Just so you don’t think I am paranoid or something — in regards to those who continually bad-mouth Torrance and his “Scottish Theology” — let me quote something from Robert Letham in his new book: The Westminster Assembly (Kevin Davis has already done a fine job highlighting
some deficiency with Letham’s critique of Torrance). Letham is basically describing the nature of Torrance’s critique of “Covenant Theology,” and the shallowness that he evinces in so doing:
The criticisms of T. F. Torrance in his Scottish Theology are pertinent at this point. We will address them more directly in chapter 6. Torrance has a programmatic, ideological opposition to federal theology. He regards the development of covenant theology in the seventeenth century as a distortion of the earlier, pristine theology of Calvin, Knox, and the Scots Confession. Torrance reserves his opporobium for the Westminster Confession and says little about the Larger Catechism, which takes a rather different approach and obviates many of the alleged deficiencies he highlights. His comments about the Trinity in the Confession are well-taken. He deprecates its subordinate appearance. It is unfortunate, I agree, that the Trinity is not considered until WCF 2.3. However, Torrance does not mention that the Larger Catechism has a strongly Trinitarian doctrine of Scripture (LC 1-6). He does not even begin to consider the relationship of the Assembly to the Thirty-Nine Articles. As we have noted, the chapter in the Confession on God and the Holy Trinity is simply an expansion of the first article of the Thirty-Nine Articles (see Excursus 1), which dated from a time when Torrance claims that a dynamic Christocentric theology prevailed. Furthermore, he imposes on the Assembly the idea of a controlling central dogma — the dual framework of a covenant of works and a covenant of grace — whereas the idea of central dogmas only emerged in the nineteenth century, among German scholars, and was far from the minds of the Westminster divines. (Robert Letham,”The Westminster Assembly: Reading Its Theology In Historical Context,” 85)
1)Β Click Kevin Davis’ name, above, for a fine discussion on Letham’s point on the realtion between the WCF and LC.
2) Letham’s point on the Thirty-Nine Articles juxtaposed with the Westminster Confession of Faith is also, well-taken; nevertheless, this still remains a glaring problem for the WCF as it identifies a methodology and order of thought that is less than desirable relative to its emphasis upon a Trinitarian Doctrine of God.
3) Letham’s problem with the imposition of a central dogma (the usual one being that the Westminsters read God through a rigid predestinarian system of thought, inter-locking through a logical-causal system of decrees) is indeed something to be wary of — viz. we should want to avoid anachronistic reasoning in order to categorize thinking to our own terms and our own concerns. But, the so called “centraldogma” should not be totally jettisoned based upon its origin in linear history; if in fact it can be demonstrated that certain “dogmas” dominated trains of thought in the past. In fact Letham himself admits that the Westminster ‘divines’ were operating from largely exegetical and pastoral concerns; and that what in fact shaped the “order” of their thinking was the order of “revelation” or Scripture itself. I do not think it is a stretch at all to say that as a result certain themes emerged (like predestination and election) that served to shape the way these divines thought and talked about God (there is no doubt that the way the WCF Assembly articulated their exegetical work was through Aristotelian causal language which necessarily brought the kind of form to their work that Torrance sought to identify, describe, critique, and constructively overcome through his appeal to certain Scottish theologians of the era). While I do agree that ‘centraldogmas’ should not be emphasized, per se; if the “material” critique that those so called ‘centraldogmas’ symbolize fit the critique, then I think it is too quick to assume that this approach has no conceptual merit that needs to be dealt with (which is what Letham assumes).
4) Most curious to me, though, is Letham’s point on the Covenant of Works and Grace; and Torrance’s critique of this whole paradigm that was present in both the WCF and Larger Catechism. Letham wants to say that Torrance’s critique was un-founded at this point (back in chptr. 5 where I take the quote from above), and that there was much diversity amongst the ‘orthodox Reformed’ theologians on this issue; that in fact it was not ‘as present’ as Torrance would have us believe, and thus Torrance’s critique of these divines is ‘shibboleth’. Letham surveys, in great detail (in chaptr. 10) the diversity amongst these theologians upon this salient point of a Covenant of Works and its programmatic abscense in much of the development leading up to the Westminster Assembly. But then in Chapter 11, Letham says this:
WCF 7.2 introduces the covenant of works, made by God with man before the fall. This is the first major confessional document in which this covenant is expressly mentioned. In it, God promised life to Adam and in him to his posterity on condition of perfect obedience. Hence, in LC 20 the covenant is called the covenant of life, focusing on the promise held out to Adam. The term covenant of works draws attention instead to the means by which Adam was to attain the promise. The condition expressed in LC 20 is personal, perfect, and perpetual obedience. In short, obedience was to be sustained for an unspecified period of time, upon the completion of which life would result in accordance with God’s promise. (Letham, 226)
Letham cannot understand why Torrance would critique the ‘Assembly’ for holding to a ‘centraldogma’ — like a ‘dual covenant of works and grace’ — that the Assembly never held, since this is only a methodological straw man read back from the 19th and 20th centuries upon these divines. But, Letham contradicts himself; quite clearly, in fact. He wants to say that there was diversity on “Covenant theology” and its development, thus Torrance goes astray in his critique of ‘orthodox Reformed’ theology at this point. Yet, Torrance’s critique was of the ‘Confession’ itself; which by Letham’s own admission, the WCF is “the first major confessional document in which this covenant is expressly mentioned.”
There are some other faux-pauxs in Letham’s critique of Torrance. In the main, he misses the crux of Torrance’s primary critique of Westminster theology; the critique that Torrance makes over and again in his book “Scottish Theology,” the critique that he finds in Scottish theologians contemporaneous with the Westminster ‘divines’. This is another failure on Letham’s part, Torrance certainly does have an aversion to ‘federal covenant theology’; but Torrance grounds his critique — in his book “Scottish Theology” — in voices that are present at the same time that the Westminster Assembly convened. What would give Letham’s diatribe against Torrance some force, is if Letham challenged Torrance’s reconstruction and interpretation of the various Scottish theologians whom Torrance engages and uses to highlight similar problems that the so called 19th and 20th century dogmaticians have marshalled through their ‘centraldogmas’ towards Westminster theology. In other words, either Torrance is playing fast and loose with “his Scottish theologians” (again just to substantiate his critique of the Westminsters); or, he has identified something that Letham has failed to, and that is that the “centraldogmatists” have a consonant and correlative voice found in these ‘Scottish Theologians’Β — grounded in the history.
PS. This is not even to mention the fact that there were other andΒ alternative voices amongst “Calvinist” and Reformed theologians of this era; voices that were as anti-Westminster theology as the ‘Scots’ that Torrance develops in his book “Scottish Theology”. Letham would do well to take a look at Janice Knight’s book: Orthodoxies in Massachusetts: Rereading American Puritanism.Β This book has been out for quite a few years now, and it makes the same critique, in many ways that Torrance and the so called “older scholarship” (the “centraldogmatists”) have made; albeit from a different vantage point. People like Muller,Β R. Scott Clark, Letham et al. have completely ignored her scholarship in this area; so you tell me, who is driven by an ideological agenda? Is it those who follow Torrance (and crew), or maybe it is Muller/LethamΒ & co. who have a certain agenda? We might as well be completely honest . . .
Pingback: If Jonathan Edwards, then Unitarian Universalism? « "I am the King's Man."