some” instead engage in the scholastic exercise of commentary building, and never do the Christian Humanist thing (which provided the context for the Protestant Reformation and subsequent sola scriptura) of ad fontes, or ‘back to the sources!’ (which meant back to the Bible in its original languages AND, though, back to its early interpretation through the Patristic theologians of the early church). So if I had spent more time on that post, this is the more concrete and broad context from which I was thinking in my own personal wrestling.

    I have written on many of these issues for years and years now (through blogging in particular), but obviously since you just started reading me you don’t have the fuller context from which I think. I would quite strongly disagree with you about the idea that we can simply read straight off the page of Scripture and arrive at our theology (in fact I would argue that Jesus would disagree with you, and I would appeal to a passage like Luke 24 and the Emmaus road to begin my argument (here’s a post that delves further into my hermeneutic http://growrag.wordpress.com/2012/11/09/christ-the-key-my-developing-jesus-hermeneutic/ , and then you have our book, Adam Nigh’s Chapter on a ‘Depth Dimension’ hermeneutic should explain this further).

    I would have to say that, indeed, of course I want to argue that my persuasion of a theological orientation is the correct one; if I didn’t hold to my position, I suppose then I wouldn’t really care so much, would I ;-)? What much of my blog is seeking to do is provide distanctiation or critical space for readers to understand that none of us simply read scripture in a vacuum; we all have an inherited interpretive tradition informing our interpretive decisions. My gripe against MacArthur & co. (and many evangelicals) is that he is solo scriptura, and doesn’t admit that he has a prior commitment to an theological/philosophical interpretive tradition that informs his reading of the text; which is hugely dangerous!!! I admit that I do, and then seek to constructively and dialectically work in a way that has an ongoing spiraling and shaping give and take between the shaping of the text (meaning) and theology (its underlying theologic; like how we conceived of the Trinity in the 4th century Greek church in particular). MacArthur & co. don’t admit this (that they have a prior theological orientation which is NOT biblical but philosophical!), and thus conflate their interpretive tradition with Scripture. And so when someone like me disagrees with their unstated interpretive TRADITION (classical theism), they presume that I am disagreeing with the Bible prima facie (which is ridiculously naive!). So there really is a massive difference between what MacARthur is doing and what I am doing; as I just sketched.

    Yes, indeed, I want to see everything principally through Christ; but my point has to do with theological order not epistemology/ontology, per se (although that is related and underlying). Theological order requires that there is first a giver of the text of Scripture (or creator), since the text of scripture is on paper written in ink and written by human authors (under the guidance of the Holy Spirit etc.). In order to not absolutize the text of Scripture we need to understand that it is merely an instrument or spectacles as Calvin would say, and that its ‘reality’ is really its giver who we encounter as we engage the text. And if we keep this theological order in place, then God’s Word doesn’t become something we possess, but something that its possessor has the authority and liveliness to speak through and contradict our own thoughts and thinking. So there is an order to being order knowing that I am presupposing; I am presupposing that God’s being necessarily, logically and chronologically precedes the giving of the text of scripture just as he precedes the creation of human beings in the first place. Thus he is the theological ground and condition and reality of the given and human text of scripture; I only know Christ through the text of scripture because he ordained that to be the place where would primarily known Him; and so I am emphasizing this as the primary ontology of scripture. I don’t see scripture as MY epistemological playground, but instead the Holy Spirit’s bedroom where He brings us into encounter with its loving reality, our bridegroom, Jesus Christ (so I see scripture in the realm of soteriology, not epistemology).

    I have more to say on all of this, and have numerous posts that I have written which effuse more.

  11. Steve,

    As I relisten to this, MacArthur is importing his view of election/predestination into the text of Scripture w/o disclosing, critically, where his view comes from (in its history of development), and I mean philosophically (and I am not totally sure he understands that either, other than knowing that it comes from Calvinist development). He simply takes it as prima facie that his view of election/reprobation etc. is indeed the emphases and categories of Scripture w/o argument! But that is circular. The Bible doesn’t say that God loves only certain people in the world; so MacARthur is theologizing at this point (not exegeting), but he is theologizing as if he is only exegeting; that is the error of his way!

Comments are closed.