I was planning on writing another post sharing a quote from Barth on natural theology. But I thought it would be better at this time to simply share why I am so impassioned about this issue. The answer might resonate with you. In fact, I would hope the answer is deeply ingrained into all of us as Christians. The reason I am so invigorated by the issue of natural theology is because it gets right down to the issue of who God is. Who we think God is will determine all else in our daily lives as Christians. The reality is, is that I am simple Bible believing Christian; a Protestant even. As someone submitted to Jesus as Lord, I am going to want to hear from my Lord alone. If He has made a way for that to happen; if He has given me capacity in union with Himself by the Holy Spirit to participate in the Self-knowledge of God, then I am going to seek that first. Natural theology is not coherent with this aim of mine as a Christian. Natural theology, as we have been observing, says that the Christian person can borrow concepts from unbelievers in order to construct a concept of godness that ostensibly allows the Christian to better proximate who God is. But why does the Christian need to rely on people who are of the spirit of the anti-Christ (cf. I Jn 4) in order to articulate a doctrine of God that seems palatable for the Christian consumption and witness?
Interestingly, my posts come with an air of academia; primarily because I interact with what most people would consider to be academic Christian theology. But if you dig in what you will find is that my opposition to natural theology (itself a technical category of academic Christian theology) is an attempt to thwart the ‘school theology’ that so many evangelical theologians are taken with these days. If the average Christian (even average Calvinists) were to read the highly speculative maneuvers these evangelicals are engaging with, as far as their attempt to retrieve the past and its theologians, it would probably become clearer to you why I am so opposed to natural theology. I am not opposed to ‘higher theological learning,’ clearly, but I am opposed to theological learning that is unnecessarily speculative, philosophical, and technical to the point of breaking. When theologians presume that they have the right to simply start talking about God’s inner-life, and their only access to that life, at a categorical level, is through the categories that pagan philosophers have given them, this is when I object with vigor! And this is what natural theologians do; they base their access to God in abstraction (abstracto), and not in the concrete (concreto) of God’s Self-revelation in Jesus Christ. In principle, I consider natural theology anti-Christ because, as noted, it relies on unbelievers’ thought conceptions in order to access and make known the very inner-life of God.
If you sense a modicum of anti-metaphysics, or what some have called ‘postmetaphysics’ in my misgivings with natural theology, you’d be onto something. Unfortunately, some will see my aversion to speculative theologies, and simply write it off as an uncritical commitment to the devilish mode of so called ‘modern theology.’ But the reality is, is that the ‘faith of the Bible’ comes to us in the flesh and soil of Holy Scripture’s witness of God come among humanity. The Bible is not a metaphysical book, as far as the reality it witnesses to, instead it presents us with a God who presents Himself to us in straw of the stable, the sands of Egypt, and upon the blood-soaked wood of the cross. The character of the biblical witness of God is not a metaphysical, speculative, abstract one; instead, the witness of Scripture is always a concrete one. This is why, as a simple Bible believing Protestant Christian, I reject natural theology, and other speculative modes of theology, that presume to think and speak God from the pagan sector of thought that reject Scripture as the fundamental source for contact with God as that is given reality in and through the face (prosopon) of Christ (solus Christus).
This is why people like Martin Luther, John Calvin (at various points of interest), Karl Barth, Thomas Torrance, Irenaeus, Athanasius, and a host of others are so appealing to me. Surely, some, more than others evince the character of theological endeavor I think the Christian should be taken with. But what they all have in common is a ferocious focus on Christ as the key. Some contemporary theologians think that Christology is simply one aspect of the whole systematic or Christian Dogmatic package; but again, these folks, a priori, have already committed themselves to some form of speculative, if not natural, theology. They are able to speak of Christ as one aspect of the whole theological project because they have some foreign (to Scripture) basis as the way they take towards God. For them, and because of this alien basis, they can speak of Christology as a piece of the theological puzzle; but not understand it as the cornerstone.
