The Rainbow of Calvinism

Here’s a few strands of Calvinism:

1) Federal/Covenant Calvinism — or Westminster shaped (typified in the history by William Perkins and William Ames, contemporaneously typified by Westminster Theological Seminary) .

2) Five Point non-Covenantal Dispensational Calvinism (best typified by John MacArthur).

3) The Spiritual Brethren Calvinism — non-Federal and anti-Westminster (best typified by Richard Sibbes and John Cotton see Janice Knight’s: Orthodoxies in Massachusetts: Rereading American Puritanism)

4) Amyraulidianism Calvinism — aka “4-point” (articulated and named after Moses Amyraut).

5) Evangelical Calvinism — Scottish Development (associated with people like John Calvin, James Fraser of Brea, Hugh Binning, the Erskines, Jonathan McLeod Campell, T. F. Torrance, Myk Habets, Bobby Grow πŸ˜‰ et al).

Can you think of anymore variations? I realize that we have regional nuances as well, primarily amongst my #1; like: Dutch, English, German, South African, American etc. But can you think of anymore representative categories of Calvinism like I have listed above? A species that has its own set of identifiable contours.

24 thoughts on “The Rainbow of Calvinism”

  1. Funny, how everyone likes to claim Calvin. But for me however, the best of Calvinism will always be Swiss (Geneva), Dutch and English mostly! πŸ™‚

    We should note too that Calvin wrote the King of England, i.e. Edward. And also that many of the 16th century Reformers went and even taught in England. Note, here for example Peter Martyr Vermigli.

  2. Of course, Calvin is my homeboy. πŸ˜‰

    I notice that your style is scholastic, #1. Not surprising, but then again, you’re somewhat dispy; so maybe you are a hybrid of 1 and 2 somehow πŸ˜‰ .

  3. Bobby,

    Yeah, I’m also Anglo-Irish, and having been a Royal Marine (enlisted to officer), for an Irish born, Republic of Ireland (Catholic Dublin) boy, that was radical!

    But scholastic and dispy sounds okay to me! πŸ˜‰ (Note, my “Brethren” background was radical too…”Kelly Brethren” (That’s for William Kelly, he was at one-time Darby’s close mate. But sadly, then both were sucked into a Brethren division near the later years of both their history. And they we on oposite ends.)

  4. Yeah, Calvin gets the wax-nose treatments. Mostly, these sorts of assessments have the tail wagging the dog. Calvin gave rise (in varying degrees) to all these traditions. He’s a seminal figure. To put him in only one of those traditions is conspicuously self-serving. πŸ™‚

  5. Yes, here’s a good quote on Calvin’s wax nose:

    Although the usefulness of the Westminster Confession or Schleiermacher for modern theological work has been debated, it is hard to imagine a Reformed theologian not wanting to honor Calvin as the great thinker of the Protestant Reformation. The challenge for American theology comes into focus when Calvin is invoked as an important predecessor in the theological programs articulated by people as diverse as Joseph Haroutunian, William Pauck, Cornelius Van Til, James M. Gustafson, and Serene Jones. Whose Calvin? Which Calvinism? The cynical answer to both questions is: whichever Calvin I need! The more reasoned answer acknowledges that Calvin can and does support a variety of seemingly contradictory claims based on the theories of doctrinal development associated with his thought. That Calvin wrote on nearly every biblical, theological, and ethical topic has given later scholars plenty of opportunities to link their agendas to the Great Reformer. In that sense, in addition to having a wax nose, Calvin also is a mirror that reflects the particular beliefs and agendas of those who claim him for their own. In the twentieth century, Calvin was claimed for and against the inerrancy of scripture, the doctrine of limited atonement, double predestination, the ecumenical movement, democracy, natural theology, women’s ordination, abortion rights, freedom of conscience, and many other things. When β€œproperly understood for our times,” Calvin stood for just about anything. (Quoting from: Stephen D. Crocco in: β€œJohn Calvin’s American Legacy,” ed. Thomas J. Davis from his chapter 7, β€œWhose Calvin, Which Calvinism? John Calvin and the Development of Twentieth-Century American Theology,” p. 168-69)

    Yes, like I said . . . Calvin’s my homeboy πŸ˜‰ . He serves many purposes here at The Evangelical Calvinist esp. his unio mystica.

  6. Pingback: Elsewhere (05.27.2011) « Near Emmaus

  7. Hi Bobby

    i wonder if you have a bullet point set of major differences between the strands?
    would be very useful!

    thanks
    Dev

  8. lol… pls help those of us out there who cannot read these things without the continuous help of a Christian dictionary =)

  9. Post-liberal Calvinism? Kelsey and Placher (maybe Tanner).
    Literary Calvinism? Melville to Marylynne Robinson.

  10. @Dev,

    Are you mocking me πŸ˜‰ . . . or are you trying to prod me to provide more development for my little Calvinist categories above?

  11. mshedden,

    Thanks, do you care to elucidate a little further on what kind of contours might be associated with those two categories? And welcome, I think this is your first comment here.

  12. Well post-liberalism is primarily methodological but those three all place a great deal of importance om Calvin’s work for there own theological development (you could include Hunsinger with them). For literary I have no idea. The problem is I am not a Calvinist but I find all of those authors convincing and worth the read. It might be true all of them were more Barth-ian than Calvinist. Maybe they are ecumenical Calvinist’s?

  13. mshedden,

    Yeah, I’m familiar with post-liberalism. My initial thought when I saw your two categories is that they might be more Barthian than Calvinist. I’ve read Hunsinger, and know his background (and Tanner), but haven’t read the other names you’ve listed (I know of Robinson but haven’t really read). What do you think of Milbank and his RO? I’m reading J. Todd Billings right now who engages him and the “Gift” theologians (like Tanner) vis-a-vis Calvin’s theology; and he finds them to be lacking in re. to actually understanding Calvin’s theology itself.

    Are you Barthian?

  14. I am Barthian in same way Milbank and RO are Calvinist: lacking and often misunderstanding him. I do my best to follow Frei’s “generous orthodoxy”, but as a Mennonite Pastor I doubt I could ever truly be Barthian. Lamely, I am just a Hauerwas-ian.

  15. mshedden,

    That’s cool. I haven’t spent much time with the post-lib stuff (Lindbeck, Frei, Hauerwas et al) — only through Vanhoozer and a few others have I engaged Lindbeck’s stuff. And then I’ve read some of Hauerwas’ ethics stuff. I’m glad to have your perspective. I think I’ve seen you over at Halden’s blog a few times, right?

  16. @Dev,

    Ok. πŸ˜‰ We’ll see . . .

    @MShedden,

    I thought so. I’ve also visited your blog in the past, I think. You attended Mars Hill Graduate School didn’t you?

  17. No. But I’ve looked there website over, a bit. It looks like a good school. Definitely offering a more diverse spectrum, or different slant than where I went to school. Although, Multnomah has a pretty diverse student body, and even faculty nowadays too. Just still more of the pietist/keswick type tradition that it appears that MHGS is. But its been awhile since I’ve been at Multnomah, and my own theological horizons have broadened somewhat as well.

Comments are closed.