There is such a thing as the descriptivist fallacy. This fallacy typically befalls the studious types of people out there. It is as the student starts the process of learning
about the history of ideas; their relative streams of origination and development; where said ideas eventually have led to in the history, so on and so forth. I have seen this play out many times, as I’m sure you have, when you come across folks who, indeed, are learners. In fact, there is no doubt that this fallacy has plagued each and everyone of us at some level in our various journeys, as we have sought to understand, in a critical way, how we have arrived where we have; as far as ideological, theological, and ideational habitations go.
The fallacy happens when a person becomes knowledgeable enough to understand, say for example, their pietistic/conversionist background as Christians; resulting in this belief that anything that might smell, to them, like pietism, is now anathema. But this is not the necessary conclusion, per se. That is to say: just because a person might come to realize how and where pietism, say of the Anglophone type, has come from, and might lead to, does not mean that pietism is inherently incoherent. But the point of the fallacy itself comes from other informal fallacies; i.e., argument of the beard, caricature, chronological snobbery, sweeping generalization, post hoc, so on and so forth. Just because we can historically identify how ideational movements have developed this does not necessarily equal that said movements of thought are inherently wrong. Just because “your people” all think some ideational framework is wrong, does not necessarily mean that it is; this is simply appeal to your people (or the group think fallacy).
This might all seem obvious to you. But I have seen how this ‘descriptivist fallacy’ is often at play in the intellectual discourses. It needs to be identified, and repented of. Just because we might have the “intellectual prowess” to understand complex developments vis-à-vis the development of ideas; just because we can call them out; just because we have those types of chops, does not mean that being able to describe an ideological framework, in and of itself, entails an argument, or even a strike, per se, against said framework. If we are going to undercut or “defeat” what we might take to be a deleterious intellectual development, we will have to do more than simply identify and describe it.
The issue de facto this raises for me, Bobby, focuses on the need for mentoring (i.e., biblical discipling— and all that it entails) with regard to the developing/growing faith of/in Christ through a true and spiritual understanding of the testimony of Scripture. Indeed, the church is in need of more of that corrective encouragement of teaching and training which comes by means of those whose Spirit is one and the same with the spirit that filled both Barnabas and Paul.
“And do not be conformed to this age, but be transformed by the renewal of your mind, so that you may approve what is the good and well-pleasing and perfect will of God. For by the grace given to me I say to everyone who is among you not to think more highly of yourself than what one ought to think, but to think so as to be sensible, as God has apportioned a measure of faith to each one.” (Rom 12:2-3)
@Richard, yes and amen. I am no longer hopeful that this type of discipleship is going to ever emerge, in the main, in the churches. It’s getting really really bad out there.
True, Bobby… and yet doesn’t thinking about it as being bad “out there” betray an “inward” rather than “Godward” perspective? I’ve found that only the realization of the depth of his love for me (in a sense…) as it being for me alone… in the depth of my own inherent wicked, sinful, and ugly nature… overcomes such an inward perspective of comparative “goodness vs badness.” Moreover, it is so “natural” for us to be and do so.
True, Bobby… and yet doesn’t thinking about it as being bad “out there” betray an “inward” rather than “Godward” perspective? I’ve found that only the realization of the depth of his love for me… (in a sense) as it being for me alone in the depth of my own inherent wicked, sinful, and ugly nature… overcomes such an inward perspective of comparative “goodness vs badness.” (Moreover, it is so “natural” for us to be and do so.)
@Richard,
Yes, but that isn’t exactly what this post is addressing. It is addressing a purely intellectualist descriptive approach that many academics, and folks with enough knowledge become dangerous with. Just because I can identify a pietist-conversion as the theological and social framework behind evangelicalism, doesn’t inherently mean I’ve made an argument against evangelicalism; or pietist-conversionist-revivalism for that matter. Just identifying the history of ideas that funds a “movement” does not in itself defeat the movement, or offer a critical engagement with said movement, per se. That’s what I was getting at with this post.