Is Evangelical Calvinism understandable?

Let me ask all of my dear readers; is Evangelical Calvinism, as represented here on the blog, intelligible to you? In other words, does its basic contours stand out to you in a way that makes memorable and coherent sense?

The reason I ask is because it seems that I have run across some folk who seem to be rather confused about what Evangelical Calvinism actually is. I would say that much of this confusion has more to do with lack of dedication to research what I (and Myk and others) are after with this than actual lack of cohesion in Evangelical Calvinism itself.

Anyway, I am just curious. Something that is becoming more and more apparent to me; is that Evangelical Calvinism will always remain somewhat abstract and academic in form. Its epistemological background (at least the style I am most famililar with, through T. F. Torrance) is quite complex and complicated, with terms like: Kata Physin, epistemological inversion, stratified knowledge of God, form-in-being, form-in-knowing, tacit knowledge, onto-relations, etc. etc. There is a mass of material and context necessary to begin to really appreciate what Evangelical Calvinism is about (at least in specifics). I do think that there are basic contours that folks can appreciate without much consternation of thought; like: Union with Christ theology, the vicarious humanity of Christ, Trinitarian Theology, the logic of grace, the ontological theory of the atonement, etc. But, I am hard pressed, personally, to know how to go about making the broader informing framework (like epistemologically) accessible for church people. And I really want to do this! I want to offer an alternative and understandable way to think about the Lord (who is love by definition) that offers a counter-voice to the constant drip of Calvinist and Arminian theology offered from pulpits and radio stations all across America. This is my burden, and I am still seeking how to reduce-without-loss the material and substantial points that Evangelical Calvinism has to offer (so not just for the academic, but your basic thoughtful Christian).

14 thoughts on “Is Evangelical Calvinism understandable?”

  1. Bobby. There really is no substitute for reading the primary texts. That you are constantly seeking to direct our attention to such texts is a real strength of your blogging. If some of your readers are still struggling to see the connection between the themes you’re keen to introduce, you ought not feel responsible for that. That said, it may help your readers if you say chose one book or significant article by TF Torrance (for example) and simply offered a section by section summary of the theo-logic Torrance is employing, highlighting relevant and important connections along the way. Avoid the temptation to read your reader’s minds. Again, those who have ears to hear will hear. Just a thought. As for me, I enjoy your blog very much.

  2. Hi Bobby – I really like your blog and your passion for Evangelical Calvinism – I just wish I understood it better, but I’m definitely a lay person and may not have the background to fully grasp it. I’ve been dissatisified with Calvinism, Arminianism and even Molinism and have more or less resigned myself to the fact that soteriology might remain a complete “mystery” to me. Again, though, your zeal for this topic is always encouraging! Eric

  3. @Jason,

    Thank you, that is good encouragement; and what I needed to hear. I want to be sensitive to folk out there, but given the range of readers in the blogosphere that is almost an impossible task. You’re right, I will just keep blogging the way I do, and hopefully it will be to the benefit of some; I’m glad it is to you! πŸ™‚ Btw, you’re blog is awesome to read and follow!!

  4. @Eric,

    Thank you, brother! I hope that I can make EC even more clear so that it might be something that you feel comfortable with as well!! I am going to be writing a guest post over at another blog; introducing EC and contrasting it with classic Calv/Arm. I will cross-post that here once its done. The folks I will be writing for over there are totally aloof to EC, and so this will be a good exercise for me … stay tuned! And thank you for the encouragement!

  5. As a theologically trained Lutheran who is a) still struggling with differentiating this Evangelical Calvinism thing from “the constant drip of Calvinist and Arminian theology offered from pulpits and radio stations all across America,” and b) under the same compulsion in Evangelical Lutheranism, I don’t think you’re on the wrong track. Jason is, of course, right. If you want ’em to have a taste for bread, feed ’em good bread. Throw in some good cheese and good wine, while you’re at it. Not because it’s fancy, not because it’s an acquired taste — because it is simply more enjoyable to eat and drink this. And I think that’s what you’re about, reading you.

