We all have interpretive tradition as we approach the task of exegeting Holy Scripture. Some know this, most, in the evangelical churches, don’t. As Christians we are all faced with the hermeneutical dilemma. That is, we are, as the ‘priesthood of believers,’ as the communio sanctorum, tasked with, and privileged by the calling to encounter and know God through the study of Holy Scripture. But precisely because we are believers, in the plural, this leads to said hermeneutical dilemma. That is, we all arrive at Scripture with pre-understandings, and a host of other culturally conditioned expectations that the text itself really isn’t (or shouldn’t be) subject to. So, as Christian interpreters of the Christian scriptures, part of the toiling we must go through, is to learn to identify our pre-understandings, and cultural conditioning, and then critically question if those pre-understandings help to enhance our respective exegeses of the text, or on the other hand, question if (and this is typically the case) these foreign apparatuses might be polluting and distorting our exegetical conclusions. Most interpreters of Holy Scripture don’t ever really get around to this process; we might call it, as DA Carson does, the process of distanciation; viz. the process of distancing, disentangling ourselves from our dearly held, and ingrained presuppositions, to the point that we might indeed come to better critically interpret the Holy text.
Yet, as I have already noted, most won’t go through this process; it can be painful. Don’t get me wrong, I am not referring to what more popularly has come to be called deconstructionism. No, in fact, what I’m after here is at real crosscurrents with this more popular and naïve approach currently under way by many disillusioned (and often young) Christians out there. Distanciation, is really the thickening process for understanding where we come from ecclesially; not to mention, culturally and personally. It is the process of digging down deep, self-examining, and listening to the past doctors of the Church in a way that might disrupt, disorientate what we have often, naively, come to hold as our sacred cows. For some, these interpretive cows might be the dispensational hermeneutic, for others, the covenantal/Ramist hermeneutic, for others an existentialist hermeneutic, and still yet for others, some form of identarian hermeneutic (i.e., feminist/womanist, queer, Black liberationist, so on and so forth). Whatever our pre-understandings entail, it is imperative that we come to understand what those are, and then shed what might be darkening our understanding of the text; and at the same time, taking on those hermeneutics that might, indeed, enhance a more proximate way towards arriving at our exegetical conclusions.
The primary problem of not going through the process of distanciation is that we end up conflating our said hermeneutic with the biblical teaching itself. That is, we end up so absolutizing our hermeneutic (i.e., dispensational; theonomic postmillennial; biblical patriarchal; Lordship salvationist etc.) with Scriptural teaching that we cannot see a critical distinction between the two. In this scenario, it becomes nearly impossible for genuine, and thus Christian engagement to obtain between competing hermeneutical adherents. Once this stalemate hardens, and it does, all we have left is a hard sectarianism, among the various hermeneutical systems, with the result being discord and back biting among purported brothers and sisters in Christ. In other words, these systems, when siloed so intransigently to the biblical text, and its teaching, lead various Christians to actually question whether or not their respective opponents are even Christians at all.
I’m all for the heated, but well-lit debate! But at the end of the day, the Christian needs to be humble enough to recognize that there is no salvific ultimacy tied to any hermeneutic, that indeed has been contrived under the broader banner of a genuinely catholic orthodoxy. This is why I am a proponent of a Christologically conditioned hermeneutic, by the way. Some scoff at the audaciousness of claiming such a hermeneutic, but for my money it is the only hermeneutic that has the capacity to provide the text of Holy Scripture with the proper orientation and context to arrive at the most proximate exegetical conclusions available.

What is hard for some (trained) people to accept is that the humanity of our Lord is actually a hermeneutic since they have been conditioned into using this word in a non -relational way and categorised it as a set of rules about how to approach the biblical text. This has to be wrong given that God has revealed himself in his Son and that the Scriptures point outward from themselves to Him. The key to understanding Scripture is … “Jesus, the Lamb slain before the foundation of the world”. This (He) is the only hermeneutic that has been provided for us and must be met out in our study and prayers and church life as we read together.
Indeed the Christologically conditioned hermeneutic IS “the only hermeneutic that has the capacity to provide the text of Holy Scripture with the proper orientation and context to arrive at the most proximate exegetical conclusions available.” Moreover, that is the conditioned hermeneutic of the Apostolic witness, as well as the majority of Church Fathers of the third and fourth centuries (in their theological mission in setting aright the alien schemes that opposed the Truth of the gospel and threatened to overwhelm the faith that is proclaimed in the Scriptures).
Incidentally, Bobby, I found my way to your postings following several distressing years undergoing the process of “distanciation” (although I didn’t have a proper nomenclature for it)… And thankfully, He is both able and faithful in sanctifying himself that we, who are his, may also be sanctified in the truth. Thanks be to God for his indescribable gift!
@RichardS,
I agree, to a large extent. The “trained” are so used to syllogisms, logics and such that they fail to recognize that this whole Christian endeavor is relational; a relationship with the triune God grounded in prayer, in the intercessions of Christ, with whom we are participants. This dialogical approach must ground and shape anything following. I am not against using literary analysis, grammatical-historical etc. tools, but they must be in service, and shaped by the dialogical, communicative relationship we have with the risen Lord; as if ‘the sheep know their Shepherd’s voice,’ and He knows theirs, as He has first given them breath to praise and worship Him. Bonhoeffer was right to press the notion of the communio sanctorum.
@RichardB,
Indeed, it is odd, isn’t it? So many have unfortunately been trained away from the hermeneutic of the Apostles. The NT itself ought to be the Christian’s primary hermeneutical training book. As you rightly note, it is saturated with Christological concentration, such that if that characterizes its witness (and method!), then likewise that ought to characterize ours!
And amen, I’m glad the Lord brought us together through this meeting place 🙂 !
“…these systems, when siloed so intransigently to the biblical text, and its teaching, lead various Christians to actually question whether or not their respective opponents are even Christians at all.
I’m all for the heated, but well-lit debate! But at the end of the day, the Christian needs to be humble enough to recognize that there is no salvific ultimacy tied to any hermeneutic, that indeed has been contrived under the broader banner of a genuinely catholic orthodoxy.”
Amen!
It became cliche’ back in the day – “Jesus saves!” , the raw truth remains, neither OUR belief or faith, nor OUR perseverence, nor OUR doctrine nor any other thing of our own can either separate us from the love of Christ or save us. Jesus saves!
Thanks Bobby!