So, theological conferences, theological university educations and programs will continue to develop all around the ceaseless speculations of the theologians. The smarter the theologian the more access his or her students have to God. But this is the point or end of speculative and natural theology: it becomes focused on the wits and imaginations of the theologians. The cornerstone is not principially Christ in these theologies, the cornerstone is the theologian’s ability to speculate and imagine more altitudinally than others; and so in our pursuit of knowledge of God we become reliant on the speculative or natural theologian rather than Christ. You can see maybe better why I become so animated by this fundamental issue as it relates to the Christian’s pursuit of the Holy and Living God.
Bobby – I tremble as I write this (in fear of aligning myself with anti-christ(!)) – But having read and pondered your previous post and this one as well – I find myself coming to very different (and I hope appreciably nuanced) conclusions…
You are far the better and more studious theologian than I (if I can even qualify for the appellation even in amateurish terms) – but I just see some of this in such a different light…
It seems to me that you (and Barth?) fail to appreciate the all pervasive ‘Cosmic’ (to borrow a dangerous term) reality of Christ and His relationship to all creation – and focus solely on the historic revelation in the person of Jesus the Christ. Colossians 1 (among others passage like Hebrews 1) unequivocally bear witness to this wonderful aspect of reality/creation.
Frankly your reaction seems a bit reactionary – reminding me of Augustine’s and Luther’s (at least you are in good company!) over-correcting responses (in my opinion) to e.g. Pelagius (for the former) and the Jews (for the latter).
Several passages seem (on the face of it) to stand in direct tension to what you propose –
e.g. the elusive allusion to Psalm 19 in Romans 10:18 where Paul seems to be saying that (somehow) even the heavens themselves speak the “word of Christ”.
Or – (not surprisingly) the strong affirmation of a common knowledge of God’s “eternal power and divine nature”..
Or – most especially the fact that Paul has apparently NO qualms with recognizing and acknowledging that the pagan Athenians (and at least some of their poet/philosophers) have some kind of valid, real knowledge of God – “in whom we live and move and have our being”!
We SWIM in the divine reality of God’s Being – so how is it that we (even in our sinful state) have NO knowledge of God – or, even more specifically of Christ?
It could be argued that every human being that ever has or ever will live experiences the reality of Christ – and this experience must produce some form of at least tacit knowledge – “For of his fullness we all received, and grace for grace.” John 1:16.
But – of course – the intimate, filial knowledge of God we can never come to apart from embracing the Gospel of Jesus Christ – and the regenerative transformation that the Holy Spirit brings. But – i would contend – all the above is the framework or foundation in which this particular and salvific revelation occurs.
Having said all of this – please know that (as best I understand your contention) I fully agree that mere human philosophical speculation can never lead us to the knowledge of the Truth. But – where I guess I strongly disagree is that neither reality nor creation are ‘neutered’ – that, in fact, they would instantly cease to exist were it not for Christ – the Logos – who holds it all together. And so the whole of it is shot through with the reality, presence and Glory of God such that it should not surprise us that here and there even the pagans in their groping after God stumble upon some truth and knowledge of God that is worthy to be acknowledged and affirmed even by so great an Apostle as Paul!
And this is why one must almost have to adopt a kind of dualistic perspective of reality in order for your reaction to ‘natural theology’ to make sense – and I know how strongly opposed to any form of Cartesian dualism T.F was!
Finally – it seems to me that even with Torrance and Barth – there are (not surprisingly with the dialectical approach) certain ‘inconsistencies’ on the idea of ‘natural theology’ – let alone ‘epistemology’. Obviously Barth is known for his loud ‘Nein!’ – but, as Donald Bloesch suggests,
‘To be sure, Barth denies the validity of a natural knowledge of God. At the same time he insists that all people by virtue of being in Christ have an awareness of the love and gracious presence of God. What Barth denies with the one hand he seems to accept with the other. We cannot on our own come to a true knowledge of God, but when have access to a general knowledge of divine reality give by the universal Christ.” (Jesus the Victor, p.76)z
Well – enough (and probably too much) said. I hope I haven’t missed your point entirely – and, consequently, misrepresented your views here. I do sincerely wish you the very best, Bobby – and genuinely thank you for thinking about and writing even in a provocative way about these critically important issues.