    There’s a place for all kinds of discussion — and we have to have the “heavy” discussions that aren’t necessarily generally accessible discourse, sometimes. As with preaching, there’s a ton of work required on the back end for a garden on the front end. And often we lean into the technical discussions in response to that drip-drip-drip of bad/cheap theology. Which is a necessary first step, perhaps, but doesn’t help us with the “laity”. I’ve been trying to tackle this by leaning into scriptural interpretation — with Barth and my doctoral work on the back end, finding the places where it all touches ground in the church on the front end. Sort of the difference between talking about it and doing it — but in terms of doing what I talk about. And teaching is another easy way, as Jason suggested — teaching the theo-logic from its sources. Both ways, preaching and teaching, you’ll learn as much as you teach, and it’ll tend to be accessible.

    But “how to reduce-without-loss the material and substantial points that Evangelical Calvinism has to offer (so not just for the academic, but your basic thoughtful Christian)” — that’s quite the trick, and a worthy goal. That is systematic theology, because you can’t do it without structuring and restructuring the topics and articles of the faith. The only easy key I have is to know in yourself what the faith is, and to remember that everything you’re working with is only theology because it talks about the faith. You can play with the material of the fides quae creditur as much as necessary until it makes a shape that preaches gospel reliably to the fides qua creditur in the pews.

  6. @Matt,

    Great words as well, thank you! I realize that there is simply a breadth of context and info that not everyone will “get;” or maybe even should “get.” But great points on the front end, back end analogies.

    As far as differentiating Evangelical Calvinism from classic Calvinism; what is it that would help to clarify that for you? Is it that you see EC (and Torrance) as still “classic” itself (metaphysically)? I know McCormack sees Torrance this way. I am often tempted to go Barthian, esp. when I read McCormack on Barth, but in the end I think I find the Barthian project to be somewhat scholastic in approach (i.e. seeking to erase any kind of “mystery” [metaphysics] relative to a doctrine of God/election).

    I’ll keep “playing” for sure though πŸ˜‰ . Where are you working on your doctorate at? And what’s the topic of your research?

  7. Bobby:

    I haven’t been reading here regularly or intensely long enough to really say whether the whole thing overall is comprehensible or not. I will admit that a lot of it does seem fairly dense, although perhaps this is because I haven’t yet read enough on it.

    I am somewhat leery of any theology that must be couched in a whole vocabulary of seemingly abstract, almost metaphysical-sounding terms. This is a hallmark of two theologies that attracted me at one time but ultimately drove me away for their unbiblicalness: liberal and Eastern Orthodox.

    A complex conceptual superstructure divorced from a plain reading of Scripture and everyday Christian experience is also what is causing me to question Dordrecht/Westminster/Princeton-style Calvinism today.

    This is not to knock Torrance at all, but are there other sources in addition to him that you can draw upon? Are there primary sources–like from, say, the early Scottish Reformation? Or even Calvin himself?

  8. @Bobby, part of the problem for me is that I’m looking at the discussions between my Reformed cousins, and interpreting them along lines I’ve grown up in among my Lutheran siblings. And so I’ve done quite a bit of reading and talking and listening to try and understand what is really going on, among Calvinists especially, but without a “native guide” to the factions or what’s really at stake. And so I trip over a lot of lines that aren’t obvious to me. I have a great deal of sympathy for your distinctions between Federal and Evangelical Calvinism — I hadn’t had a name for the differences before, and it seems to be a good one.

    I’m not clear on what you (or BLM) mean by metaphysically classic. Unless you mean Aristotelian/Platonic, “classic” doesn’t clearly describe to me a metaphysical system, just a value judgment on it. πŸ˜‰ And yet I do see EC as in many ways “classic” in attempting to reach behind the Arminian schism and its polemics to a sense of the tradition, the articula fidei, as the reformers gathered them out of necessity from their own catholic traditions. Doing so in ways that pointedly recenter the faith on the gospel, but doing so descriptively in ways that pointedly reflect the contemporary philosophical debates. There is that, for me, in the ways Torrance reflects Barth — as opposed to the ways Pannenberg, for example, moves away from him into modernity, or the ways the “radical orthodox” try to recapture the history. I see in FC, and what often passes for “confessionalism” among Lutherans, an attempt to follow out a polemical line of counter-confession as though it were the expression of the core of the faith.

    It’s probably easiest to refer you to http://parrhesia-lalein.blogspot.com/p/vita-brevis.html for where I am and what I’m doing — except to say that I work on Barth’s doctrine of creation, and I have a hunch about the “seeking to erase any kind of ‘mystery'” wrt the doctrine of God and election in the Barthian project. The man is obsessed with following out the thread. And it is scholastic in its own way — mostly because he’s following out that thread of theological thought through dialectical disputation. The Dogmatics are profoundly archaic in that way.

