Brian LePort, ThM student at Western Seminary, and a great brother in Christ; has recently posted this (something that is right up my alley in addressing):
I’ve had some good conversations the last couple days since arriving in San Diego, CA. One topic that has been addressed twice already is that of Calvinism. I used to think of myself as a Calvinist until the Calvinist told me that I didn’t belong. Prior to that, I thought of myself as an Arminian, but they told me the same thing. It lead me to believe that I must affirm something like what Dr. Gerry Breshears (Western Seminary, Portland, OR) calls “Calminianism” (Calvinism + Arminianism).
While I don’t know if that label fits what I did glean from it is that within the canon of Scripture and the broad Christian tradition we find language that can say both how important it is for us to believe the Gospel, to confess it, and to live in accordance with the teachings of Christ while stating with equal strength that we did not merit God’s favor, that he brought us to him by his Spirit, that he has known us from the very, very beginning in such a way that we can say we were “foreknown” and “predestined”.
What bothered me about many Arminians is how often they attempted to explain why free will matters while over qualifying God’s electing purposes. What bothered me about many Calvinist is how often they attempted to explain why God’s election matters while over qualifying our imperative to choose and submit to the Gospel.
It is not that I am saying that Christians shouldn’t seek to reconcile how this works. That is fine. What I am saying is that it is odd how something so complex can become so central to our Christian identity to the point that we will disavow other Christians who do not understand this paradox as we do. Why is it that so many of us cannot embrace the tension found within Christian soteriology? It’s what we Christians do with everything else.
Think of it. The church fathers wrestled for many, many years with what orthodox Theology and Christology entailed. What did they conclude by the leading of the Spirit? First, the doctrine of the Trinity: one God in three persons–Father, Son, and Spirit. Second, orthodox Christology: Christ is both “fully God” and “fully human”.
Paradox. Tension. It is no surprise that within these two doctrines we find aspects of Christianity that the modern mind struggles to fathom.
I don’t care if you find the label Arminian works best to describe you or if the label Calvinist works best to describe you. What I do want to know is whether the tensions inherit within the Christian tradition remain. If not, why not? We are the ones who worship the Triune God. We are the ones who worship the God-Man. (see the posting at Brian’s blog: here)
Brian actually answers his own question[s] in his last paragraph. The problem that has given rise to classic Calvinism and Arminianism is that they both operate from a substance concept of God (like from Aristotle’s monadic unmoved mover conception) that necessarily require that the dynamic personalist (dare I say ‘Evangelical’) tension Brian is looking for will NEVER, NEVER, NEVER, EVER be found within the stalwart halls of classic Calvinism and Arminianism. It is all about a person’s conception or doctrine of God! This will dictate everything else. Brian has rightly identified (maybe even tacitly) the correlation between the fact that we as Christians worship the Triune God; thus leading to the conclusion that there will be or should be a relational and personal tension within the way things are articulated theologically-exegetically. So, if God’s nature is relational by nature; then the theologian’s understanding of God’s relation to us will be framed in relational (versus positivist or propositionalist) ways. If God’s nature is Stoic and Static; then the exegete’s understanding of God’s relation to us will be framed in deterministic, decretive (by way of decree), logically-causal ways (or with no room for ‘tension’).
Won’t you join me in inviting Brian to Evangelical Calvinism 😉