Peace and Blessing in Christ Jesus!
wayne
Wayne,
I don’t think Bloesch is all the accurate in his critique (I read that book of his years ago, and while good he was upsetting in some of the ways he characterized Barth’s theology).
As far as the cosmic reality, I don’t really think this is the case at all; ie I mean I don’t think I underappreciate that at all. For Barth his doctrine of election and resurrection actually curtails your concern quite heavily there—I’ll link a couple of blog posts later on that. With TFT he is more in step with the Logoi theology of the patristics and someone like Maximus the Confessor, not to mention St Ephrem the Syrian (I also have posts on that). But what I am referring to is a theological ontology that starts fully in God’s explicit self revelation in Christ; this is where a doctrine of recreation impinges on epistemology—this is what Apocalyptic Theology is about and the subversive grace of God enacts in Christ—again, I have many posts on these things.
The charge of Barth’s and my focus on a historicist Christ is a common but misguided critique of Barth. Paul Molnar deflates that critique very nicely (I’ll link later). But you are right to notice that a focus on Christ’s mediation of total knowledge of God displaces the possibility for any sort of dualistic or a priori styled knowledge of God from the get-go. One thing your response doesn’t really respond to is the problem of placing an abstract creation supposedly robust and open for knowledge before that knowledge is given particularly in Christ. It seems as if you simply presuppose a Christian view of the creation without the Christ in order to provide a foundation for knowledge of God. But this is to put the cart before the horse in a dogmatic sense.
The Athenian situation is somewhat unhelpful since it requires your position a priori before we interpret the way you are. IOW, I could just as easily read Paul there from the doctrine of creation that Barth’s doctrine of election provides for—which takes us back to Bloesch’s sort of strange conclusion about what Barth is seemingly doing (I will come back later and respond to that more fully).
But the biggest problem your view has, I think, is that you borrow CHRISTian premises for your theory of knowledge before grounding them in Christ; which is actually pretty circular. This has been part of my critique.
And in re to my last post: I don’t think you have dealt adequately with the way Christian theology has developed in many ways, as that has taken shape by some theologians grounding their thinking of God in the categories provided for by unbelievers. I am pushing for a principled Christian theology that moves away from doing that and one that intentionally works from Christ alone as Mediator.
One more thing: Barth works from an actualist perspective. So the idea is that what is given by God for knowledge of Him, for the Christian, is all that there is. There is no space for negative theology or speculation about who God is. There simply is God’s Self-givenness in Christ. And this has radical consequences for our capacity to know God in a Kingdom that is solely regulated by faith not sight. You seem to want to have a kingdom regulated first by sight then attenuated by faith. I don’t see how that gives us a consistently Christian theology whatsoever.
I appreciate your tone, btw, Wayne. I guess I’m youngish, but I’m actually a solid 45 and have been doing this for awhile ;). I’ll come over to your blog and respond a bit as well. But first some shut-eye.
Thanks for even caring about giving me a response, Bobby – and I meant no disrespect by the use of “young” – oh how I wish I were still 45! I welcome your comments on my blog! Thanks!
I’ll be there later, Wayne. Working the graveyard schedule right now. Need sleep 🙂
Wayne, here are some posts: https://growrag.wordpress.com/2016/10/08/how-do-we-know-god-the-analogy-of-being-strained-through-david-bentley-hart-and-karl-barth/
https://growrag.wordpress.com/2016/09/05/the-doctrine-of-re-creation-or-resurrection-in-christ-as-the-foundation-for-everything-in-the-theologies-of-barth-and-torrance/