  9. @Matt,

    Thanks for sharing a little more background.

    You must know of how McCormack constructively works with Barth; meaning that Barth is a post-metaphysical theologian. No? You’re aware of the “Companion debate,” right? The one where McCormack lays out his view on Barth, and how he believes that Barth believed that the resurrection etc. are constituting to God’s being (Barth’s election). That’s what I was getting at with “erasing anything metaphysical” or what have you.

    I do like the way you have construed EC, in a way; i.e. getting behind the polarities by reaching back into the history. To be metaphysically “classic”, btw, is to not be actualistic, pace Barth. That’s what I and/or and better, McCormack would be after with his critique.

    I’ll check out your background further via the link, thanks brother!

  10. Stefan,

    If you check out the table of contents to our forthcoming book; you’ll notice that most of the chapters are on Calvin. Calvin and his “mystical union” double grace theology place a central role in Evangelical Calvinism and/or Scotttish Theology. It is rooted, I think, I a very patristic way of thinking; esp. in an Athanasian vein.

    As far as a “plain” reading of Scripture; well, I think that there is a lot to what “plain” might mean. Did the Apostles read the OT in light of Jesus in plain ways? I just think there is more depth to what a plain reading of scripture entails than some; I suppose.

    If you have the chance, you also might want to check out my “EC Themes” page on top of the blog.

    When you say Princeton style of Calv; what do you mean? Like a Barthian style?

    I’m glad you’re here, Stefan. When I have more time I would like to provide you with a more thoughtful response.

  11. Hi, Bobby:

    You’re right: “plain” is probably too…um, plain in its meaning. What I mean is that as a younger agnostic, I saw enough of liberal theology and higher criticism to see the ways that men and women will use language to redefine and deconstruct Scripture and supplant it with elaborate systems of their own making.

    And now I’m seeing the same pattern again, as certain Reformers will use complicated verbal arguments to claim “sola scriptura” while redefining clear biblical teaching because it conflicts with their systematics (e.g., Presbyterians on baptism; 5-pointers on limited atonement; hard cessationists on arguments from history against the biblical witness; etc.).

    So I don’t mean to prejudge a new (to me) theology just because it uses a lot of unfamiliar metaphysical terms, but it’s an instinctive reaction. Of course, I suppose one must always expect to invest a certain amount of energy in basic concepts and definitions when learning a new area of knowledge…after all, at one time I had to learn words like “soteriology,” “posttribulational,” “credobaptist,” and “ecclesiologically”!

    As for what I meant by “Dordrecht/Westminster/Princeton,” I was thinking of the same thing as what you call “federal Calvinism,” and alluding to men like Warfield and Machen, as precursors of the sort of rigid, highly systematized form of small-tent Calvinism that is espoused by some within the Reformed movement today.

  12. Stefan,

    Thank you, brother! I understand, and am with you. When you said Princeton Calvinism I was thinking Barthianism, because that’s what is predominate there nowadays πŸ˜‰ .

    We think of ‘EC’ as more of a mood than a system, but at least Myk and I in the forthcoming book have identified 15 core theses that stand out to us as basic contours to our expression of EC. What I like about EC is that it remains open-structured and dynamic. Meaning since our God is relational and dynamic there is freedom for what some might call ‘tension’ to remain.

    Yes “plain” has been so abused it is hard to just be “plain” anymore πŸ˜‰ .

    Thanks!

  13. Bobby, lately every time I run into a not-entirely-transparent use of language in a Barth-connected field, it turns out to be within two jumps of Bruce McCormack. “Actualism,” being metaphysically “classic,” … And at this point I know and like just enough McCormack students for it to be a handicap when they say things that belong to his idiosyncratic usage, and I try to get a hold of it from the generally accessible meanings of the terms. Much research to be done, little free time until spring, and few footholds from outside. But I appreciate you throwing a few clues my way — last time I read the Companion I was obsessed with the lucidity of Webster’s view, and had piles of other folks to choose from and interpolate between. So, “know of” yes; know in depth, not quite yet.

  14. Matt, I find myself obsessed with the lucidity of Webster’s thought quite often myself; so that’s very much so excusable πŸ˜‰ . I have much more study to do myself, but that is the distinction I was referring to—within the self-referencing world of the PTS Barthians—between metaphysical and post-metaphysical; the one McCormack speaks from.

Comments are closed.